Cigar Ratings & Reviews

#nowsmoking: My Father La Promesa Petite

Reading Time: 4 minutes

#nowsmoking: My Father La Promesa Petite (4 1/2″ x 50)

My Father La Promesa Petite Cigar Review

Factory: My Father Cigars Factory, in Estelí, Nicaragua
Strength: Medium-Full
Size: 4½” x 50 Rothschild
Wrapper: Ecuador Habano Rosado Oscuro
Binder & Filler: Garcia Estate farm-grown Nicaraguan

#nowsmoking My Father La Promesa cigar review at Famous Smoke Shop

Where It’s At

First, give me the back story. . .

Translated to “the promise,” the name for My Father La Promesa cigars comes from a promise Don José “Pepin” Garcia made to his family when he left Cuba alone in 2001. That promise was that he would honor his family and its tobacco heritage by being successful in the cigar industry outside of Cuba. Today, with the My Father Cigar Company having estate farms in Nicaragua, two cigar factories – one in Nicaragua, the other in Miami – and having received innumerable high rating scores for his cigars over the years, it’s safe to say that the promise has been aptly fulfilled.

#nowsmoking My Father La Promesa cigar review cigar in ashtray
#nowsmoking @famoussmokeshop: The My Father La Promesa Petite is a Rothschild-size cigar offering a well-balanced, medium-full mix of earthy notes, sweet spice, and bittersweet chocolate on a slightly pepper finish.

The My Father La Promesa selection debuted in 2016, but were made in very limited quantity. It wasn’t until 2018 that this selection became a regular production cigar. The highlight of the line is the stunning Ecuador Habano Rosado Oscuro wrapper. Most “Oscuros” tend to be very dark, almost black; yet, La Promesa’s wrapper – bordering on maduro – boasts an attractive reddish patina. The core blend is a diverse mix of binder and fillers grown on the Garcia family’s estate farms in Nicaragua. In addition to the My Father La Promesa Petite cigar reviewed here, they are also offered in four other sizes:

Let’s talk construction. How well is it made?

Perfectly. The Habano Rosado Oscuro wrapper has an attractive color, more of which is revealed when the two long bands and the pink silk foot band are removed. The skin is thick, smooth and beams with a rich rosy hue. Once clipped, the draw had just the right amount of pull, offering a wheaty, toasty and leathery flavor.

So, how does it smoke?

Beautifully. Once lit, the cigar offered plenty of dense, creamy smoke, and was impressively mellow in body and strength. A quick shot of pepper entered the mix, and almost as quickly rounded out to an earthier flavor with some leather, semi-sweetness, and a note of cedar. Even in the early part of the cigar, Humberto said it was “loaded with rich tobacco flavor.”

#nowsmoking My Father La Promesa cigar review by Gary Korb

At the midsection, the cigar moved to a more medium-full strength, offered a high volume of dense smoke, and retained its earthy base note, while sweet spice entered the fray finishing with a slight hint of pepper on the palate.

The retrohale had a woody-spicy component which both of us liked. The cigar also maintained excellent balance throughout, and by the last act, the mix shook-out as earthy, leathery, cedary, and bittersweet on the order of dark chocolate made with a very high cacao content.

What are the primary flavor notes?

Earth, leather, light pepper, cedar, sweet spices (nutmeg & cinnamon), sweet cream, bittersweet chocolate.

So, is it complex?

To tell the truth, I was enjoying this cigar so much I wasn’t paying much attention. But Humberto felt thought it was “very complex,” offering a number of sweet and sour-ish change-ups along the way.

#nowsmoking My Father La Promesa cigar review by Humberto Gonzalez

My observation, which could make the case for complexity, was how the cigar started out with earthiness, light pepper, and semi-sweet spiciness, then increased to a more sugary sweetness – like sweet cream – and finally, returned to earthy and bittersweet notes in the end.  

What drinks can I pair with it?

We agreed this cigar would be best enjoyed in the evening after dinner. Humberto thought a good single malt like the Macallan would do the trick, and I seconded that, too. However, since the La Promesa Petite had such a rich Nicaraguan character to it, I would go with a great Nicaraguan rum like Flor de Caña 12 year. Humberto disagreed on rum, but if you check the flavor properties of the Flor de Caña, you may agree with me.

(For more cigar pairing ideas, see our cigar pairing guide.)

#nowsmoking My Father La Promesa cigar review by Humberto Gonzalez and Gary Korb

Tell me who this cigar is for. 

I don’t think the My Father La Promesa Petit would be wasted on a new cigar smoker, especially someone who wants to sample one of the better My Father cigars. Plus, it’s far from overpowering in strength. In the hands of a more experienced cigar smoker, the deep, dark flavor of the Petit will certainly offer much more in terms of this cigar’s overall refinement.  

Bottom line: Is it humidor worthy? 

For sure. At under $8 a cigar (at press time), this cigar pays off in spades. It also lasts for close to an hour if not smoked too hurriedly. Moreover, the consistency and balance of flavors made every puff a treat for Humberto and me. I would say, at least start with a 5-pack.


#cigaradvisor #cigar #cigars #cigarlife #cigarlifestyle #cigarsociety #cigarporn #cigarreviews #cigarphotography #botl #sotl #nowsmoking #menwhosmoke #thecigarculture #relax #luxury #ultimateluxury #luxurylifestyle #luxury #gooddeal #cigarbible #myfathercigar #lapromesacigar

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor news - aganorsa leaf announces two new jfr lunatic cigars - release - cover

Cigar News: Aganorsa Leaf Announces Two New JFR Lunatic Cigars

Reading Time: 2 minutes If you already love Aganorsa Leaf’s affordably-priced JFR Lunatic Maduro cigars, get ready to enjoy two new vitolas based on popular demand. In addition to the two new cigars, Aganorsa is also adding a JFR Super Toro Fresh Pack. Learn more here.

Read More
cigar advisor panel review video of cao bx3 - cover

CA Review Panel: CAO BX3

Reading Time: 6 minutes Can CAO top their famed Brazilia with another Brazilian blend? Try saying that five times fast, and then pop in and check out our review to see if CAO BX3 passes the test.

Read More
cigar advisor news-epc encore el futuro cigar release-cover photo

CIGAR NEWS: E.P. Carrillo Renews Encore Line with El Futuro Cigar

Reading Time: 2 minutes E.P. Carrillo Cigars is following one of its best acts, the 96-rated (and “2018 Cigar of the Year”) Encore Majestic, with a new size: the EPC Encore El Futuro. Rolled to a true 5×50 Robusto, El Futuro certainly shows great promise. Learn more here.

Read More
music and cigars cigar advisor playlist Cigar Advisor Cover

The Cigar Advisor Playlist: Volume 5

Reading Time: 6 minutes Sink into your chair, turn the speakers up, and check out our ongoing, definitive guide to pairing cigars and music. Now playing: Volume 5 feat. Michael Giannini of Ventura Cigars.

Read More