Cigar Ratings & Reviews

#nowsmoking: Onyx Bold Nicaragua Toro

Reading Time: 4 minutes

#nowsmoking: Onyx Bold Nicaragua Toro Cigar Review 

Onyx Bold Nicaragua Cigar Review – Toro

Factory: Tabacalera AJ Fernandez – Estelí, Nicaragua 
Size: 6”x54 
Strength: Medium – Full 
Wrapper: Mexican San Andrés Maduro (aged 4 years) 
Binder & Filler: Nicaragua (aged 4 years) 
Presentation: Boxes of 20 cigars and 5-packs 

#nowsmoking Onyx Bold Nicaragua cigar review at Famous Smoke Shop

What’s the cigar’s back story. . 

In another classic brand line extension, Onyx Bold Nicaragua cigars have arrived with a blend that ‘dares to be bolder.’ And once again, Tabacalera USA’s Head of Product Capability, Rafael Nodal, and AJ Fernandez are at the wheel.  

cigar makers Rafael Nodal and AJ Fernandez working together
AJ Fernandez & Rafael Nodal (via Facebook)

“Onyx Bold is the much anticipated follow up to the award-winning Onyx Reserve, which boasted an impressive 94 cigar rating from Cigar Aficionado when it was first introduced, said RafaelHandmade at the AJ Fernandez factory in Nicaragua, it brings a meticulously fermented dark, San Andres wrapper that envelopes a unique blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos aged for more than four years.”  

The Evolution of Onyx Cigars

When Onyx Reserve was introduced in 2000, it was a Dominican-made cigar with a Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper, Nicaraguan binder, and a Dominican, Peruvian, and Nicaraguan filler core. One year later, the Onyx Reserve Mini Belicoso scored a “Classic” 94 points in Cigar Insiderwhich increased the brand’s popularity tenfold and earned it a very dedicated following. (When I first started working at Famous, I often remember Onyx Reserve being out of stock as a result.)  

Onyx Bold Nicaragua cigar review by John Swarr

Looking at the original Dominican version, that blend was, in one sense, a harbinger of the brand’s future, in that from the start Onyx leaned toward a Nicaraguan-forward blend, which has been fully realized with the release of the Onyx Estelí and Onyx Bold Nicaragua selections. In addition to being bolder in flavor, Onyx Reserve remains mostly box-pressed, while the other two are all parejo shapes  

Onyx Bold Nicaragua cigar review by Gary Korb

Moreover, Bold Nicaragua shouldn’t be confused with the Onyx Estelí Selección  No.1 I reviewed earlier this year. True, Onyx Estelí has a San Andrés wrapper and Nicaraguan filler, but it also has Honduran Criollo 99 filler and a Sumatra binder. 

Handcrafted in three sizesa 5×50 Robusto, 6×54 Toro, and a 6×60 Magnum, Onyx Bold Nicaragua is made for today’s cigar smoker’s palate which is geared toward more full-flavored blends made with Nicaraguan-grown tobaccos.  

Onyx Bold Nicaragua cigar and whiskey and box
#nowsmoking @famoussmokeshop: The Onyx Bold Nicaragua Toro offers a remarkably smooth, medium-full cigar that makes for a sweet, woody, spicy, and at times, curiously complex smoke.  

How well is the cigar made?  

Excellently. The wrapper has that classic, “basic black” color for which Onyx is known. The cigar was also well packed and finished with a well-made triple seam cap. The prelight draw was excellent, revealing some saltiness, a leathery note, woodiness and earth. The 6”x54 dimensions also felt comfortable in my hand.  

How does the cigar smoke?  

The smoke offers a sweet, earthy, and slightly peppery set of flavors out of the gate. It’s also smooth and creamy with a medium-body early on. By the first inch, the flavors continued to be mainly earthy, sweet, and spicy, and rounded-out nicely. As the Toro continued, the peppery spice seemed to have left, settling the cigar down to a very full-flavored and relaxing smoke. The burn was also outstanding, offering a very firm grey ash that I could tap off at my discretion.

onyx bold nicaragua cigar review part 1 construction and how it smokes

Moving into the midsection of the cigar, some spiciness returns, tips its hat, and exits, only to return again later on. Notes of strong coffee and a hint of dark chocolate entered the fray in the latter half, while the core flavors held steady and the smoke retained a very smooth and refined character. The wrapper appears to be a major contributor in terms of this cigar’s overall profile. And although the Toro lets loose more strength in the final act, it’s the wrapper that keeps it from going over the top.  

