Cigars 101

5 Things You Need to Know About…Cigar Cutters

5 Things You Need to Know About Cigar Cutters

If you love a fine cigar – then you already know that a cigar cutter is a must-have tool in your arsenal of accessories. And while we’ve debated the merits of each type of cutter and how to cut cigars with each many times over in the past, it dawned on me how little historical information exists out there about cigar cutters. Actually, there’s pretty much nothing – except for the fact that we as smokers have been using our teeth to bite the cap off our cigars since, well, forever.

Let’s just say Zino Davidoff was not a fan of such uncultured behavior: “[this method] does not permit much precision…I never practice or recommend such a method,” he wrote in The Connoisseur’s Book of the Cigar. So if you bit the end off your smoke, Zino would have labeled you a philistine; apparently he never forgot his cutter at home.

 

cigar cutters piercer
A cigar perforator, patented in 1868. (Illustration credit: cigarhistory.info)

 

 

The first incarnation of cigar cutters were most likely knives, and their design got more and more specialized for use on cigars as smoking became more popular. By the 1870s, smokers were using a piercer – sometimes called a cigar perforator – in addition to cutting their cigars. And this continued, until the popularity of the cigarette overtook the cigar as the king of tobacco in the early 20th Century.

Cigar smokers liked their toys even back then. Cutters ranged from simple pocket-sized blades to weighty and ornate mechanical gadgets that severed the caps of cigars. But if you see an antique cigar cutter, you’ll notice the size of the hole: it’s tiny. That’s because most of the cigars being produced back in the day were small, and rolled with a tapered, almost pointed head. Seems 60 rings were a long way off, yet.

 

lady cigar cutters
The original cigar porn: It may seem like a statue, but it was made to cut cigars…and it works like our imagination says it would. Lift her left leg in the air, cut your cigar.  Naughty Victorian age folk. (Image via liveauctioneers.com)

 

Cigar cutters began to fall a bit out of favor, however, as machine-made cigars became popular. You didn’t need one; if you smoked a machine-rolled cigar, the cap was already perforated for you, with a small punch-sized hole for your smoking convenience.

Premium handrolled cigars stuck around, of course – so as long as they survived, so did the need for a cutter. That continues today, so here are 5 things you should know about cigar cutters:

#1. Yes, you CAN sharpen and clean cigar cutters.

Depending, of course, on what kind of cutter you tend to use. For most non-disposable guillotine cigar cutters, sharpening and cleaning involves removing the case – not only a huge headache, but the surrounding case might prevent you from being able to get the entire blade surface as sharp as you’d like. And at the risk of voiding your warranty, you’re better off taking a crack at cleaning it first. I’ve heard of two ways to do it:

  1. Use a cotton swab or clean rag dampened with rubbing alcohol to clean the surfaces, and the tobacco oils and leaf debris should come off with a little “persuasion.”
  2. For cutters with stainless blades, drop it in a cup of hot water and let it sit until the water is able to penetrate the built-up shreds of tobacco and other funk. Once thoroughly soaked, they’ll come off. Make sure you dry your cutter thoroughly.

You could also try home-grown remedies for sharpening scissors (like cutting through aluminum foil or very fine grit sandpaper), but your mileage may vary – and I’d take any of these solutions with a grain of salt, mostly because (a) I don’t want you to ruin your cutter trying them, and (b) I don’t want you screaming at me because I told you to do something that turned out to be dumb and/or dangerous. I say plenty of dumb and/or dangerous stuff; ask my wife. For cheap plastic cutters with a single blade (you know, the cheap ones) – toss ‘em. Spend a buck on a new cutter, instead of demolishing the head of your next cigar.

If you absolutely need to sharpen a guillotine cigar cutter or a v-cutter, I suppose you could use a Dremel tool, a stone polishing burr and a very steady hand to maintain the cutting angle as you grind the edge. You might also try a diamond rod file, gun file or hobby file, but again – you’re slightly altering the shape of the cutting edge, which will probably diminish the cutter’s performance over a relatively short period of time. Save this method for bullet cutters and sharpening cigar punches – they’re a lot easier.

