Cigars 101

The blend vs. the size of the cigar. What counts when rating it?

Q. What is the difference between the Excalibur #1, #2, #3 etc., besides the actual size. If the blend is the same, why do the ratings vary so much. Just curious.
Thanks,
Tim M.

A. The same tobacco blend is used in each cigar line, regardless of the brand. Size plays a critical role in the flavor of a cigar, because you have more or less tobacco in the cigar. But this is only one part of the reason ratings vary.

The other, and perhaps even more important part is, subjectivity. You, me, and a half a dozen other people could smoke the same cigar and come up with completely different opinions. Or, we could smoke different size cigars and have similar opinions. That’s why I usually try to avoid mentioning “flavors” in the cigar descriptions I write unless I’ve personally experienced them myself – and more than once. Even then, it doesn’t mean that someone else will taste those same flavors.

My advice is to try various sizes within a particular brand or brand extension until you find the one that tastes best to you. For one brand a Robusto may be the best. For another, a Lonsdale, a Torpedo, or a Churchill. For example, I prefer the Avo Maduro No. 2, because, for me, that size has been the most flavorful and consistent. I like the Flor de Oliva Sumatra Robusto, and the Davidoff Millennium Petit Corona for the same reasons. Three completely different blends, three different sizes.

Some experts say that if you really want to experience the blend as the Master Blender intended, try a Corona (usually 5″ x 42) or a Toro (usually 6″ x 50). Coronas are often used for testing in the factory, but the main reason for trying these two sizes is that they are proportional with regard to length vs. width, and therefore best suited to express the desired flavor, texture and aroma of the smoke. So keep experimenting. Your humidor should be filled with all sorts of sizes and shapes. That’s what enjoying premium cigars is all about. – G.K.

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for CigarAdvisor.com since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
Now Smoking Rafael Gonzolez Cigars

#Nowsmoking: Rafael Gonzalez Churchill

The Rafael Gonzalez Churchill offers a long, smooth, and mellow smoke with dominant notes of cedar, nuts and a pinch of sweet spice. A terrific starter cigar – click to see more of our review.

Read More
5 things you need to know about Culebra cigars CACover

5 Things You Need to Know About… Culebra Cigars

Culebras: those snaky-looking cigars, entwined in a set of three. Hard to find and rarely made these days, but they sure are fun to smoke, especially with two friends. Culebra cigars also have an interesting back story. We dig into what makes these time-honored cigars so unique, and demonstrate how to smoke them.
Read More
Cigar Questions answered part 24 fan mail CACover

Fan Mail: Your Burning Cigar Questions – Answered (Part 24)

This month, we tackle four premium cigar questions that, if you use our answers, might make you the smartest person in the room – or the bar, anyway. Each Cigar Q&A is in a quick and easy-to-use video format; watch them now and share with your cigar smoking pals!
Read More
10 cigar numbers

2015 CA Report: 10 Top Cigar Numbers

What's in a name? Numbers. And in the case of these 10 smokes, the cigar numbers matter - it's their name. See 10 numerically named cigars and their review.
Read More