Cigar Ratings & Reviews

#nowsmoking: Aganorsa Guardian of the Farm Nightwatch JJ

Reading Time: 4 minutes

#nowsmoking: Aganorsa Guardian of the Farm Nightwatch JJ (5 1/2″ x 50)

Aganorsa Guardian of the Farm Nightwatch Cigar Review – JJ (Robusto)

Factory: Fabrica Aganorsa Leaf – Estelí Nicaragua
Strength: Medium-Full
Size: 5½” x 50, Box-pressed Robusto
Wrapper: Nicaraguan Jalapa Corojo Shade Grown Maduro
Binder: Jalapa Corojo
Filler: Corojo and Criollo from Estelí and Jalapa

#nowsmoking aganorsa guardian of the farm nightwatch jj cigar review at Famous Smoke Shop

Where It’s At

First, give me the back story. . .

The original Guardian of the Farm selection was a collaborative effort between Kyle Gellis of Warped Cigars and Max Fernández of Aganorsa Leaf. The line debuted in 2016 as a Nicaraguan puro that featured a Nicaraguan Corojo wrapper. Nightwatch differs in that it is a solo project, created by Max Fernández himself, and boasts a Nicaraguan Corojo Maduro wrapper from Jalapa, which is shade grown.

The all-Nicaraguan blend is said to be “more intense” than its 2016 predecessor, and uses only tobaccos grown by Aganorsa Leaf. The Corojo binder is from Jalapa while the filler is a mix of Corojo and Criollo tobaccos grown in Estelí and Jalapa. These components are covered by a dark, proprietary Corojo Maduro wrapper that was grown under shade tents in Jalapa.

According to the company’s press release, Max summed-up the cigar as follows: “To make a second blend for Guardian of the Farm and our loyal dogs is a blessing. Every dog, whether it is one of ours or your own, is commemorated with this cigar.”

#nowsmoking Aganorsa Guardian of the Farm Nightwatch JJ cigar review closeup
#nowsmoking @famoussmokeshop: The Guardian of the Farm Nightwatch JJ is a box-pressed Nicaraguan puro offering well-balanced flavors of earth, leather, cocoa, and espresso with a medium-full body and strength.

Let’s talk construction. How well is it made?

Solid, with a sharp, Cuban-style box-pressing, and a partially closed foot, which helps it light more easily. The Corojo wrapper is spotless, and features two bands – a white and gold “Guardian of the Farm” band with the face of a guard dog, plus a secondary maroon band that specifies it’s from the “Nightwatch” selection and the Aganorsa Leaf marque.

The wrapper offers a barnyard aroma, and the cold draw had a light leathery and cocoa note.

So, how does it smoke?

Beautifully. The smoke is creamy, dense, and reveals initial flavors of leather, cocoa, and a note of pepper. The JJ also rounds-out very quickly leaving a little pepper on the finish. All of the flavors were evenly balanced and well-defined.

#nowsmoking aganorsa guardian of the farm nightwatch jj cigar review by Kevin Beck and Gary Korb

What are the primary flavor notes?

Earth, leather, white pepper, espresso coffee, and cocoa. The retrohale offered little additional flavor, and was impressively smooth showing no signs of the usual pepper. As to the peppery notes, they faded from the main mix in the second act, which was also much creamier and chocolatey.

The third act remained creamy, well-balanced, and seemed to get even sweeter, as a note of espresso leaked in. In the last two inches, earthier notes emerged, and the sweetness turned bittersweet like dark chocolate, but the cigar remained cool, balanced, and flavorful right down to the nub.

So, is it complex?

Yes. The Guardian of the Farm Nightwatch JJ didn’t present any stunning changeups, but some of the more noticeable transitions were the pepper fading at the midsection, some increased sweetness later on, and the darker, earthier notes in the final act.

#nowsmoking Aganorsa Guardian of the Farm Nightwatch JJ cigar review by Kevin Beck

What drinks can I pair with it?

Coffee was a natural, but for harder drinks, Kevin suggested bourbon (he prefers Bulleit), while I thought a good rum like Flor de Caña would also make a good pairing. Reason being, the JJ has a very Cubanesque quality which goes well with both. Wine drinkers might want to go for a vintage Shiraz or Spanish Rioja.

(For more cigar pairing ideas, see our cigar pairing guide.)

Tell me who this cigar is for. 

Most avid cigar smokers. The medium-full body and complexity may be wasted on new cigar smokers, but the cigar is exceptionally smooth and creamy, so I wouldn’t rule it out. But for the more experienced, the cigar lives up to its Aganorsa Leaf rep delivering plenty of rich flavor and just the right amount of body and strength.   

#nowsmoking Aganorsa Guardian of the Farm Nightwatch JJ cigar review by Gary Korb

Bottom line: Is it humidor worthy?

Absolutely. While also coming at a fair price considering it’s under $10 (at press time) and presented in boxes of 25 cigars. This is a cigar that you can smoke just about every day, so it’s also a very box worthy cigar.

Suffice it to say. . .when I was done smoking the Guardian of the Farm Nightwatch JJ, I wanted another almost immediately.


#cigaradvisor #cigar #cigars #cigarlife #cigarlifestyle #cigarsociety #cigarporn #cigarreviews #cigarphotography #botl #sotl #nowsmoking #menwhosmoke #thecigarculture #relax #luxury #ultimateluxury #luxurylifestyle #luxury #gooddeal #aganorsaleaf #guardianofthefarm #aganorsacigar #boxworthy #cigarbible

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor top 10 cigar tins - cover

Top Ten Cigarillo & Small Cigar Tins

Reading Time: 6 minutes Are bigger cigars robbing you of valuable session time and getting left unfinished? Then it’s time to call in the Tin Stars—cigarillos & small cigars that offer great taste in a more compact smoke. Here are 10 of the best!

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review h. upmann 1844 barbier - cover

#NowSmoking: H. Upmann 1844 Special Edition Barbier

Reading Time: 3 minutes Our Cigar Advisor’s review of H. Upmann 1844 Special Edition Barbier Belicoso comes to life through intertwining flavors of mild pepper, creamy undertones, and an earthy ebb and flow. Immerse yourself in the H. Upmann barber pole’s twisted melody, where every puff unveils an orchestra of excellence.

Read More
cigar advisor news – drew estate introduces innovative new acid kubariety 3 packs - release – cover

Cigar News: Drew Estate Introduces Innovative New Acid Kubariety 3-Packs

Acid KUBARIETY 3-packs give adult cigar smokers a chance to experience the full Drew Estate product line by offering 3 cigars for the price of two.
Read More
Top New Cigars Sept 13 2021 Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (Sept 13 2021)

Reading Time: 3 minutes It’s the perfect time of year—I call it cigar season. Check out these new cigar arrivals from AJ Fernandez and AVO – along with a treat from Erik Espinosa!

Read More