Your best bet – and what we here at Cigar Advisor officially recommend you do – is to return it to the manufacturer, since brands like Xikar feature a lifetime warranty – just send your cutter back to them (or take it back to where you bought it, and they’ll send it) and they’ll use the right tools for sharpening the entire blade surface.

 

#2. You’re not limited to using a cigar punch on huge ring cigars anymore.

Let’s say you’ve fallen in love with the Asylum 13 Ogre – a super-sized 6×80 jawbreaker that lasts you 3 hours per cigar. How has cutting the cap been working out for you? I’m guessing you probably used a larger diameter punch cutter, or took a couple whacks at this tree stump with your guillotine with just-ok results.

 

xikar cigar cutters x875
Cuts 80 RG cigars, and then some. Also useful for light pruning around the yard. Click for more details.

 

Upgrade your gear: the XIKAR X875 cutter delivers an appropriately sharp clipping to cigars up to 80 RG (like the Ogre) with a pair of stainless steel blades easily capping the biggest smokes on the market. As a matter of fact, I don’t know that there’s a cutter with the capacity to cut a bigger cigar out there…so if you prefer your cigars at beastly sizes, add it to your lineup.

 

#3. The world’s most prolific cigar smoker didn’t use one.

winston churchill no cigar cutters
Go ahead – tell this face he’s doing cigars wrong.

Winston Churchill (no, not George Burns – his El Producto Queens were machine-made, with a formed hole in the cap; no cutter necessary) had a ritual, as we all do, for lighting a cigar: instead of cutting, he’d poke it with the end of a wooden match, or with a tool called a piercer. It’s kind of like a drawpoker, though it makes me think the draw must have been terrible. Sir Winston would blow through the cigar from the foot, expelling the loose tobacco to make sure his cigar would draw.

Whatever works, right?

 

#4. Swiss Army Knives have cigar cutters.

Both the #1 and the #2 producers of Swiss Army Knives – who are owned by the same company, actually – offer product options that include cigar punches and cigar scissors among the tools on board (they call them “implements”). Victorinox has two cigar smoker-friendly knives, Wenger has five…six, if you include their Giant Swiss Army Knife. Bigger than your boot and weighing in at 2 pounds with nearly 90 implements that perform 141 functions, it includes a dozen screwdrivers, 9 blades, golf tools, reamers, files, 3 fishing tools, a laser pointer, a laboratory key, pliers and yes, cigar scissors. Plus a toothpick, of course. Check it out; and be sure to read the reviews…they’re priceless.

Wenger giant knife largest Swiss Army knife
A knife for the true outdoor adventurer – though you’ll need a Sherpa just to lug it around for you. Look for the cigar scissors just north of the Allen wrench.

 

 

#5. How you cut it will change the character of the cigar.

While certain cigars call for using different cutters – it’s extra difficult to punch a torpedo, for instance – no one single cutter or method is “right,” “wrong” or “preferred.” You do what makes your cigar taste good, when we’re talking straight-up parejo shaped cigars. But interestingly enough, the method you use to clip your cigar can make a significant difference in the intensity of the smoke. A classic guillotine or a scissors cut provides a wide amount of surface area at the head for a smooth, open draw. If you opt to go for a v-cut or a cat’s-eye cut on your cigar, you’ll notice a change in the concentration of the smoke and the flavors you pull through the cigar. The flavors are richer and fuller; that’s because the now-smaller opening you’ve created in the cap is funneling the smoke through a narrower opening. Even smaller is the resulting hole from punch or bullet cigar cutters; with an opening less than half of the surface area of a guillotine cut, a cigar that’s been punched might seem like it has a bit of a harder draw. But the resulting big blast of flavor that’s being channeled on the palate is what really speaks to fuller-bodied cigar smokers, upping the intensity even more. There is a downside, however, as focusing the flavor also focuses the tars and the other elements of the cigar that can lead to harsh flavors if you over smoke it…so be aware.

