Cigar Makers

2018 CA Report: The Top 5 First Generation Cigar Makers

The Top 5 First Generation Cigar Makers

By Tommy Zman Zarzecki

I’m drafting this article only days before IPCPR, the cigar industry’s biggest tradeshow, a yearly gathering of cigar makers and the retailers who come to meet and greet, as new product will be on display. Attending this show will be countless cigar-making legends who were born into tobacco families from Latin America: prolific names like Fuente, Oliva, Padrón, Eiroa and so many more. But there will also be some modern-day icons who entered the business with very little first-hand knowledge and just a whole lot of big dreams.

Below I list five of these men, all who have worked so incredibly hard to get where they are today. Even in the face of looming FDA regulations, draconian smoking laws, and outlandish tobacco taxes, they drive forward, while continuing to make some of the world’s very best cigars. I happen to know these five guys personally, and I know how much the cigar culture means to them, as well as the faithful followers who purchase their creations.

So, I give you my list of five, and a little bit of their backgrounds, as well as two cigar selections from these manufacturers that I, myself, enjoy.


Steve Saka – Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust

I’m not sure I’ve ever known or talked to a gringo who has such over-the-top passion for premium aged tobacco as Steve Saka. He actually went to school for engineering, (I mean, what American-born kid says, “I’m gonna blend cigar tobacco when I grow up.”) A few years back he was a fellow writer of mine at Cigar magazine. While I was known for writing the funny shit that Lew Rothman loved to laugh at, Steve was basically my antithesis, crafting in-depth fascinating pieces, (one about black tobacco in particular), that have been lauded as some of the best ever written about the leaf. He was then brought on at Drew Estate to make things happen, and with the creation of the Liga Privada No.9 line, and being named president and CEO, it was mission accomplished. In July of 2015, he started Dunbarton with the main goal of making outstanding cigars (that he would enjoy smoking) the proper way, no matter how long or what it would take. Again, with his first introductions of Sobremesa and Mi Querida, a mission very much accomplished.


Mi Querida – Short Gordo Grande – 4 ¾ x 56

Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro . Inside: Nicaraguan

Mi Querida - Short Gordo Grande


Sobremesa – Short Robusto – 4 3/4 x 52

Wrapper: Ecuadorian Habano . Inside: Mexican San Andres, Nicaraguan & Pennsylvania Broadleaf

Sobremesa – Short Robusto



Pete Johnson – Tatuaje Cigars

At 18 years of age, he left his lifelong home in Maine to fulfill his dreams as a rock-and-roll bassist in an LA band. Well, things don’t always work out for aspiring musicians, so Pete started working as a bouncer in a strip club. A local cigar shop he frequented needed some part-time help, which turned into a full-time gig and the dude was hooked on the cigar lifestyle. He started visiting cigar factories and reading everything he could on the subject as making his own cigars became the driving goal. Fast forward to his introduction to Jose Garcia (affectionately known the world over as Don Pepin), who began making cigars for the kid known as Tattoo Pete. Very early on his cigar was ranked #4 on the “Top 25 of the Year” list and success came fast. Today, while he’s not actually playing in a band, some would say he’s living the rock star life, with a clothing line he developed, amazing wines that he’s created, and of course, a portfolio of some of the most flavorful cigars available in the world.


Tatuaje Black – Corona Gorda– 5 5/8 x 46 – Body: Full

Wrapper: Nicaraguan Criollo . Inside: Nicaraguan

Tatuaje Black – Corona Gorda


Tatuaje Tattoo – Caballero – 5 x 50 – Body: Medium

Wrapper: Ecuadorian Habano . Inside: Nicaraguan

Tatuaje Tattoo – Caballero


Alan Rubin – Alec Bradley

Alan says he fell in love with cigars in his 20’s, but it was in 1996 that the reality of making premium-aged sticks became just that. Does anybody remember Occidental Reserve cigars? That was Alan Rubin along with partner Ralph Montero’s creation back around 2000. They were made by the great Henke Kelner (of the Occidental Factory in the Dominican Republic), the prolific master blender who made Davidoff’s high-end products. It was then followed up by the Trilogy and MAXX, and a real-live cigar company started to take shape. But it was the Alec Bradley Tempus that garnered super high scores from reviewers that set things on fire (pun definitely intended). When Prensado was named “2011 Cigar of the Year” with an insane ‘96’ rating, Mr. Rubin’s love for the leaf grew way more than ever expected, and was a testament to a lot of years of really hard work. In case you weren’t aware, Alec and Bradley are the names of his two sons who are now old enough to smoke great sticks, as well as work with dad in building the company to the next level.


Alec Bradley Prensado Lost Art – Robusto – 5 x 52 – Body: Full

Wrapper: Honduran Corojo. Inside: Nicaraguan & Honduran

Alec Bradley Prensado Lost Art – Robusto

Alec Bradley Nica Puro Rosado – Toro – 6 x 52 – Body: Medium to Full

Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano. Inside: Nicaraguan

 Alec Bradley Nica Puro Rosado Toro


Jonathan Drew – Drew Estate

Jonathan Drew wanted to be a lawyer but eventually ended up running a cigar empire. The Brooklyn boy, along with college frat brother Marvin Samel, started with a 16-foot kiosk, selling cigars at the World Trade Center in New York City. With a mind for marketing and pushing the tobacco-filled envelope even further, John took things in a new and different direction with the 1999 release of the ACID brand, which created a whole new cult generation of cigar lovers. Enter Steve Saka and the creation of Liga Privada No.9 and T-52, and Drew Estate exploded with a hardcore group of followers the industry had never really seen. 2007 saw the opening of the mothership – La Gran Fabrica Drew Estate – the 96,000 sq ft factory in Esteli, Nicaragua, one of the five largest cigar making facilities in the world. While they make outstanding cigars, so much of Drew’s popularity is due to the fact that John is a certifiably insane character (and I can say that with total love, being a longtime friend). His connection with his fans is genuine and the main reason for his amazing success as the reigning president of Drew Estate.


