Cigar Ratings & Reviews

#NowSmoking Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection

Reading Time: 5 minutes

#NowSmoking Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection Scherzo Cigar Review

Factory: Tabacalera AJ Fernandez – Estelí, Nicaragua
Size: 5½”x 55 Robusto Grande
Strength: Medium – Full
Wrapper: Nicaraguan Hybrid
Binder & Filler: Nicaraguan Cuban seed including Pelo de Oro

Presented in boxes of 10

cigar advisor nowsmoking cigar review aging room rare collection scherzo at famous smoke shop

The Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection Cigars Back Story

The Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection marks another blending collaboration between Tabacalera USA Head of Product Capability, Rafael Nodal and A.J. Fernandez. Rolled in three voluptuous sizes and finished with pig-tail caps, the Aging Room Rare Collection cigars are Nicaraguan puros blended with specially selected rare tobaccos; in particular, Pelo de Oro, a leaf that’s especially challenging to grow and cure successfully (more on this tobacco below), and a Nicaraguan hybrid wrapper developed by A.J. Fernandez.

cigar advisor nowsmoking cigar review aging room rare collection set up of cigars on box

The first new line extension from Aging Room Cigars in more than a year, Nodal indicated that this debut marks the first of several Rare Collection projects the company plans to release. The objective of the series is to offer small batch runs based on the availability of rare and superbly well-aged tobaccos.

The line is presented in three sizes:

Festivo (4½”x52)
Scherzo (5½”x55)
Vivase (6”x60)

“This is not just an updated cigar,” said Nodal who’s Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro took Aficionado’s “Cigar of the Year” honors in 2019. “With the Rare Collection, we are offering adult consumers a complex, medium-full bodied, Nicaraguan blend containing some of the rarest and most well-aged tobaccos of any cigar we’ve released to date.”

 

About Pelo de Oro Tobacco

Pelo de Oro is a rare type of tobacco that was once used for cigar wrappers. Today, the leaf is considered by most to be one of the toughest crops to grow in any area. Hearty, flavorful and even a bit sweet, the tobacco was a favorite among the workers who grew and cured the plant in the early-to-mid 20th century. Pelo de Oro translates from Spanish to “golden hair,” a call to the bold color that glistens on a properly refined leaf. Pelo de Oro is both flavorful and beautiful but gains its notoriety from being difficult to harvest. The plant is extremely susceptible to molds and other agricultural diseases and is infrequently employed in today’s cigar landscape. Though phased out of Cuban fields, and castoff by many in the cigar industry due to the difficulty of successfully growing large, healthy batches, it’s therein which lies the challenge to others. The cigar industry is one built on tradition and heritage, and some cigar masters have refused to do-away with the golden gem entirely.

Source: https://www.montecristosocialclub.com

 

The Basics At-a-Glance

Construction: Deftly constructed and packed to the gills giving this plump Robusto added weight, while feeling balanced in the hand. The rolling is seamless and the pigtail cap is textbook. The hybrid wrapper is rich in color, oily, and shows a fair amount of the vein structure, which I found attractive.
Cold Draw: Just slightly firm with a distinctive leathery flavor.
Base flavors: Earth, leather, baking spices, brown sugar, oak, black pepper.
Aroma: Leathery.
Burn & Ash: Excellent. Even throughout, revealing firm grey ashes.

cigar advisor nowsmoking cigar reviewe aging room rare collection pigtailed head
#nowsmoking @famoussmokeshop: Attractively oily, and well-packed, the Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection Scherzo offers a refined, medium-full smoke with flavors of earth, leather, baking spices, brown sugar, oak, and notes of black pepper on the finish. Highly complex.

 

Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection Scherzo Cigar Review – Act I

cigar advisor nowsmoking cigar review aging room rare collection act 1

I expected the first few puffs to be strong and peppery, but instead I got more of a citrusy tanginess with a peppery finish. The pepper settled down quite quickly imparting a mostly earthy smoke with some of that tanginess remaining. The cigar also left a fresh, clean sensation on my palate.

