Cigars 101

Should I Remove Cellophane from Cigars?

Reading Time: 4 minutes

It’s the undisputed heavyweight champion of cigar storage questions that we receive from cigar enthusiasts: whether to remove the cellophane from cigars before placing them in a humidor. Yes, there is a debate – which we’ll get into shortly – and both sides of the cello on/cello off dispute are passionate about their feelings on the matter. The reality is that the answer lies in-between…but before deciding whether you should leave the cellos on or off your cigars in a humidor, we should first define what cellophane is – because understanding cello will help to eliminate at least one myth about it.

What is Cellophane?

Cellophane is not plastic. It’s made from a byproduct of plant cell walls and vegetable fibers called cellulose. While it is waterproof, it’s also semi-permeable and allows water vapor to pass through it – so leaving your cigar’s cello on will not prevent it from receiving the humidity it needs to stay fresh. Confusing cellophane for plastic has led to many of the negative opinions you may have heard about cellophaned cigars…so at least we can check that one off, right out of the gate. Here’s more:

Cello On or Cello Off?

Are there justifiable reasons to keep it? There sure are. Or should you throw it away? You can do that, too. To help you decide, let’s explore the benefits of both worlds…

Benefits of Taking the Cello Off

While it doesn’t prevent humidity from reaching your smokes entirely, cellophane decreases the amount of moisture that your cigars do receive. Rehydrating cigars that are cellophaned takes a longer period of time, and that can play a role if you’re trying to fast-track the rejuvenation of a neglected stick. Additionally, cigars that are out of their cello sleeves will age faster than their cello-clad counterparts. If you’re the type of enthusiast who lets cigars sit for months or years before enjoyment, removing the cello might be right up your alley.

Another benefit of cellophane removal is the promotion of plume development. Plume is another hotly-debated topic in the cigar world – and it’s less common than the discussion might lead you to believe. Plume (also called “bloom”) is the result of the leaf’s naturally-occurring oils and sugars making their way to the surface of the cigar’s wrapper and crystallizing. If it happens, it’s only after years of aging; and while not every cigar ends up with this phenomenon, cellophane can hinder the process both physically as well as your ability to notice it visually. Plume advocates say it’s a sign that your cigar is in optimal condition for smoking.

Visual matters take me to the next benefit of cello removal. Let’s just be honest with ourselves: glistening cellos are not as aesthetically appealing as the cigar’s natural leaf wrappers themselves. There’s something about a naked cigar in a humidor that is inviting, whereas the plasticky look of cellophane is more industrial and generic. I suppose this could come down to subjectivity, but nobody ends up smoking the cello.

Last but certainly not least, without the cellophane, you can feel the texture of your cigar and smell its aroma unimpeded. You can roll the cigar between your fingers and listen for crackling that may indicate it is too dry, or more accurately feel if there are soft or hard spots down its length.

Benefits of Keeping The Cello On

Cellophane sleeves act as a layer of protection around the cigar that can help prevent it from damage, especially on the foot. It also protects your premium from dust and dirt that may find its way into your humidor through various means. If you’ve ever dropped a cigar on a hard surface that was not in its sleeve, it’s likely the cigar experienced a crack or tear in the wrapper – this is especially common with more delicate leaves such as Connecticut Shade or Cameroon. That makes the cello great for traveling, helping to protect your cigars from the unexpected bump, bounce or drop.

One of my favorite go-to reasons for keeping the cigar in its cello is that it acts as an automatic indicator for a well-aged cigar. Frequent a cigar lounge long enough, and you’ll probably hear the term yellow cello. Cigars that rest for a considerable period release their oils and sugars to the surface as they age; in turn, this process stains the cellophane a distinct yellow or orange tint. When held up to a light, you’ll notice this coloring mostly in the corners of the cellophane near the head when it’s just beginning to crop up, or the entire length of the sleeve when it’s been occurring for some time. When you see this effect, you know that your cigar is primed for your enjoyment.

