Cigar Lifestyle

Cigar Advisor Asks: What Was Your First Cigar?

Reading Time: 8 minutes

What Was Your First Cigar?

Cigar Advisor Asks Around: what was your first premium handmade cigar?

By Gary Korb

If someone were to ask, “Do you remember your first kiss?” odds are you’d say, “Yes.” The same is true for cigar smokers, most of whom do remember their first premium cigar. The keyword here is “premium” – not Garcia y Vega little cigars, Swisher Sweets, Phillies Blunts, Dutch Masters Panatelas, or other machine-made cigars, which, admittedly, are often gateway cigars to the premium cigar realm. I’m referring to cigars made entirely by hand somewhere in beautiful, downtown Central America.

Back in the 1980’s, I was smoking some now-defunct dry-cured cigars, but I had my first premium cigar in the early 1990’s, just prior to the cigar boom. My then wife and I had gone to one of the local clubs to see my friend’s band play. Behind the bar, I spotted a large desktop humidor, and after expressing my interest in its contents the bartender offered me a cigar menu. I chose a Don Tomás Special Edition Connecticut #200 mostly because at $7 it was the cheapest cigar in the list. To my surprise, it was wonderful; mild, nutty, creamy and aromatic. After that night, I was off to the races.

buy don tomas cigars special edition connecticut first cigar

Having worked at Famous Smoke Shop for nearly 15 years, as you might imagine, many of my coworkers also enjoy relaxing with a good cigar. Being the naturally curious person I am, I asked some of my colleagues, plus a few cigar business friends, if they remember their first premium cigar, and what follows are their stories. I also took the liberty of adding some good suggestions that may interest you while searching for your first premium cigar.

pullo first cigar don diego
John’s First Cigar: Don Diego

“My first premium was a Don Diego. Before that I was smoking Bering, which was machine-made. In college I had a friend – Mike – whose friend’s family owned a tobacco store in State College, PA. When he saw what I was smoking, he handed me the Don Diego and said, ‘Try one of these.’ We smoked our cigars on the steps of the music hall at the University of Scranton, which used to be a church; so in a way, you could say I got religion that day.” – John Pullo, Managing Copywriter (FSS)

buy don diego cigars online first cigar

In the 1960’s and 70’s, when most premium cigars were mild, Don Diego was the popular option to Macanudo cigars, and still enjoy a fair amount of popularity today. John’s buddy most likely offered the Diego for its mild Dominican tobaccos and smooth, well-rounded flavor. If you’re interested in trying a Don Diego and some other good mild cigars, this Dominican 6 Pack is a good place to start (It’s also got a couple of Macanudos).

Jose Blanco first cigar
Jose’s First Cigar: La Palma Petit Corona

“My first premium cigar was a La Palma Petit Corona, made at my uncle’s Tabacalera Palma factory in the Dominican Republic. I smoked it right there in the factory, and I remember many people saying, ‘He’s going to like cigars as his father.’ It was a bit strong for me, but as I reflect back on that time, I was getting to smoke what I saw my father doing everyday as I was growing up.” – José Blanco, Owner/Founder Las Cumbres Tabaco-Señorial Cigars

J_Detore padron 1964 first cigar
Jonathan’s First Cigar: Padron 1964 Annivesario

“My first premium was a Padrón 1964 Aniversario. My brother bought it for me on my 21st birthday. Actually, I did try a Toraño Signature my brother was smoking prior to smoking the Padrón, but I had only shared a few puffs, and it was way too strong for me. But the Padrón was fantastic. It’s a hard cigar to forget.” – Jonathan Detore, Copywriter, Marketing (FSS)

buy padron 1964 Anniversary cigars online first cigar

The Padrón 1964 Aniversario is not usually a cigar one would choose as a first premium for its full body, complex flavors, and higher price point. But if you’re interested in starting out with a Padrón, you may want to sample their mainline “Thousands” series that are medium in body and mighty-mighty tasty.

“My first premium cigar was a Romeo y Julieta Vintage #1. I bought it at Famous Smoke Shop in 2001 [before I worked here] and smoked it at a local bar. It was the first really good, mild-bodied cigar I ever smoked. I not only totally enjoyed the experience, but I stayed with that cigar for a few years. Once I began working at Famous my choices naturally expanded to other brands.” – Ed Bearby, Lead Sales, Customer Engagement (FSS)

buy romeo y julieta vintage cigars online first cigar

Khuong romeo y julieta first cigar cigar monster
Khuong’s First Cigar: Romeo y Julieta Churchill Tubo

“In the early 90’s my college buddies and I went on a cruise during Spring Break. In Barbados, I stopped into a cigar shop to check things out and I picked out a Romeo y Julieta Churchill Tubo. I lit it on the beach with a gin & tonic, surrounded by incredibly hot Bohemian women in thongs. It must’ve been the combination of atmosphere, gin, and women; but it all culminated in an amazing smoking experience. I instantly regretted only purchasing one single cigar. I went back to the cigar shop and purchased a 10 count box. That was the beginning of a very expensive lifestyle.” – Khuong Pham, Manager, Cigar

buy romeo y julieta churchill cigars online first cigarMost Romeo’s average medium in body, but all are well made in a variety of well-balanced blends and wrapper choices. Interested? You’ll find the Best of Julieta sampler offers a great selection at a nice price.