At about the first inch, some sweet tobacco notes arrived followed by a mix of earth, citrus tanginess, and sweet tobacco. The body was dead-center medium and equally medium in strength. Nutmeg arrived at this juncture and black pepper continues to linger, albeit lightly, on the finish. The burn was also impressive.

 

Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection Scherzo Cigar Review – Act II

cigar advisor nowsmoking cigar review aging room rare collection act 2

Leathery notes returned, even in the aroma, with a bit more black pepper on the finish. The body and strength remained in the medium realm as baking spices began to arrive. The Scherzo was demonstrating excellent balance, smoothness, and an impressive set of flavors.

Further into the second act, more sweetness emerged in what I speculated was molasses or brown sugar. Additionally, everything had settled into a very smooth and creamy smoke with all the flavors in harmony.

 

Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection Scherzo Cigar Review – Act III

cigar advisor nowsmoking cigar review aging room rare collection act 3

Two flavors that dominated at this point were baking spices and what I had finally determined was brown sugar. Everything was hitting on all cylinders as the body shifted into full gear and a note of oak entered the fray. By now, my Scherzo was one big chewy mix of earth, leather, oak, baking spices, and brown sugar.

In the last two inches the strength increased to spot-on full and the flavors became sharper. The sugary sweetness just barely eked out from the mixture other flavors, and that’s about where I left it.

 

What whiskey pairs well with the Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection Scherzo?

An excellent Añejo Rum—try Flor de Caña from Nicaragua—or smoke it with Aging Room’s recommendation, a Cuba Libre. No doubt a good bourbon will also do the trick. For some other excellent cigar pairings, see our Cigar & Spirit pairing guide.

 

Is the Aging Room by Rafael Nodal Rare Collection Scherzo cigar worth smoking?

cigar advisor nowsmoking cigar review aging room rare collection setup 2 with cigar on whiskey stave in front of rocks glass

Without a doubt. The Scherzo was also one of the most complex cigars I’ve smoked in the past several months. So, not only do I recommend smoking it at a time when you can devote some quality time to it, it’s also a cigar you want to smoke very patiently or you may miss a number of its more refined points. There’s more going on in this cigar than you may realize at first puff. The other thing I liked about this cigar was that it was full, yet smooth without being overpowering or leaving me with some headiness.

As to who it’s for, the Aging Room Rare Collection Scherzo may be a little much for new cigar smokers. Plus, it’s upscale price could be a yellow flag for newbs, but I thought it was worth it. Bravo to Rafael and A.J. for another stellar performance.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for CigarAdvisor.com since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor news-epc encore el futuro cigar release-cover photo

CIGAR NEWS: E.P. Carrillo Renews Encore Line with El Futuro Cigar

Reading Time: 2 minutes E.P. Carrillo Cigars is following one of its best acts, the 96-rated (and “2018 Cigar of the Year”) Encore Majestic, with a new size: the EPC Encore El Futuro. Rolled to a true 5×50 Robusto, El Futuro certainly shows great promise. Learn more here.

Read More
cigar advisor avo caribe cigar panel review cover

CA REVIEW PANEL: AVO SYNCRO TORO CIGAR REVIEW (VIDEO)

Reading Time: 6 minutes Avo Syncro Caribe is the fourth installment in Avo’s artisanal line extension, and the Panel offers their review of the Avo Syncro Caribe Toro. Capped by a Dominican wrapper, there are a number of things that make this particular blend unique. For the entire story, watch now.

Read More
top new cigars august 16 2021 cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (August 16 2021)

Reading Time: 3 minutes You better not be hitting the stadium pregame without some tasty smokes. This edition of Top New cigars has the latest from E.P. Carrillo, HVC, and H. Upmann to help take your tailgate herf to the next level!

Read More
Macanudo Inspirado Red cigar review MWC CACover

My Weekend Cigar: May 14, 2018 – Macanudo Inspirado Red Robusto

Macanudo breaks out of its comfort zone and throws a smooth, but full-bodied fiesta! See our quick Weekend Cigar review of the Macanudo Inspirado Red Robusto Box Pressed, and get the tasting notes NOW to see why "long aged tobaccos can tame even the boldest blend." It may just change your mind about this classic brand.
Read More