Cigar Buying Guides

2016 CA Report: Best Top 25 Cigars of 2015 Alternatives

Reading Time: 6 minutes

The Best Alternative Smokes to the Top 25 Cigars of 2015

By Gary Korb

Every December, cigar smokers look forward to the list of the “Top 25 Cigars” of the year published by Cigar Aficionado magazine. The list has become so highly-anticipated that the publication begins leaking the names of the cigars between 11 and 25 several weeks before the final top-10 are released. Retail cigar stores begin clearing space to display the winning boxes as they await the onslaught of customers who will be coming in to buy the best cigars of the year. Think of it as the Hajj for cigar lovers. This concept of creating an annual “best” list has become so popular, practically every cigar news and blogger site now has their own Top-25 list, including us here at

Manufacturers love it, too. Landing a spot in Aficionado’s “Top 25 Cigars” is akin to winning a coveted Oscar for “Best Picture.” Some brands sell out entirely from the notoriety, especially if they’re limited edition cigars, while others that some cigar smokers may have overlooked earlier in the year are given new life.

Recently, Famous Smoke Shop created a cigar sampler made up of cigars listed in the “Top 25 Cigars of 2015.” Suddenly, a lightbulb appeared overhead. What if we took the 10 cigars in that sampler and created a second sampler made up of alternative cigars? Let’s face it, no matter how many accolades a given cigar receives, when you come right down to it, opinions are utterly subjective. For every good cigar on the market, there’s another cigar that’s just as good…in someone else’s opinion. So, for those who may not agree with the chosen cigars – and there always are – or those looking for “equivalent” smokes that are easier on the wallet, we present the following alternatives to 10 of the Top 25 Cigars of 2015, and why they were selected.

Inferno Flashpoint Maduro Torpedo (alternative to the My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo – #1)

buy top 25 cigars my father le bijou 1922 torpedotop 25 cigars alternatives inferno flashpoint cigarsThis cigar is made in Estelí by Oliva, who, like the Garcia family, have been making some of the best Nicaraguan cigars for generations. Like the Le Bijou 1922, this torpedo has a diverse, all-Nicaraguan core, but with a deliciously dark Mexican San Andres Morron wrapper that’s comparably sweet as the Nicaraguan Pelo de Oro Oscuro used on the Le Bijou.

Four Kicks Black Belt Buckle Corona Gorda (alternative to the CAO Flathead V642 Piston – #3)

buy cao flathead cigars top 25 cigarstop 25 cigars alternatives crowned heads black belt buckle cigarsThough it’s not box-pressed like the CAO Flathead V642, the Four Kicks Black Belt Buckle Corona Gorda does boast a similar Nicaraguan long-filler core and an equally dark and oily Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro wrapper. The smoke is full-flavored, earthy, woody, and impressively complex with just the right amount of sweetness.

La Aurora Cameroon Belicoso (alternative to the Arturo Fuente Don Carlos No. 2 – #4)

top 25 cigars arturo fuente don carlos cigarstop 25 cigars alternatives la aurora cameroon cigarsNot an easy match-up due to the Don Carlos’s extraordinary reputation, but this figurado similarly melds the most select Dominican Piloto Cubano longfillers with a dash of Nicaraguan for extra depth, and completes the recipe with a plush Cameroon wrapper. Medium-bodied, you may pick up notes of sweet spice, cocoa, and cedar along the way.

Rocky Patel Cuban Blend Torpedo (alternative to Rocky Patel The Edge Habano Torpedo – #7)

top 25 cigars rocky patel the edge habano torpedo cigarstop 25 cigars alternatives rocky patel cuban blend cigarsHere’s a match that’s so close it’s scary. Rocky’s bestselling The Edge Habano line has become a modern classic, but one taste of the Cuban Blend with its plush Corojo wrapper offers a bold, spicy, creamy, and “decadent” smoke with awesome balance in a virtually identical blend. You can’t miss with this alternative, and you’ll save a few bucks, too.

Romeo House of Montague Robusto (alternative to Laranja Reserva Toro – #13)

top 25 cigars laranja reserva toro cigarstop 25 cigars alternatives romeo y julieta cigarsEven Cigar Advisor had the Laranja Reserva near the top of our Top 25 Cigars of 2015 list, so finding an alternative presented a unique challenge. The result was this Romeo House of Montague Robusto. Blended with Nicaraguan, Dominican and Brazilian long-fillers, the Brazilian Arapiraca wrapper may not have all the citrusy notes found in the Brazilian Laranja leaf, but it makes up for it in balance, complexity and natural sweetness in a more medium-bodied smoke.


