Cigar News

The Supreme Court’s “Leegin” Decision: What it means to you

Reading Time: 3 minutes

If you can bear with a little legal mumbo jumbo, the following excerpts illustrate some of the key points of the decision and should help give you a better understanding of why the Court ruled the way it did.

Justice Kennedy writes: “A single manufacturer’s use of vertical price restraints tends to eliminate intrabrand price competition; [competition between manufacturers who sell different brands of the same type of product.] this in turn encourages retailers to invest in tangible or intangible services or promotional efforts that aid the manufacturer’s position as against rival manufacturers. Resale price maintenance also has the potential to give consumers more options so that they can choose among low-price, low-service brands; high-price, high-service brands; and brands that fall in-between.”

Kennedy later adds, “If the consumer can then buy the product from a retailer that discounts because it has not spent capital providing services or developing a quality reputation, the high-service retailer will lose sales to the discounter, forcing it to cut back its services to a level lower than consumers would otherwise prefer. Minimum resale price maintenance alleviates the problem because it prevents the discounter from undercutting the service provider. With price competition decreased, the manufacturer retailers compete among themselves over services.”

The other side of the argument

Justice Breyer, who dissented with Justices Stevens, Souter and Ginsburg, wrote: “The fact that a rule of law has become ‘embedded’ in our ‘national culture’ argues strongly against overruling…The per se rule forbidding minimum resale price maintenance agreements has long been ‘embedded’ in the law of antitrust. It involves price, the economy’s ‘central nervous system’…It reflects a basic antitrust assumption (that consumers often prefer lower prices to more service). It embodies a basic antitrust objective (providing consumers with a free choice about such matters). And it creates an easily administered and enforceable bright line, ‘Do not agree about price,’ that businesses as well as lawyers have long understood…The Court suggests that it is following the common-law tradition…In sum, every stare decisis concern [the doctrine that, once a court has laid down a principle of law applicable to a certain set of facts, it will adhere to that principle and apply it to future cases where the facts are substantially the same] this Court has ever mentioned counsels against overruling here…The only safe predictions to make about today’s decision are that it will likely raise the price of goods at retail and that it will create considerable legal turbulence as lower courts seek to develop workable principles. I do not believe that the majority has shown new or changed conditions sufficient to warrant overruling a decision of such long standing.”

What does all of this mean to you, the cigar consumer? Some of the ruling’s consequences are yet to be seen, but one thing’s for sure: Cigar makers will now be able to set minimum retail prices for their brands and respective frontmarks. Accordingly, retailers will be prohibited by law from selling below the manufacturer’s set minimum price. It may help level competition among the big online retailers, while giving the B&M cigar stores a leg up, but, as Justice Breyer noted, expect prices to go up regardless of where you purchase your cigars.

So, will cigar smokers abandon online “cigar discounters” if the prices are equivalent to their corner cigar store? Probably not. Online retailers will still have a considerable amount of market power; the ability to offer bigger selection, save customers state sales taxes where applicable, offer free cigars, shipping, and other premiums, as well as provide a wider range of customer services. It will also be incumbent upon mass merchants to be more creative in their marketing and new customer acquisition efforts.

How this decision will play out in the months ahead should prove to be even more provocative after the RTDA convenes in Houston next month when the manufacturers meet the retailers face-to-face. £

If you have the interest and the time, you can read all 55 pages of the decision by clicking here.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor news – miami cigar releases limited edition nestor miranda 80th anniversary collection – release – cover

Miami Cigar Releases Limited Edition Nestor Miranda 80th Anniversary Collection

Reading Time: 2 minutes Nestor Miranda has been the face of Miami Cigar & Co. since 1995 and is one of the reasons for its success. For that, and for turning 80 this year, the Nestor Miranda NM80 cigar selection was released. Learn more here.

Read More
cigar advisor news – assouline releases arturo Fuente since 1912 book – release – cover1

Cigar News: Assouline Publications Releases “Arturo Fuente: Since 1912” Anthology

Reading Time: 3 minutes Ready for a deep dive into the world of Arturo Fuente Cigars? Compiled in this luxurious coffee table book by Aaron Sigmond, Arturo Fuente: Since 1912 covers the history, the family, the cigars, and much more. Learn more about the book here.

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars 12/26/2022 - cover image

CA Report: Top New Cigars (December 26, 2022)

Reading Time: 3 minutes Congrats! You survived the holidays. Destress with a flurry of new cigars fresh at Famous from Foundation, CAO, and AJ Fernandez!

Read More
montecristo relentless cigar review video cacover

CA REVIEW PANEL: Montecristo Relentless Cigar Review (Video)

Reading Time: 6 minutes When the band says “Montecristo” cigar smokers pay attention. Blended in collaboration with Plasencia, Montecristo Relentless boasts a core of Nicaraguan long fillers from Jalapa, Condega, and Estelí, all surrounded by a hearty Ometepe binder, and rolled with a tawny Nicaraguan Rosado wrapper. To find out what verdict our judges decreed, watch now.

Read More