Yadi Gonzalez Vargas 90 miles cigars first cigar
Yadi’s First Cigar: Flor de Gonzalez Gold Series

“My first experience with a premium handmade cigar was the ‘Gold Series’ by Flor De Gonzalez given to me by my Dad. At the time [the mid 1990’s], the cigar boom was on, so I thought it would be an appropriate time to share a stogie with my friends from college during a get-together at one of their houses. The experience was fun and will always be cherished. For one, I was smoking a cigar that had just received an excellent rating by Cigar Aficionado, and to top it off, my dad was producing them! The taste of toasty nuts and creamy chocolate was so enchanting I got carried away with my puffing and made myself a little sick. Other than that, it was extremely pleasant, and the best part was that my friends and I had a great time shooting the breeze and comparing notes about our grand cigar smoking experience.” – Yadi Gonzalez-Vargas – President, Flor De Gonzalez Cigars

Erol Ata first cigar el rey del mundo cigar
Erol’s First Cigar: El Rey Del Mundo

“My first premium was an El Rey Del Mundo that I bought on my own and smoked back at my house. Beside the great flavors, the best part about it was taking the time to sit back with a fine cigar and escaping from the day-to-day hustle. It was the start of many hours of relaxing times to come.” – Erol Ata, Buyer, Purchasing Dept. (FSS)

Since El Rey Del Mundo are an exclusive brand, you won’t find them at most cigar retailers, but they’re made in the same factory as the classic Hoyo De Monterrey and Punch brands. That said, they may be a little too full for some newer smokers, so I suggest starting with Excalibur Cigars. They’re a little milder, yet still have plenty of rich Honduran flavor.

buy excalibur cigars first cigar

Tommy ZMan first cigar partagas
Tommy Zman’s First Cigar: Partagas

“I smoked my first premium cigar about 20 years ago at my brother in-law’s wedding at a time when you could actually celebrate indoors with a tasty stick. The best man picked up a bunch of Partagas #10’s for the guys, and that’s a pretty big stick for anybody’s first time. We lit up at the head table, and I can honestly say that I fell in love with cigars from the very first puff. I remember sitting there in my tux feeling like royalty as we drank scotch, while a cloud of fragrant blue smoke wafted above our heads. 20 years later, and yeah, I’m still in love.”  – Tommy Zman, Founder, Cromag Nation Community

buy partagas cigars online first cigar

Partagas cigars are another classic brand that’s kept up with the surge in complex, full-bodied cigars over the years by releasing a number of excellent line extensions. But if you want to share Tommy’s experience from their core line, you’ll find the Partagas #10 and all the other sizes here.

Hal Odzic te amo first cigar
Hal’s First Cigar: Te Amo

“In the late 1970’s, I was working at a supermarket. We were setting up some displays and the manager asked me to run over to the smoke shop across the street and get him a pack of Te-Amo cigars. I brought them back and he said I bought the wrong wrapper. I don’t remember if he wanted natural and I bought maduro, or vice versa, but in any event, I went back and exchanged them. When I returned, he offered me one, and that was it. – Hal Odzic, Catalog Manager (FSS)

buy te amo cigars online first cigar

jenny ryan perdomo first cigar
Jenny’s First Cigar: Perdomo Champagne

“My first premium was also my first cigar, a Perdomo Champagne. I chose it myself, because I knew the brand had a great reputation, and since I like Champagne, I imagined that a cigar named “Champagne” would be very enjoyable, which it was. – Jennifer Ryan, Merchandiser, Purchasing (FSS)

buy perdomo champagne cigars first cigarJennifer made a good call by choosing the Perdomo Champagne, but Perdomo makes so many excellent cigars, you might be interested in this Best of Perdomo sampler, which includes the Champagne and several more savory Perdomo selections.

