Food & Drink

Why Bourbon Kicks Scotch’s Ass – Bourbon And Cigars

Reading Time: 5 minutes

If you’re like most folks, you either a) prefer scotch or, b) prefer bourbon. Yeah, sure there are other types of whiskeys (or whiskys if you fall into that “a” category), but unless you’re Canadian or Irish, you’re really only interested in bourbon or scotch. Most are attracted to scotch right away. They’ve heard it’s a noble drink, one for the gentleman, one that “the most interesting man in the world” probably drinks. Well considering his beer of choice is Dos Equis, I’m not trusting this guy with my drink of choice! Well, in case you haven’t gathered the tone of this opening statement, I’m about to tell you why bourbon kicks scotch’s ass. In addition Bourbon pairs well with your favorite cigar.

Scattered across the balmy wetlands of the Kentucky marsh, encased somewhere inside a stretch of black, moss-laden vegetation, lay rickety old shacks; all housing thousands of barrels of bourbon, aging to perfection. The sweltering hot air of the humid climate has no hiding places, making its way into the heart of the oak barrels and pulling at the whiskey within. Expanding and contracting in unison with the weather, the bourbon burrows into the charred oak. It is here that bourbon takes on a dark, caramel brown tone, and draws warm, sweet and oaky nuances from the charred wood. It’s not smooth, it’s bold, it doesn’t go down easy, it comes up like a fire, it makes no apologies, it’s born and raised in the USA, it’s Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey.

There’s something grand about bourbon, a prideful feeling that you’re somehow a part of its gritty, rough-and-tumble past. When I sip at a glass of barrel proof bourbon, thoughts of Wild West saloons, old time bar fights, and backwoods moonshinin’ outlaws fill my head. It’s a distinctly American drink, with a bold, in-your-face character, and yet sweet, like your grandma’s oatmeal cookies. One thing I find so interesting about straight bourbon is the rigorous regulation it adheres to. If you’re unfamiliar with the bourbon “routine”, allow me to show you the ropes.

Bourbon must be 100% made in the USA. Purists may even tell you it needs to be Kentucky-bred, but made anywhere in the United States will technically pass as bourbon. Bourbon must also be made from a recipe of no less than 51% corn (if it wasn’t already American enough). Here’s where it gets really interesting: all bourbon MUST be aged in new, charred oak barrels. Use a barrel once and it is toast, never to be touched by the sweet, golden liquid again (well, at least on American soil…). “Why is this last step so important?” you ask. “Because the freshly charred oak barrels contain bold, untapped flavors!” I answer. This is why a 15 year old bottle of bourbon is typically about 5 shades darker than a scotch of the same age. It’s also one of the reasons bourbon is bold and scotch is weak… I mean smooth, excuse me. But I don’t mean to speak out of turn, we must first pay our respects to the granddaddy of whiskies.

Contrast all this Wild West whiskey talk to a very similar spirit being distilled over 3,000 miles “across the pond”. Bourbon’s (not so) distant relative, it’s the original, it has the history, and a strict set of guidelines to insure its legendary quality – let’s take a quick peak at our friend, scotch.

This is an old beverage, no doubt, with its beginnings over 500 years back! King James IV preferred the drink, as did George IV and Queen Victoria; which added to ol’ scotch’s “street cred”, and is now well-known as the (unofficial) drink of sophistication. “It’s a smooth drink”, you’ll hear enthusiasts boast of the finer, more matured single malt offerings. You see, scotch fans take pride in 3 factors that make up their beloved drink (as far as I can assess). History: scotch is older therefore it’s better (I think there’s more to it than that). Drinkability: the idea here is that the longer a whisky ages, the smoother it becomes (how elegant). Exclusivity: it’s expensive, it’s dry, and you’re probably not going to like it right away, in other words – it’s an acquired taste (what a bunch of hipsters…).

Like bourbon, scotch too has a precise standard to which all must be held accountable. Scotch must be made in Scotland, good for the Scots! It needs to be at least 80 proof and made from malted barley. It may contain no added substances, other than water and plain caramel coloring. Wait, what was that last part? Caramel coloring? You’d think scotch would have a more “manly” hue to it if they’re going to the trouble of manipulating the color… Now then, all scotch must be aged in oak casks for a minimum of 3 years. Notice I didn’t say “new” oak casks, that’s because scotch can be aged in any barrel, so long as it’s oak. Remember when I mentioned bourbon barrels are only used once? What I meant was they are only used once by bourbon manufacturers, they are then transported to other distilleries all over the world, including (you guessed it) Scotland. So when you’re sipping at your aged glass of scotch and you notice a subtle, sweet note, that’s just a little slice of bourbon DNA – you’re welcome.

