Cigar Ratings & Reviews

#nowsmoking: Bolivar Cofradia Lost and Found

Reading Time: 5 minutes

#nowsmoking Bolivar Cofradia Lost and Found Cigar Review (Video)

Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found EMS Robusto – Cigar Details

Factory: HATSA – Danlí, Honduras
Size: 5”x54
Strength: Medium-Full
Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sumatra
Binder: Connecticut Broadleaf
Filler: Dominican, Honduran, Nicaraguan

Presented in 5-packs and singles.


The Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found Cigars Back Story

The Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found selection is a collaborative, limited production effort between Forged Cigar Co. and Robert Caldwell’s Lost & Found series for the Bolivar Cofradia cigars brand.

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review Bolivar Cofradia Lost and Found - cigars and red wine on a table top

Last year, STG’s new business development manager, Justin Andrews, and Robert Caldwell of “The King is Dead” cigars fame, among numerous others, visited the historic HATSA cigar factory in Danlí, Honduras. During their visit Justin and Robert happened upon two bales of wrapper tobacco that sparked their interest. One bale was Connecticut Broadleaf, the other, Ecuador Sumatra. Both bales indicated that the tobaccos had been aged five to eight years. It was then decided that each wrapper would be used for two new blends, respectively, and the Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found selection was born.

“I would have never imagined standing among a sea of bales at HATSA, knowing that any tobacco we wanted to blend with was available to Justin and me,” said Robert. “This collection represents the power of a strong collaboration.”

cigar advisor #nowsmoking Cigar Review Bolivar Cofradia Lost and Found - cigar and wine glass on a glass table top - at Famous Smoke Shop

When it came to blending, the Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found EMS (short for English Market Selection) would be rolled in the lighter Ecuador Sumatra wrapper while the practically black Connecticut Broadleaf would be used for the binder. In turn, Bolivar Lost & Found Oscuro would be rolled in the Connecticut Broadleaf and use the Ecuador Sumatra for the binder. However, both core blends would include Dominican, Honduran, and Nicaraguan fillers.

Each Lost & Found blend is rolled in two sizes: a 5×54 Robusto and a 6×54 Toro. In lieu of boxes, the cigars are packaged in 5-packs, which also help distinguish the Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found cigars from the mainline Bolivar Cofradia cigars.


The Basics

Construction: The cigar is well packed and neatly rolled. I found no soft spots along the cigar’s length. The cap on my sample was a little sloppy but it clipped well and issued an excellent draw.
Cold Draw: Tangy and very appealing. I thought it had a light orange peel flavor without the bitter peel taste.
Base flavors: Mostly earthy with notes of baking spices, tangy fruit, and molasses.
Aroma: Sharp.
Burn & Ash: Textbook. The burn was well paced and even revealing an almost white ash that was quite firm. The ashes fell in ¾-inch nuggets, on average.


Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found EMS Robusto Cigar Review – Act I

bolivar cofradia lost and found robusto act 1

The cigar took the flame easily and issued some interesting opening notes. I thought I detected a hint of licorice upfront but it was too faint to fully define. Once the cigar got going, I picked up a tangy fruit flavor and a cereal like note which, combined, reminded me of a cranberry bran muffin. Unfortunately, it didn’t last long.

The burn got off to a very even start and revealed a sharp cone after each ash tap. The smoke was mostly medium in body and pretty smooth with some light spice on the finish. By the time the cigar reached the midsection I got balanced flavors of baking spices, tangy fruit and a bit of earth that was bubbling under.


Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found EMS Robusto Cigar Review – Act II

bolivar cofradia lost and found robusto act 2

Some nice improvement in all aspects at this middle section. A molasses flavor appeared which gave the cigar a welcome sweetness while the earthiness rode shotgun. The cigar also continued to draw and burn in textbook form. However, as the cigar pushed toward the cusp of the final stage, the earthiness increased overtaking the molasses. The body was now more medium-full, but the strength remained medium.


Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found EMS Robusto Cigar Review – Act III

bolivar cofradia lost and found robusto act 3

At this point some sweet notes began to claw their way out, but the earthy taste was still leading the pack. The body had now shifted to full but hadn’t increased in strength. The cigar had also turned a little bitter telling me that I may be hitting on it a little too much. More time between draws helped lighten that up a bit and surprisingly brought out a little more of the molasses. With that the cigar ended happily.


What whiskey pairs well with the Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found EMS Robusto?

bolivar cofradia lost and found robusto cigar pairing

I think a gin & tonic, a mojito, or other mixed cocktails would go nicely with this cigar. Otherwise, you may want to consider a red wine like a Cabernet, or maybe even a Rosé. For more combinations, see our Cigar & Spirit pairing guide or Wine pairing guide.


Is the Bolivar Cofradia Lost & Found EMS Robusto cigar worth smoking?

cigar advisor #nowsmoking bolivar cofradia lost and found robusto cigar review nub

I was a little puzzled by this robusto, mainly because I wasn’t sure if it was supposed to be more complex or simply a good-natured anytime smoke with a lean set of flavors. I didn’t expect it to be as earthy as it turned out, but the tangy fruit, molasses and baking spices held my interest. Based on my experience, the quality of the cigar, and its affordable price, I’m going with good-natured, anytime smoke, which makes it accessible to cigar smokers at every level. That said, based on having smoked two Cofradia Lost & Found EMS Robustos, the second cigar (seen in the video), impressed me as being a little more complex than the first. Suffice it to say, I felt a little lost at first, but I found the cigar to be worth picking up and deciding for yourself.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor news – cao arcana mortal coil cigar returns as annual release - release - cover

Cigar News: CAO Arcana Mortal Coil Cigar Returns As Annual Release

Reading Time: 2 minutes Back by popular demand, CAO Cigars has just re-released the CAO Arcana Mortal Coil Toro for a second time. The signature filler in the blend is the “Andullo” fermented leaf that undergoes a rigorous process. Get the whole story here.

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review west tampa attic series - cover

#NowSmoking: West Tampa Tobacco Co. Attic Series

Reading Time: 3 minutes This week we’re reviewing the first release from the Attic Series, Attic, from West Tampa Tobacco Co. Out of the imagination of Rick Rodriguez, the Attic Series will feature blends that Rick’s kept all for himself over the last 30 years. Watch the review to see if Attic Series, Attic is worth a try!

Read More
cigar advisor panel review of weller by cohiba 2022 - cover

CA Review Panel: Weller by Cohiba 2022

Reading Time: 6 minutes The latest super-premium cigar, Weller by Cohiba 2022, is a collaboration between Buffalo Trace Distillery and Cohiba. Does the flavor match the price tag? That’s what the Advisors are aiming to answer. Click now to read their cigar review and see if it’s worth smoking!

Read More
nowsmoking CAO Zocalo Robusto cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: CAO Zocalo Robusto

Reading Time: 5 minutes Now in full production, CAO Zócalo is “more refined and nuanced than it appears,” making it a good end-of-the-day or after dinner cigar. Can you guess what Gary suggested to pair with it?

Read More