Cigar Buying Guides

The Battle – Boxing Edition: Cigar Wrapper Leaves

Reading Time: 5 minutes

The Battle of the Cigar Wrapper Leaves

If you’ve been swiping through Cigar Advisor looking for those “ratings” screens full of inflated numbers, slanted cigar reviews and stupid phrases like “pleasant subset” or “humble notes”- you’re out of luck. We don’t do that here. Instead, we give you the facts on each stick and leave the review to readers like you. How did we pick the cigars for The Battle? We just happen to like ’em for one reason or another. As for the descriptions, we’re going off of what flavors the fillers have, what taste the wrappers have, and so on…and a little bit of personal experience too. So we pick a few smokes, lay them out in a particular set of categories and let them fight it out.


For this Battle, we’re telling the tale of the tape by wrapper leaf: Cameroon, Connecticut, Corojo and Sumatra. Four totally different looks, feels, tastes and aromas; but because an honest fighter doesn’t box outside his weight class, we’ve put them into a four of pugilism’s more popular divisions. Now, we’re not going to give you the rope-a-dope and tell you that just because one cigar is in a particular weight class, that it doesn’t have skills – it just means that it’s…different. The same way heavyweights rely on punching power, and lightweights rely on speed. Every one of these smokes can go the distance, so read on – you just might find a new sparring partner in this month’s Battle. Get in the ring!

Cigar Wrapper: Cameroon



Oliva Serie G Robusto (4½" x 50) cigar wrapperGeorge Foreman once said Roy Jones, Jr. “hits like a heavyweight and moves like a lightweight.” So it is with Serie G…presented in mostly box-pressed shapes, each cigar is a blend of Nicaraguan Habano longfillers and binders. Medium body puts Serie G in our Middleweight class, but be warned – like Jones, it never throws a haymaker.

Arturo Fuente Cuban Corona cigar on sale“Among the best of all time.” It’s said of both Arturo Fuente cigars and Felix Trinidad, one of the best Puerto Rican fighters in history. Fuente are handmade in the time-honored family tradition, and have become legend for their Dominican tobaccos – which offer a quick jab sequence as tight an in-your-face as Tito’s.

Partagas cuban heritage cigars on saleMarvelous Marvin Hagler had the highest KO % of all middleweight champions, ever – and one of the best chins in boxing history. Partagas has over 150 years of tradition originating in their native Cuba – and a rock-solid blend of Dominican Cuban-seed & Mexican fillers, making it an amazingly consistent cigar. Neither is to be taken lightly.


Cigar Wrapper: Connecticut

Perdomo champagne cigar wrapper on saleIt’s the Julio Cesar Chavez of this group – known for outstanding punching power and the relentless stalking of his opponents. Champagne is a flurry of complex flavors and smoke that ends nice and smooth…like a picture-perfect right hook.

Avo Classic cigars on sale ct cigar wrapperRay “Boom Boom” Mancini was a champ with a whirlwind punching style. Avo Classic cigars have that same one-two punch of curing and aging to provide a consistent, mild to medium-bodied Dominican filler smoke that burns clean through all 15 rounds.

Macanudo Cafe cigars on sale CT cigar wrapperLike Floyd Mayweather Jr. in his lightweight days: a world title holder thanks to the jab and a solid right. Blended with Dominican fillers, a set-up jab of Mexican binders and U.S. Connecticut shade wrapper, Macanudo Café is a true contender as well. And as Mayweather is to boxing, you don’t have a conversation about cigars without Macanudo.


Cigar Wrapper: Corojo

Rocky Patel Edge honduran cigars on saleThe Edge is the Larry Holmes of Corojo…one of the greatest heavyweights of all time; it’s a whole new dimension in full-bodied cigars. And the Edge, just like the Easton Assassin’s left jab, has one of the most potent weapons in the cigar world: potent all-Ligero long-fillers.

Camacho Corojo honduran cigars on saleCamacho Corojo cigars are fully-aged cigars with a distinctive ‘Havana-like’ flavor – so we can best compare them to heavyweight Joe Louis. Louis had a reputation as an honest, hardworking fighter; and Camacho is an honest, hardworking cigar made from genuine, first-generation Cuban seed (’97 vintage) Corojo leaf grown in Honduras. It’s a robust, yet smooth experience…just like a Joe Louis fight.

Prensado honduran cigars on saleThe first all box-pressed selection from Alec Bradley, and their most muscular to-date – this cigar is Smokin’ Joe Frazier. Made in Honduras, the blend’s Honduran and Nicaraguan longfillers bob and weave the palate. Prensado is as potent a smoke as Frazier’s left hook, his knockout weapon of choice; and both have been Undisputed World Heavyweight Champions.


Cigar Wrapper: Sumatra

Romeo y julieta cuban heritage cigars on saleJust like Sugar Ray Leonard, Romeo y Julieta 1875 is a name known in every house. They’re also both known for being smooth, with excellent balance – and finishing with a left hook. In Sugar Ray’s case, it got him Olympic boxing gold; in RyJ’s, it’s the cedar-aged Dominican longfiller tobacco that will leave you with a standing 8-count.

la gloria cubana serie RF cigars on sale cigar flavorsIf you were to sum up Manny Pacquiao in one word – it’s “aggressive.” Same with Serie RF cigars…robust, power-packed smokes with a full-bodied, no-nonsense blend of Nicaraguan Ligero and Dominican Olor. Just like stepping into the ring with Pacquiao, it’s only for the more experienced who can go the distance.

acid Kuba Kuba cigars on sale sumatra cigar wrapperAcid Kuba Kuba – the “Golden Boy” of ACID cigars, and still the best-selling in their ‘blue label’ series. Both have a relaxed style, and among the most flavorful, too: De La Hoya being chosen a perennial “Fighter of the Year,” and Kuba Kuba the choice of legions of fans in and out of the Battle ring.


Try ‘Em…Smoke ‘Em…And Pick Your Winners!


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chuck Martin
7 years ago

Another totally useless article….

Cindi Miller-Newmam
7 years ago

Good, solid info!

Joel Hoffman
7 years ago

entertaining and informative nice work

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
cigar advisor news – onyx vintage nicaragua boasts extra aged habano wrapper – release – cover

Cigar News: New Onyx Vintage Nicaragua Boasts Extra-Aged Habano Wrapper

Reading Time: < 1 minute In a follow-up to the Onyx Bold Nicaragua, a new Onyx cigar with an all-Nicaraguan blend is headed to retail. Onyx Vintage Nicaragua is so-named for its vintage fillers and rare Nicaraguan Habano wrapper. Get all the details here.

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars january 9 2023 - cover

Top New Cigars (January 9, 2023)

Reading Time: 3 minutes Rocky Patel, West Tampa Tobacco Company and FLVR get the spotlight for the first cigar reviews of 2023. See why we’re giving them first dibs.

Read More
cigar advisor news - cao vision 2022 cigars - release - cover

Cigar News: CAO Releases Vision 2022 Cigars

Reading Time: 2 minutes CAO Cigars want to light-up your cigar life once again with the release of the CAO Vision 2022 cigars. Presented in 30-count humidors complete with their famous LED lights, the blend also boasts a new Honduran Jamastran wrapper. Learn more here.

Read More

2019 CA Report: The Essential Cigar Advisor Guide to J.C. Newman Cigars

Reading Time: 27 minutes See inside our Essential J.C. Newman Tasting Guide: We smoked nineteen J.C. Newman cigars from their handmade and machine-made selections. What we learned was, this is one situation where “Hello Newman” has an entirely different meaning.

Read More