What is the cigar’s flavor profile?  

Onyx Bold Nicaragua cigar flavors

Rich, dark, and well-balanced with dominant flavors of sweet tobacco, wood, and peppery spice. Overall, the smoke is smooth, creamy, and medium to full in body with occasional flourishes of espresso and bittersweet chocolate.  

What drinks can I pair with this cigar besides coffee?  

Onyx Bold Nicaragua cigar and whiskey pairing

Being that the Onyx Bold Estelí has Nicaragua written all over it, I thought a good bourbon or Tennessee whiskey would make a nice match, so I went with Jack DanielGentleman Jack. The result was quite good, and the Jack wasn’t overly sweet either, which offered a nice balance between the flavors of both the cigar and the whiskey on the palate. The whiskey also seemed to reduce, and in some cases, even eliminate, the cigar’s peppery flavor.  

(Find more cigar and drink pairing combinations here.) 

Should I buy this cigar? 

Onyx Bold Nicaragua cigar smoked down to the nub

If you have a few notches on your gun belt in terms of experience, you’ll get the most from this blend, which is “bold,” but in a much more refined senseAlthough I was surprised AJ and Rafael didn’t go with an all-Nicaraguan leaf blend, the Mexican San Andrés wrapper was an excellent choiceIf you love bold, full-flavored cigars, or also happen to be among the Onyx devoted, the Onyx Bold Nicaragua will make a fine addition to your rotation. Plus, for the price point, it’s a pretty good value.  


#cigaradvisor #cigar #cigars #cigarlife #cigarlifestyle #cigarsociety #cigarporn #cigarreviews #cigarphotography #botl #sotl #NowSmoking #menwhosmoke #thecigarculture #relax #luxury #ultimateluxury #luxurylifestyle #luxury #gooddeal #smokeability #famous80 #onxyreserve #onyxboldcigar  #ajfernandezcigar 

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
1 year ago

Great article Gary

1 year ago

Already wanted to give it a try, but now I can not wait to get my hands on one.

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor master blenders christian eiroa of c.l.e. cigars - cover


Reading Time: 3 minutes This Master Blenders Series episode spotlights C.L.E. Cigar Company founder, Christian Eiroa. Growing up in a legendary cigar family, he’s learned from the best. Watch how he’s made it work and discover why there’s more to making cigars in Honduras than you thought.

Read More
cigar advisor panel review cover shot for la gloria cubana medio tiempo robusto

CA Review Panel: La Gloria Cubana Medio Tiempo Robusto Cigar Review (Video)

Reading Time: 7 minutes When added to the right combination of tobaccos, medio tiempo leaves provide additional layers of flavor and complexity to the smoke. That’s the concept behind the La Gloria Cubana Medio Tiempo cigars – a new full production lineup. And in this review of the La Gloria Cubana Medio Tiempo Robusto, the Cigar Advisor Review Panel gets a chance to taste if that’s the case in this artisanal style cigar.

Read More
Macanudo Insirado Brazilian Shade cigar review video Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Review Panel: Macanudo Inspirado Brazilian Shade Toro Cigar Review (Video)

Reading Time: 6 minutes A limited edition, with a shade wrapper grown in Brazil’s Bahia region—a big first for Macanudo, and part of a complex blend that also boasts a proprietary Dominican filler leaf. Watch now as the panel reveals what else makes it special.

Read More
Top 12 Best Rated Oliva cigars Cigar Advisor Cover

2021 CA Report: Top 12 Best Rated Oliva Cigars

Reading Time: 7 minutes Oliva cigars are very well regarded among their Nicaraguan peers. But which of their cigars would *you* call their best? See the top 12 must-smokes from Oliva, as chosen by Famous Smoke customers, plus a few of the reasons why they’re so popular.

Read More