Nica Rustica by Drew Estate – El Brujito – 6 x 52 – Body: Full

Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro. Inside: Nicaraguan and Mexican San Andres

Nica Rustica by Drew Estate – El Brujito

Liga Privada T-52 – Belicoso – 6 x 52 – Body: Full

Wrapper: Connecticut Habano . Inside: Nicaraguan, Dominican, Honduran, Brazilian

Liga Privada T-52 – Belicoso


Rocky Patel – Rocky Patel Cigars

Being the son of a ball bearing factory owner from India isn’t exactly a glamorous sounding beginning for one of the world’s most successful cigar makers. At age 14, his family moved to Green Bay, Wisconsin, where he later attended the state’s university. He moved to LA to attend law school and became an entertainment lawyer, where the clientele loved premium cigars. He would be on movie sets, and between takes, actors like Arnold Schwarzenegger and Mel Gibson would fire up premium sticks, and Rocky became hooked. Much to the chagrin of friends and associates who said he was nuts trying to enter the cigar industry, 1996 saw the birth of the Indian Tabac Cigar Company. People were immediately drawn to the colorful packaging adorned with Indian Motorcycle artwork and some damned tasty cigars inside. Things shifted as he began marketing his own name, and cigars early-on like the Decade and the Edge catapulted his success. After the introduction of many popular brands, the Rocky Patel Sun Grown Maduro was named the #2 Cigar of the Year in 2016, which was a defining accomplishment for the guy many have referred to as the hardest working man in the cigar industry.


Rocky Patel Sun Grown Maduro – Toro – 6 1/2 x 52 – Body: Full

Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro. Inside: Nicaraguan

Rocky Patel Sun Grown Maduro – Toro

Rocky Patel Vintage Connecticut 1999 – Petite Corona – 4 1/2 x 44 – Body: Mellow to Medium

Wrapper: 7 years aged Connecticut, Connecticut Shade. Inside: Dominican & Nicaraguan

Rocky Patel Vintage Connecticut 1999 – Petite Corona

newest oldest most voted
Korey Kimball
Korey Kimball

I haven’t tried any Tatuaje cigars yet but will make it a point on my next order. Great write up. Thank you.

Ray Csi
Ray Csi

Some good smokes right here by some gooooood cigar companies.

James Elliott
James Elliott

Don’t know how you leave Melillo off this list. Without him, Saka and Drew aren’t where they are today. He’s like the offensive lineman of the Drew team the from ’03-’13… all the work, none of the recognition. :-)

Vince Perez III
Vince Perez III

Nice read. A fan of all 5

George Parry
George Parry

I met Rocky Patel a few times in San Diego he is a very nice guy, we smoked and talked for a while.
He tells some GREAT storys….

Adrian Pulido
Adrian Pulido

They left out alot of drew estate early history. CA maybe doesn’t know.

Tommy Zman Zarzecki

Tommy Zman Zarzecki


Tommy Zman, is an obsessive enjoyer of life’s leafy pleasures. Growing up in the bowels of northern New Jersey, parented by an eccentric Polish father and a neurotic Italian mother, what else could this man possibly be other than a humorist? ZMan’s a real throwback to a time when men were kings of the castle and smoking a cigar in public didn’t label you an outcast and a pariah. He’s an old–school down to earth guy - but when it comes to p.c. tyranny and nanny-state legislature, he’ll draw his sword and swing for the fences. Tommy gathered a faithful following as a longtime feature writer at Cigar Magazine, and his testosterone laden FaceBook community, CROMAG NATION™ is truly the last great bastion for Men’s Men.

Show all Tommy Zman Zarzecki's Articles
best cigars for manning the grill Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: Best Cigars When You’re Manning the Grill

Whether you’re actually manning the grill or busy devouring all that barbecued goodness (or both) – here are the best cigars to pair with it all. WARNING: Read with caution; this may cause you to eat your monitor.

Read More
rafael nodal top 5 cigars cacover

5 Cigars That Made My Career: Rafael Nodal

Rafael Nodal has had a hand in blending some of the most renowned cigars in the world, gathering huge ratings and prestigious awards along the way…not bad for a kid who was picking oranges in Cuba at 15. Today, we sit with Rafael to discover the 5 cigars that influenced his style, earned him success, and give some little-known facts about your favorite Altadis and Boutique Blends.

Read More
10 Top Infused Flavored Cigars Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: 10 Infused & Flavored Cigars Under $5

10 Affordable Infused and Flavored Cigars You Could Be Smoking... Money matters; so does flavor....
Read More
small cigars for winter buying guide

2015 CA Report: Top Small Cigars for Winter Smoking

Too cold to smoke cigars outside? Can't smoke inside? No problem: brave the elements with these 6 small cigars and get big flavor as you brave the elements.
Read More