An interesting trial would be to take your regular go-to cigar, and try it with a different cut: does it smoke more robustly with a v-cut or punch cut? Is it more smooth with a guillotine cut, if that’s not what you regularly use? Try a cut you’ve never used and see if it makes a difference in the flavor intensity of your cigar.

 

 

newest oldest most voted
Janet Lindholm
Guest
Janet Lindholm

Very interesting.

Pierre Jourdan
Guest
Pierre Jourdan

You lack the cigar knife from http://www.lesfineslames.com in this review ^^

Gilbert Martinez
Guest
Gilbert Martinez

GOOD STUFF

Tim Eaton
Guest
Tim Eaton

Thanks

Rich Villescas
Guest
Rich Villescas

Thanks!

Greg Ronalds
Guest
Greg Ronalds

I like the punch cut for the go-to cut. I find it classier as compared to having to cover the large ring guages to make a good draw.

Terry Balentine
Guest
Terry Balentine

i prefer a punch, (i keep several sizes) to start with, if it doesn’t draw easily i can always chop it with the scissors or guillotine.

Dan Colley
Guest
Dan Colley

For about three years now, I’ve been using what is called a “perfect cutter”. I got mine from a company in Miami, and I think they hold the patent on them, but I’m not sure. Anyway, since I’ve been using it, I’ve never had a bad cut … NEVER !!! Mine is made of titanium but they come in stainless steel as well, it doesn’t rust, is self-sharpening and because of it’s design, it cuts exactly the right amount off the head without damaging the cap. Now I only use a traditional cutter when I am on the road and… Read more »

Peter Harberts
Guest
Peter Harberts

I’ve been using a Xicar 75 to cut my Asylum 13 Ogre 80 ring cigars and found it very satisfactory. It gives an excellent open draw which allows the full flavour to come through. It’s hard to find 3 hours of leisure to enjoy these cigars, but worth the effort. If I could find the time, I wouldn’t smoke anything else. This cutter was bought in Australia and retails at an astonishingly expensive $49.95 (smoking cigars in Australia is a wealth hazzard). What can you do? You need the right tools.

Alan Compton
Guest
Alan Compton

I have been using an unprimed 22-250 rifle casing to punch my cigars for many years now and love it. The hole is about the same as a manufactored bullet punch but being a hunter/shooter i always have a few shell casings laying around. I use a drimal tool to sharpen the brass hole with ease. If it gets dull I just hit it with the drimal again. Cleaning out the punch is a snap as I use a piece of heavy copper wire to push the tobacco out from the primer hole. The old saying “Necessity is the Mother… Read more »

Norm Brust
Guest
Norm Brust

the v-cut gives you ample exposure for a good draw and it keeps the filler away from your tongue.

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
5 Tips for buying your first humidor Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Quick Guide: 5 Tips for Buying Your First Humidor

Use these quick starter humidor buying tips to shorten the learning curve and find the right cigar storage solution to fit your needs!

Read More

5 Things You Need To Know About… Whiskey And Cigars

This relationship actually runs pretty deep…so I’m sharing 5 Things I learned that bond whiskey and cigars together: how cigarmaking dovetails with distilling, why a smoke is a natural fit with a pour of whiskey by its side, and what else these indulgences have in common.

Read More
h. upmann cigars guide h upmann cigar reviews 2018 CACover

2018 CA Report: The Essential Cigar Advisor Guide to H. Upmann Cigars

If you’ve passed on H. Upmann cigars, the Cigar Advisors have 9 reasons why this great Cuban heritage brand deserves a spot in your humidor – get the full smoking experience with our NC H. Upmann cigar reviews inside!

Read More

2016 CA Report: The 3 Biggest Mistakes of Pairing Cigars & Beer

Craft beer and cigars both have their share of myths. Learn about pairing cigars with beer, plus the 3 mistakes you can avoid to have a better experience.
Read More