In addition Bourbon and cigars is a match made in heaven. Being primarily a cigar enthusiast (and owner of the social cigar app Cigar Dojo), I continuously find myself in the midst of the ever-popular “what is the best drink to pair with your cigar” debate. Coffee, wine, craft beer, even sodas are thrown around as favorites; but 9 out of 10 times the discussion comes down to the big guns: bourbon and scotch. The thing that amazes me is how instantly biased people are in favor of scotch over bourbon. It’s as if there is no contest, it’s the cigar smoker’s default choice. Maybe it’s all they’ve ever known, maybe it just sounds like the right thing to do, and maybe (most definitely) it’s because these cigar fanatics have never experienced a “real” pour of true, Kentucky straight bourbon.

To me the choice is obvious, the two go hand in hand. Allow me to explain if I may. I’m sure most will recall the great cigar boom of the ’90s. There was so much demand for hand rolled cigars that manufacturers started rolling up darn-near anything they could get their hands on! But not all manufacturers subjected themselves to these shoddy practices; it was out of this era that we were given the infamous Fuente Opus X and Padron 1964 cigars, something the cigar world won’t soon forget. Some might say we’re now in the midst of a “second wave” cigar boom. Perhaps not as strong as the first, but this time manufacturers have the resources to combat the craze. Cigar fanatics are going crazy for that oily, tobacco goodness. Everything is bigger, bolder, and stronger – it’s all about the in-your-face flavor bomb cigar. Limited editions and rarities are being traded around like gold on the black market. Sure, not all these “newfangled” cigars have the lasting power, but that’s what’s fun about the cigar hobby; it’s the thrill of the chase, and putting those taste buds to work!

This is where bourbon comes back into the picture – if you’re searching for a flavor workout, look no further than small batch Kentucky straight bourbon. You see, the bourbon world is sort of going through its own “boom”. It was in the early 1990’s that the world was introduced to Booker’s, a small batch bourbon that was uncut, unfiltered, and bottled straight from the barrel. What this all means is that this bourbon will punch you in the face with flavor! Soon Booker’s was joined by fellow distilleries looking to reprise age-old recipes in their purest form. Small batch, single barrel, barrels aged at sea, tornado bourbon… these are just some of the crazy concoctions being spun-out by Kentucky distilleries today. Old Rip Van Winkle Distillery produces a product so rare and delicious, that on its annual release each fall, you can expect to find lines of grown men winding around liquor stores across the country! This is the kind of fired-up attitude cigar smokers can appreciate. We crave the bold, the rare, and the unique – and that is exactly what bourbon has to offer.

Do yourself a favor, next time you reach for that smoky, peat-infused scotch, pair it next to a barrel proof bourbon and let their subtle complexities and differences vie for the title of your palate. You may just find yourself a wee bit surprised.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David Mallory
7 years ago

I do have to say that I prefer bourbon over scotch!!

Glenn Gibson
6 years ago

Make that two Bourbon over scotch fans

Jim Sherlock
6 years ago

Blanton’s a fave……

Michael Bardo
6 years ago

Love Blanton’s, but then there’s Elmer T. Lee!

Douglas A. Beilharz
6 years ago

“There’s another American whiskey” he said wryly, “It’s Rye whiskey”. If you like bourbon’s strong taste, try a bottle of Breakout (excellent rye) or Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey (you will be amazed.) DO NOT TRY Crown Royal Rye! ! ! It shames the Crown Royal name. Crown Royal Canadian whiskey is both flavorful and smooth beyond belief; their rye attempt disappoints beyond description.

Marc Lambert
6 years ago

Hey Eric. I’m a big fan of ur Dojo and happy to see u writing elsewhere, but brother I gotta disagree here. I generally prefer Scotch or Rye bec I favor smokey & peaty over sweet & rich, but much depends on the cigar being paired as some work better with the bourbon long sweet finish. On the other hand, my palatte craves complexity and diversity, so often enjoys contrast and cleansing over compatible & similar flavors. Depends alot on what ur goals r for the experience- something I’d like to hear u discuss. Thx for the food for thought!

mike steele
4 years ago

Might be the best article I have ever read! Very well put – and so true!

4 years ago

Wow, you make Bourbon sound so cool and exciting! It’s to bad Bourbon’s flavour is flat and simplistic, if it was more complicated and interesting I would probably drink it more. Also, as a member of the Whisk(e)y Tribe I must say you got a few things wrong about what Scotch Enthusiasts like about scotch. The only people that like the whiskey for the age are people who think it’s a good whiskey because they saw Don Draper drinking it on Mad Men, yes I know someone like this. This is not an enthusiast trait, it is a fan trait. The longer a Scotch ages it does get smoother as there is more Angel Share. The core whiskies in any well established Scottish distillery is going to a 10 year old scotch and then some non-age statement whiskies. 10-16 year old whiskey is what most scotch lovers hover around as their go to bottles. I tend to prefer whiskies in that age range myself. My next critique is that of cost. Cost is subjective to the city and country of purchase. I haven’t had to many $70 whiskies I didn’t think was worth more than that. Also, I have never thought my whiskies were dry and they definitely are not an acquired taste. There are so many different whiskies in Scotland that you can just try a different one if there is one you don’t like. Admittedly, there is much controversy over distilleries using caramel colouring. This has actually resulted in most big name distilleries not using it. Crisis averted. Now, let me turn my attention to what this site really cares about. I am no stranger to Bourbon and cigar smoking. I quite enjoy it, though I would not consider myself an enthusiast. I do find it interesting that for your big climax, after saying why bourbon is more interesting you say it is superior because of the combination with cigar smoke. As if cigars aren’t an acquired taste and scotch doesn’t have it’s own built in smoke. There are so many different types of cigars to try and so many different types of Whisk(e)y to try that you should just try them and see what you like. Saying one is better than the other is akin to snobbery. In the Whisk(e)y Tribe there are only two rules pertaining to good whiskey. 1. The best Whiskey is the whiskey you like to drink. 2. The best way to drink it is the way you want to. Anyone whom says otherwise is being a pretentious a** hole(that is actually part of the rule). Some people prefer whiskey flavoured water(whiskey in their water), some prefer whiskey flavoured Coke(whiskey in their Coke) and some prefer whiskey flavoured smoke(whiskey in their tobacco). However you want to experience it is all well and good but don’t tell people that one is better than the other simply because you want to sell people a cigar.