If you’re a germophobe like me, one of the best kept secrets of cellophane is its ability to protect your cigars from the who-knows-where-they’ve-been-hands of every Tom, Dick, and Harry that marches through the doors of your local shop. I prefer to have my cigars unspoiled, thank you, but that’s just me.

The final benefit of cellophane is that it creates a microclimate that surrounds your cigar. The slower evaporation of humidity means that you can leave a cigar out of your humidor for longer when traveling without drying it out.

 

Is There a Best of Both Worlds?

Actually, there is! Some smokers will cut the tail of the cellophane, the portion that’s folded over behind the cigar (sometimes with a UPC code). They’ll trim it down to the cigar’s foot, allowing the protective benefits of the cellophane to remain while also opening the cigar to more of the humidor’s humidity.

 

What’s The Verdict?

The final hurdle is taste. Some say that cigars fare better with age if the cello is left on while others claim it’s the other way around. Who’s right?

No one.

Taste is subjective to the individual enjoying the cigar. Your unique perspective is all that matters, not someone else’s. After all, their opinion isn’t going to smoke your cigar. That being said, my parting gift to you is to do what you feel is best. There are no noteworthy, or at least tangible, adverse effects caused by either practice.

23 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Tony Bifulco
5 years ago

THANK YOU.. For making it CLEAR ….it gets confusing , a BIG Cigar company here in Florida (i wont name , begins with a T ) says removing the cellophane is an absolute MUST once the humidor has been seasoned , and frankly, i prefer to leave it on. Granted they look better off when you open the lid , but i think theyre better protected with it on…..

Joseph Gadberry
4 years ago

I leave it on until a few hours before I smoke it. I unwrap it and put it back in the humidor to admire until my planned smoke time. I only smoke a 3-5 sticks per week.

Lawrence Mixson
3 years ago

I have noticed some posting pictures of cigars with cellophane they have pulled from a humidor after a long period and sometimes the cellophane appears cloudy. Is this plus that have cone from the cigars, and if so, does this reduce the flavors experienced?

Lawrence Mixson
3 years ago

Autocorrect seems to have messed with me. The question should have been “Is this oils that have come from the cigars…”.

Jared Gulick
2 years ago

Lawrence, the yellowish color of the cellophane is due to being stained by the oils surfacing on the wrapper. This will not reduce the flavor and is absolutely normal!

Jesse
2 years ago

Thanks for the information! Cleared some questions up for me…now I can tell my wife she was wrong about this! Haha

Mike Clifford
2 years ago
Reply to  Jesse

So how did that tell my wife she was wrong thing work out? 😊

John A.
3 months ago
Reply to  Mike Clifford

😎

Tim Carroll
2 years ago

Question: Cello on or off for FLAVORED cigars in a flavored only humidor. I have various infused cigars in one humidor from CAO to Drew Estate to multiple varieties of Acids. Thoughts? Thanks and happy smoking!

Jared Gulick
2 years ago
Reply to  Tim Carroll

Tim, the information here applies to both traditional and infused cigars alike. Thanks for reading!

Craig
2 years ago
Reply to  Tim Carroll

My goto is Acid Kuba Kuba. However, I may have other non-infused as well. I took the cello off a batch of Kubas with my new Humidor and noticed the smell on the blue label was almost gone on them all. I leave the cellophane on my infused cigars now.

Last edited 2 years ago by Craig
Bman
1 year ago

As far as I’m concerned, here’s the deal:
If I were going to age cigars for a long time and leave them sitting in a humidor completely undisturbed for a long time, I might take the cello off. To me, the yellow cello phenomenon is a nice thing to see, but I keep wondering whether flavor would have leeched into a bare stick next to it instead of being lost to the cello.
HOWEVER, if you ever dig through or rearrange your humidor at all, any bare stick you touch will lose some luster on its wrapper when it rubs against other cigars or absorbs the oils of your hands. Every time you move a bare stick, the wrapper may flake a little.
So, my recommendation is unless you’re going to age something for years and years completely undisturbed, leave the cello on if it comes with it.

