Cigar Buying Guides

10 Classic Cigars to Revisit Immediately

10 You Need: Classic Cigars to Revisit Immediately

Do you remember your first cigar? You probably recall the experience – or at least, who was around at the time, or who might have given it to you. Mine was a Don Diego corona gifted by my friend Mike, who had a few years of premium cigar experience and a friend who owned a shop. Apparently he saw in me a lost soul, yet a potential BOTL, when I remarked, “wow…those Garcia y Vegas come in tubes? They must be nice.”

The Don Diego was a treat – and as I made my way into the cigar world, I learned…tried…sampled…smoked…and just (I’m sure) like you, found new and exciting things to fill my humidor with that were decidedly un-Don Diego-ish. My palate developed and I found new tastes and sensations in premium cigars; I learned what “toasty” tasted like, and so on. But looking back, there were some classic cigars along the way that – even though they were really good – I just drifted away from, almost never to return, for no reason other than having been lured away like a hungry trout at a fishing derby. The choices! And that’s when I decided I needed to try these cigars again, and see how much (or even if) I still liked ‘em.

The bad news: many of my old go-to’s are discontinued. As the Boom went bust, many brands crashed and burned; leaf supplies dried up, and some smokes were never to be rolled again. Some were no loss, but others are still a standard by which I judge today’s sticks (fare thee well, Oliva Special S – I will always remember). So I rounded up 10 from back in the day, and gave them another try; here’s what happened…

AF Chateau Fuente Sun Grown

Size: Belicoso (5 3/4 x 52)                      Strength: Medium

Arturo Fuente Chateau Fuente Sun Grown belicoso cigar

Your first Fuente might have been a Curly Head, but this was my first exposure to sun-grown wrapper – as well as using a v-cutter on a torpedo. I always enjoyed these classic cigars, and now I remember why: Dominican tobacco that’s done like no one else can…and still does. If Arturo Fuente has fallen off your radar – you need new radar.


Ashton Classic

Size: Magnum (5×50)                                  Strength: Mild

Ashton classic cigar magnum

The classic mild cigar story: aged Dominican filler meets up with Connecticut Shade wrapper; creaminess ensues. Because I was an inexperienced smoker at the time, Ashton taught me a thing or two about mild cigars with body and flavor – and it was one of the first cigars I ever smoked to the nub. And I did it again.



Size: Robusto (5×49)                                    Strength: Medium

Cohiba cigar Robusto

The cigar that even non-smokers know: “hey, is that a Cohiba?” (I’m sure you’ve heard that.) People knock it because they think this Dominican version doesn’t hold up to the Cuban Cohiba; truth be told, you’ll be keeping a few of these in your humidor, and maybe even getting a dog to guard them. Try it again with an open mind, if you don’t believe me.


Carlos Toraño Exodus 1959

Size: Robusto (5×52)                                    Strength: Medium

carlos torano exodus 1959 cigar

What I forgot: this smoke intensifies in flavor AND body as it burns. What I remembered: how much I like the 5-nation blend, and the fact that this stick just burps big smoke from start to finish. If you want a refresher on what complexity is all about, revisit this cigar immediately.


Dunhill Aged

Size: Condados (6×48)                     Strength: Mild-Medium

Dunhill Aged cigar condados

We all have a special occasion cigar; though newer things have since replaced it, this was mine at one time. I got turned on to it because a friend smoked Dunhill cigarettes. Smooth, elegant, consistent and DELICIOUS, this Dominican super-premium has always been worth the splurge – even if the occasion isn’t special.

Excalibur #1

Size: Churchill (7 ¼ x 54)                Strength: Medium

hoyo de monterrey #1 churchill cigar

Connecticut-creamy, smoking it again had me up to my eyes in mellow flavor in no time…and that’s because Excalibur uses the cream of the crop (literally) tobaccos, as they’re rolled in the same factory as Hoyo de Monterrey. I think the Excalibur has been around as long as I have – but so what? A solid 10: it still smokes great. Do it.


La Gloria Cubana

Size: Wavell (5×50)                          Strength: Medium

la gloria cubana cigar wavell

To everyone who dumps on “old man” cigars: my old man taught me when to fight, and how to fix my car – so I’ll take it as a compliment. LGC was a Boom all-star and a brief go-to, so it didn’t take much arm-twisting to light it again. Classic looking and tasting, medium body is my wheelhouse…a bold and rich payoff. Great value, too.