Steve Saka first cigar
Steve’s First Cigar: a gifted stick from his Ops Officer

“My very first handmade cigar was given to me by a Senior Chief Gunner’s Mate while serving as an enlisted “squid” about the USS Connole (FF-1056) in 1995. We were on an extended deployment in the Mediterranean Sea and it was smoked above deck while the ship was searching for Russian Akula-class subs. I do not recall the brand, I just remembered it being extremely dark and powerful, too strong actually as he berated me for looking ‘green around the gills’ and ‘to grow a pair.’ Gotta’ love the abuse… Thankfully my Ops Officer, Lt. Walter S. Laird, took pity on me and started sharing his selection of much better quality premium handmades with me soon after. It was unusual for a Line Officer to associate with a young Petty Officer socially and it was then I realized that handmade cigars were much more than just smoke.”  – Steve Saka, Owner/Founder, Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust

Now it’s your turn! Please leave a comment telling us about your first premium handmade cigar experience.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Steven S. Pitruzzello
6 years ago

Tough to be sure since it was a long time ago, but I think my first premium was a Te Amo Celebration. It came in a heavy glass tube with a rubber seal. I still have one or two in one of my humidors which I hesitate to smoke because I know I can’t get ’em anymore. Really liked that stick!

Ryan Hoffman
6 years ago

Onyx Reserve

John Tucker Jr.
6 years ago

It was in the mid 90’s…my son was born in ’92 and I didn’t want to give out garbage-as so MANY new fathers do-. In my tastings, I had a CAO Gold?…it was a double corona that came in a glass tube….Niiiccceee! Too nice to give away – so I got a Good (cheaper) cigar for the Give Aways.

Jose Garcia
6 years ago

My first cigar was a cohiba robusto in Cuba with my wife.
Now she syas she created a monster, it was her idea for us to try a cigar.

Doug Rogers
6 years ago

Had to think hard, but I believe it was a Troya that got me started. Back the. It was a premium, medium-bodied stick, but over the years has become a machine made only smoke. That led me to Bauza and Te Amo. First box I ever bought was Te Amo Celebration in the glass tubes. You could only get 10 at a time I believe. Great memories.

Tim Ferrell
6 years ago

Old La Gloria Cubana Torpedo

Eric Bear
6 years ago

My 1st cigar ever. Rocky Patel Vntage 1990. I’ve only had the opportunity to enjoy 7 cigars so far. 2 RP Vntage 1990, 1RP Nicaraguan, 2 Oliva G series, 1 Perdomo Lot 23 and 1 Cuban Parejo. I’m such a novice. I have some Oliva series G toro, Rocky Patel Ncaraguan Toro, and some Nub cafe Espresso and Room 101 Payback ordered and shipped waiting for delivery. I’m considering ordering Asylum 13 Barber Pole wrapped. I’m learning.

Gregg Somers
6 years ago

When I asked the guy in the shop for the best stick under $10, he handed me an Arturo Fuente “Short Story”. Great smoke.

R. Clay Barnes
6 years ago

I went to a little cigar shop in Seattle in 1992. I can’t remember the name but Im sure its closed now since the state of Washington has destroyed the cigar industry in our state. I asked the tobacconist about what I should try and she said that being a newbie I should buy a Macanudo Hyde Park. I can remember it like it was yesterday. That stick got me hooked.

Christopher Morse
6 years ago

In high school circa 1998 CAO anniversary gold band on it. I believe it was a Cameroon. Been hooked ever since.

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles

Cigar News: Pledge Lonsdale Limitada Joins E.P.C. Pledge Cigars Line

Reading Time: 2 minutes E.P. Carrillo Cigars’ Pledge cigars selection, which earned them 2020’s Cigar of the Year announced that they’re adding the Lonsdale Limitada to the Pledge line based on the brand’s followers’ request for a smaller ring gauge cigar. Read all about it.

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review the shepherd - cover

#NowSmoking: The Shepherd

Reading Time: 4 minutes Pospiech, Inc. co-founder, Mike Szczepankewicz, and Matt Booth teamed-up for The Shepherd, a limited edition one-off with a bold profile. For this review Gary dug into its undisclosed blend saying, “it’s got cojones,” but that’s not all. Watch and read what else he discovered.

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review - macanudo vintage 2010 cover

NowSmoking: Macanudo Vintage 2010

Reading Time: 4 minutes Travel back to the classic “Connecticut” cigars of yesteryear as Gary gives his review of the Macanudo Vintage 2010 Torpedo. Built on a 10-year-aged U.S. Connecticut Shade capa see what this cigar’s mellow character and nuanced flavor set have to offer.

Read More
nat sherman timeless sterling cigar review short robusto Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Review: Nat Sherman Timeless Sterling Cigar Review – Short Robusto

Nat Sherman Timeless Sterling Short Robusto Cigar Review Country of Origin: Dominican...
Read More