CLE Plus Toro (alternative to Alec Bradley Sanctum Toro – #15)

top 25 cigars alec bradley sanctum toro cigarstop 25 cigars alternatives cle plus cigarsSeveral Alec Bradley Cigars have earned high scores for their complexity, full-flavor and pristine Honduran Trojes Corojo wrappers, but few can do Corojo like Christian Luis Eiroa. His CLE Plus Toro is a full-flavored, all-Corojo Honduran puro that smokes like a dream. Loaded with caramelized flavors of cedar, nutmeg, and a hint of cinnamon, this is one creamy, sweet n’ spicy delight.

Perdomo2 Limited Edition 2008 Maduro Epicure (alternative to Avo Syncro Nicaragua Toro – #16)

top 25 cigars avo syncro nicaragua toro cigarstop 25 cigars alternatives perdomo 2 epicure maduro cigarsThis Cuban-pressed Perdomo2 Limited Edition 2008 Maduro Epicure is a Nicaraguan puro. It may not have the complexity of the Avo’s multi-nation blend, but you will find plenty of rich, earthy-spicy Nicaraguan flavor in there. Plus, the inherent sweetness of the maduro wrapper is on-par with the Syncro. It’s also a lot more affordable.

Liga Undercrown Robusto (alternative to L’Atelier La Mission 1959 – #17)

top 25 cigars l'atelier la mission 1959 cigarstop 25 cigars alternatives liga undercrown robusto cigarsThis favorite from Drew Estate has a lot in common with the L’Atelier: Rich-tasting Nicaraguan long-fillers, a savory Mexican San Andrés Maduro wrapper, and outstanding quality from a top-tier tabacalera. Add the Brazilian Mata Fina and the T-52 stalk-cut binder, and you’ve got yourself a thick, creamy, full-flavored banquet of a smoke.

Perdomo 20th Anniversary Sun Grown Churchill (alternative to Montecristo Espada Quillon – #20)

top 25 cigars montecristo espada quillion cigarstop 25 cigars alternatives perdomo 20th anniversary sun grown churchill cigarsWith all due respect to Montecristo’s Grupo de Maestros, Nick Perdomo and his team also use a variety of Nicaraguan tobaccos from Estelí, Condega and Jalapa in this extraordinary tribute to 20 years of Nicaraguan tobacco farming and blending achievement. Rolled in a flawless and flavorful Sun Grown wrapper, 14 months of bourbon barrel fermentation and at least 6 years of aging make this puro nothing short of magnificent. Brimming with caramelized flavors of sweet wood and spices, this savory surrogate delivers rich complex flavor in spades.

Perla Del Mar Perla P (alternative to Nub Cameroon 358 – #23)

top 25 cigars nub cameroon 358 cigarstop 25 cigars alternatives perla del mar perla p cigarsNearly identical in size to its Nub counterpart, the Perla Del Mar Perla P boasts a resoundingly rich-tasting blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos from Pueblo Nuevo, La Reina, Condega, and Jalapa box-pressed in a silky and seamless Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper. The smoke is earthy, delicately spicy, well-balanced, and complex with a slight paradigm shift that’s equally satisfying.

And there you have it: 10 cigars that stand-up to an equal number of sticks that have been chosen to be among “the best.” Most of these top 25 cigars were hard acts to follow, and let’s face it, we’re talking apples to oranges; but if nothing else, you’ll save some money in the process.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Nicholas G Apostle
7 years ago

I don’t see the point

Robert Vaughan
7 years ago

Not a very impresive list.

James Laabs
7 years ago

I found this article interesting, it gave me some insights into brands I was not familiar with.

Camden Hottes
7 years ago

So glad to see the Undercrown listed… I believe their Corona Doble size is one of the best tasting and constructed cigars out there.

Jack Bliesath
7 years ago

Great article on alternatives. I smoked many of the list, and really was not impressed with some. I’m always looking for sleepers and it’s great to see a bundle finally!

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor news – crowned heads releases mil días maduro – release – cover

Cigar News: Crowned Heads Releases Mil Días Maduro

Reading Time: 2 minutes Released as a new regular production line extension, Crowned Heads Mil Días Maduro cigars boast a dark, Grade-A Connecticut Broadleaf maduro wrapper, and more, including a new all-Nicaraguan core blend. Read all about it here.

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars july 24, 2023 - cover

Top New Cigars (July 24, 2023)

Reading Time: 3 minutes Summer sure is heating up with an onslaught of new cigar releases. Check out the latest sticks from Drew Estate, Diesel, and Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust and read these quick reviews to see just how humidor-worthy they are!

Read More
cigar advisor 5 things about traveling with cigars - cover


Reading Time: 7 minutes : I made mistakes so you don’t have to. See my top 5 tips on traveling with cigars and spend your time enjoying them instead of regretting bad decisions. Click now to learn more!

Read More


Reading Time: 3 minutes Have you ever wondered what makes a cigar “earthy?” Do you know how to bleed a cigar lighter and why it’s important? Those questions, including how long premium cigars can survive without a humidor are answered in this month’s Fan Mail videos. Watch now.

Read More