Cigars 101

Trading Cigars: A Guide

Some things to consider when trading cigars…

If you enjoy cigars, odds are you have a friend or group of friends you enjoy smoking with. One thing I’ve come to love about the cigar-smoking community is their eagerness to share, and resistance to pettiness.

However, once in a while, you’ll find yourself on the short end of the stick, so to speak. You’ve just given your buddy a long-lost Camacho 10th Anniversary 11/18, and he returns the favor with a bandless bundle special from the bottom of the humidor. Likely a decent smoke, for sure, but by no means fair when it comes to trading cigars.

In my mind, there are several things to consider when sharing cigars. When done in good-faith, it offers the double-benefit of expanding your cigar horizons while reaffirming camaraderie.

  1. If participating in an online trade, make sure you’re dealing with someone you can trust. Many forums have systems in place that indicate members’ trustworthiness.
  2. Don’t confuse a “gift” with a “trade.” If you gift a cigar, don’t expect anything in return. If you’re looking to trade in-kind, make it clear. If it’s more of an open-ended trade, don’t expect a cigar immediately. As the saying goes, “the best things come to those who wait.”
  3. Don’t let MSRP be your sole guide when offering a trade. Instead, take a moment to consider availability, price paid, and whether the recipient will actually enjoy the cigar. Macanudo Estate Reserve might be a $17 stick, but you have to wonder if it’s really a fair trade for a Padrón Serie 1926 80th Anniversary, especially if the other party prefers a full-bodied smoke.
  4. If offered an open-ended trade or gifted a cigar, accept it and thank your benefactor. The time will come when you smoke a cigar he or she would really enjoy, and when it does, return the favor graciously.

Trading cigars shouldn’t be about “getting ahead” or “tit for tat,” but rather about sharing some great sticks and trying stuff you don’t normally smoke. Use this as your ultimate guideline, and remember: always let your cigar-conscience be your guide.

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
5 Cigars that Made My Career: Alan Ruben of Alec Bradley Cigars - Cigar Advisor Cover

5 Cigars That Made My Career: Alan Rubin of Alec Bradley Cigars

Watch now and learn as AB founder Alan Rubin reveals the “wow” moments that shaped Alec Bradley cigar success, from his first smoke to finding out his cigar was chosen #1. Plus: Alan’s little-known blending tricks, and great “hard work” stories about your favorite Alec Bradley cigars…

Read More
Tricks to Cleans Your Palate between cigars CACover

5 Pros: Tricks to Cleanse Your Palate Between Cigars

Summertime is cigar time: and odds are, you’re smoking more than one cigar during an afternoon by the pool, or at night over drinks. For cigar makers, testing blends can lead to taste bud burnout. These 5 cigar pros will teach you tricks to cleanse your palate between cigars and enjoy the last one as much as the first.
Read More
top new cigars may 18 2018 CACover

CA Report: Top New Cigars – May 18 2018

You’ve already endured the sweaty days of mowing, power washing and weeding; so kick back, take a break and let us bring you the top new cigars this week: a soon-to-be-classic from Henry Clay, a rare Romeo, a C&A boutique gem, and a festive limited edition from our friends at CAO. Add these picks to your humidor now!
Read More
Perdomo Habano barrel aged cigar review CACover MWC

My Weekend Cigar: Feb. 12, 2018 – Perdomo Habano Barrel Aged Epicure

My Weekend Cigar was a pure Nicaraguan experience: the Perdomo Habano Barrel Aged Epicure, in a sun grown wrapper...it's the nuts: clocking in at a hefty 6x54, it's full bodied, smooth, and very reasonable. See what else I have to say about My Weekend Cigar from Perdomo, in this short review!
Read More