Jared Gulick
1 year ago
Reply to  Bman

Bman, couldn’t agree more. Thanks for reading!

John A.
3 months ago
Reply to  Bman

I agree 100%

George Davis
1 year ago

I’m a new owner of my very own cedar humidor. I’ve been smoking for years and have always bought one stick at a time, so storage was never an issue. The info will certainly be helpful as I start to explore cigars and prices not found at the corner store. Buying multi-packs, bundles and boxes have not been possible until now.

Editor
Gary Korb
1 year ago
Reply to  George Davis

Hi George. That’s good to know. I’m a big believer in the “slow build.” ;-)
G-~

Treeruyak
1 year ago

One other point in the ‘Leave it On’ camp, would be if you are storing various cigars against each other in the same humidor. Think putting a Maduro against a Connecticut. Just my 2¢.

Chuck
10 months ago

I have always wondered if the cello was a good thing to leave on. So I’m thinking I’ll try it both ways

Robert
4 months ago

Removing the cellophane from the cigar and disposing it into an outdoor fire pit is it toxic as it burn and a danger to the surroundings. Upon research cellophane is not considered as plastic. I need an opinion
Thank you

Jared Gulick
4 months ago
Reply to  Robert

Robert,

Thanks for reading!

I’ve tossed my cellophane in the firepit, it’s not plastic. As to wether it’s toxic when burning, I’m honestly not sure. It’s completely safe when used to keep your cigars fresh.

If you’re hesitant, just keep it in your pocket and throw out later.

Joseph
4 months ago

One of the best and most well written articles I’ve read in a while. Thanks so much.

Jared Gulick
4 months ago
Reply to  Joseph

Joseph, thank you so much for reading! :)

John A.
3 months ago

Thanks for your input! I’ve tried it both ways,and for me, I leave the cello on as it seems to keep my stogies fresher longer, even in my high dollar humidor. I recalibrate my humidor every 6 months, to make sure my hygrometer is accurate.

Jared Gulick

Jared Gulick

Features Editor, Jared Gulick, is a Certified Tobacconist, nerd of all things science, musician and serial abuser of the Oxford comma. He made his way to the Famous Smoke Shop retail store in 2018 and joined the Advisors when it was discovered that he could locate the shift key. Prior to his work in the cigar industry, he was a recording studio engineer, songwriter, and a journalism major at Northampton Community College.

Show all Jared Gulick's Articles
cigar advisor top new cigars 10-17-22 - cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (October 17, 2022)

Reading Time: 3 minutes In this edition of Top New Cigars, we smoke fresh sticks from Tim Ozgener, Caldwell, and Rocky Patel…plus, give you a chance to WIN $50 in cigar cash. See the reviews and enter now!

Read More
cigar advisor fan mail cigar questions answered part 49 - cover

Fan Mail: Your Burning Cigar Questions Get Answered (Part 49)

Reading Time: 2 minutes Were V-cutters around in Churchill’s time? What makes a cigar…good? We answer these questions and more in our latest edition of Cigar Advisor Fan Mail. Tune in to see our video responses!

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review 20 acre farm drew estate - cover

#NowSmoking: Drew Estate 20 Acre Farm

Reading Time: 4 minutes Cigar Advisor’s Jared Gulick gets down to the details in his #NowSmoking cigar review of Drew Estate 20 Acre Farm. See why he thinks it’s well worth the buy.

Read More
#nowsmoking Viva La Vida cigar review Box press Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: Viva la Vida Box Press Toro Famous Exclusivo

Reading Time: 4 minutes Gary and Jared are livin’ the life in this Viva La Vida Box Pressed Toro: made expressly for Famous Smoke Shop with the same blend as the original Viva La Vida cigars, it’s a one-size, box-pressed vitola. The question is, how does it compare to the parejo version? Click now and see!

Read More