About 6 months ago, I was looking for a good Maduro, that would still fit my budget. Took a chance on the Private Stock #2 Maduro, and it has now become my everyday cigar of choice. The Narural isn't bad either, I just happen tp prefer the Maduro.
I am mystified by the generously high ratings this cigar has received. In my opinion, this smoke is no bargain: It simply has no personality, is devoid of all flavor. Likely, I'll end up tossing out the remaining 24 and place an order for some of my regular reliables.
I'm not big on mild cigars but this is one exception. This cigar offers great flavor not found in most mild cigars that I've had, well worth the money. And they're made by Davidoff so you know they're made with love!1 2
The draw, burn and flavor are as good as any $20 stick I've ever smoked, I'm lighting my 15th out of 25 and no disappointment yet. These would be a steal at $100 a box. When Davidoff is involved, count on perfection.0 1
A terrific, consistent cigar for the money.0 0
By no means is this even close to being a second. Very good taste, smooth, burn and draw. Very good from beginning to end.9 5
I keep trying other brands but keep comming back to this one.1 0
I found these to burn and taste as good or better than some of my much more expensive Dominican sticks. No touch-ups required and great draw and flavor. Great construction as well.0 0
These cigars are as good or better than most 94 or 95 rated cigars that I have smoked.0 0
I have gone through two boxes......A well made, great smoke..Love the #14 ! This is very similar to the classic AVO for much less money. These are among my favorites..In my opinion they stand side by side with much more expensive cigars. A very consistant,clean smoke.If you like them mild and tasty, they don't get much better !!!0 1
This is by far the best value and smoke you can get. I fell in love with them when I first got introduced. They are cheaper on line, than they are in my local cigar shop.0 0
I have tried CAO gold, AVO, Ashton 898, Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real, PS#2 is the absolute show, Mild, flavorful, Excellent notes of PB, Cedar, Light toasted almonds. MY #1 FAV,Great all aroud home stoge or a handout. Dave COLUMBIA SC.4 3