El Rico Habano

Size: Corona Suprema (6×50)         Strength: Full

el rico habano cigar corona suprema

Meet my first full-bodied cigar – and the one that gave me my first serious case of the sweats. I forgot how incredibly aromatic this cigar is, but had no problem recalling its Nicaraguan tobacco-inspired lust for power. If you like ‘em strong, drop what you’re smoking and give El Rico Habano another try…you won’t be disappointed.


Sancho Panza Extra Fuerte

Size: Barcelona (6 ½ x 48)              Strength: Full

sancho panza extra fuerte cigar barcelona

I was going through a phase where all I smoked was Honduran cigars (don’t ask), and even then I knew this one stood apart from most of them. Spicy and peppery, “robust” doesn’t even begin to cover it: noobs are on notice. Still stands tall, though – all business, and burns great. If I stay on the “nice” list, maybe I’ll get a box for Christmas.


RP Vintage 1992

Size: Torpedo (6 ¼ x 52)                 Strength: Medium

rocky patel vintage 1992 cigar torpedo

A Nicaragua-Dominican blend with a Mexican binder, it’s a 52-ring buttered biscuit of delight. The smoke output is a little thinner than others on the exhale, but the flavors more than make up for it – and there are many of them. Other solid blends have come from the Patel family in recent years, but this is Rocky at his best.


One more bright spot about this list of classic cigars you need to try again: they’re all pre-2007. That matters, if the FDA institutes their “substantial equivalence” testing clause when they make their final ruling regarding premium cigar regulation. Premiums that were on the market before February 2007 would be grandfathered; subsequent products released would be required to undergo an extensive (translated: expensive) testing period, to make sure that a blend has the same characteristics (materials, ingredients, design, composition, etc.) and raises no new questions of health when compared with the pre-2007 standard-bearers. Sounds simple, but it’s not; FDA has been reviewing almost 4000 cigarette applications for 4 years, and ruled on fewer than 1% of them.

On the plus side, if the FDA lowers the hammer on cigars – you’ll still be able to smoke these 10.

Did I miss any? Make a comment below, and shout at me.

Leave a Reply

5 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
0 Comment authors
Marty HoarJohn MooreCharles Duke FuerteDarryl ButlerSteve Miller Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Darryl Butler
Darryl Butler

It’s tough to revisit those oldies but goodies when there’s so many cigars to choose from. It is to many cigars to choose from period.

Steve Miller
Steve Miller

Great to see two of my faves on the list. Ashton Magnum is my guilty pleasure and the Wavell is always in my humidor.

John Moore
John Moore

A lot of GREAT cigars on here. That Ashton was my first! Oddly surprising how many I have had.

Marty Hoar
Marty Hoar

El Ricos are a must try. A great high powered offering from General.

Charles Duke Fuerte
Charles Duke Fuerte

The Excaliber #1 & the Sancho Panza Extra Fuerte Madrid are 2 of my all time favorites.

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
5 Tips for buying your first humidor Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Quick Guide: 5 Tips for Buying Your First Humidor

Use these quick starter humidor buying tips to shorten the learning curve and find the right cigar storage solution to fit your needs!

Read More
2018 top thanksgiving cigars cacover

2018 CA REPORT: Thanksgiving Cigars – Different Smokes for Different Folks

Just as there are many tasty food choices for Thanksgiving dinner, not every dish suits every palate; the same goes for your Turkey Day smokes. See our top hand-rolled premium picks for Thanksgiving cigars that will satisfy every kind of smoker on your holiday guest list!

Read More

#NowSmoking: Four Kicks Black Belt Buckle

Trending: #nowsmoking Four Kicks Black Belt Buckle Sublime, a Maduro from Crowned Heads Cigars...see our 10-second cigar review of this Toro here, and share! Find us on Instagram: @famoussmokeshop and @cigaradvisor
Read More
Top 10 Oscuro Cigars Buying Guide

2015 CA Report: Top 10 Recommended Oscuro Cigars

Learn about oscuro cigars: what makes an oscuro wrapper so, and what to expect from this distinctive tobacco. Plus: 10 great cigars with oscuro wrappers!
Read More