Emanuel Stamathis
4 years ago

First of all Bourbon, or Scotch enhance cigars PERIOD no matter what the alcohol marketeers try to brainwash you with! You may love either of the two and that’s fine but those spirits first lack sweetness that objectively ENHANCES cigars. Secondly they are too full bodied and strong and will squelch our complexities of the strongest of cigars. Sweet drinks enhance and also cleanse the pallet. Sugar is a pallet cleanser in the way Sorbet used to be used in between meal courses at fine restaurants. This is why Port Wines, champagnes, sweet wines like Riesling’s, Rum, soft drinks, dark chocolate etc.are top drinks and food that enhance cigar smoking experience. Whether you like those sweeter drinks or not, it doesn’t change the chemical Physiology of taste buds. During cigar taste tests, judges use soft drinks to cleanse their pallets in between cigar sampling, not bourbons or scotch. Guys, put your manhood down for a minute and stop being fanboys to the new “manly in drinks” that are popular at the moment (insert bourbon now). It always confounds me when someone who loves bourbon or scotch try to tell me they get sweetness and then I answer with bs, you just like that spirit but it DOES NOT ENHANCE THE SUBTLETIES OF THE CIGAR ITSELF!

Emanuel Stamathis
4 years ago

Edit, first sentence, “DO NOT ENHANCE”!

3 years ago

Don’t let anybody brainwash you into drinking something. A bottle of 10 year old Laphroaig will be as enjoyable as a bottle of Blantons under the right circumstances. Figure out what you like,not what someone else likes. That’s the enjoyment of this ride. These great blogs get you going in the right or wrong direction but ultimately enjoy whatever makes your tastebuds happy.

Master Sensei

Master Sensei

Cigar Dojo Eric G AKA "Master Sensei", is a web developer, graphic artist, SEO, and social media expert, as well as mastermind behind the Cigar Dojo app (the world's greatest social cigar app). With years and years of internet development experience Eric has designed and created dozens of web properties for clients of all sizes. In addition to cigars Eric is also a bourbon and craft beer enthusiast and recently completed the IveHadThat app and website. Eric's passion is defending the principles of right vs. wrong and doing his part to preserve our ever shrinking freedoms via battling the cancer of socialism. Master Sensei says... "cigar's are a symbol of freedom and are a microcosm of a much larger battle." Whoa... deep eh? As a relatively new cigar smoker (only a few years) Eric's passion for the cigar smoking lifestyle is at a fevered pitch, he describes his passion for cigars as being like a kid in a candy store.

Show all Master Sensei's Articles
cigar advisor top new cigars september 18 2023 - cover

Top New Cigars (September 18, 2023)

Reading Time: 3 minutes Want a fresh cigar that impresses? Look no further! This week on Top New Cigars, we’re reviewing the latest from Espinosa, Warped, and Black Label Trading Company. From Cuban tradition to 10-year anniversaries, it’s all covered inside!

Read More
cigar advisor food for thought: using food to choose the best cigar for you - cover

Food for Thought: A Better Way to Choose the Right Cigar for You

Reading Time: 6 minutes Have you been choosing your cigars the wrong way all along? Senior Famous Smoke Shop Purchaser, Humberto Gonzalez thinks so. See his method of using food to determine what you should be smoking…and why we think it’s a better way to start smoking.

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review don reynaldo regalos by warped - cover

#NowSmoking: Don Reynaldo Regalos by Warped

Reading Time: 3 minutes This review of the Don Reynaldo Regalos by Warped might be more appropriate for Father’s Day. The limited production cigar was created by Kyle Gellis as a tribute to his father who loved Cuban cigars. Read on to see if he hit the mark.

Read More
Top 8 Best Rated CAO Cigars Cigar advisor Cover

2021 CA Report: Top 8 Best Rated CAO Cigars Under $10

Reading Time: 7 minutes Stop letting one dude in a suit speak for you and everyone else. In our Best-Rated CAO Cigars Under $10 guide, we put our faith in cigar consumers like you for the final say in what blends are best!

Read More