Cigar Buying Guides

Top 10 Maduro Cigars to Smoke on Halloween

Reading Time: 5 minutes

Our 10 Best Maduro Cigar Picks to Enjoy on Halloween

Updated October 2023

Maduros are often lauded as the ‘candy bars’ of the cigar world. And for good reason. The leaves’ extra fermentation leaves them a bit mellower and a lot sweeter—the perfect complement to almost any blend. That’s also why they’re must-have smokes on Halloween.

The holiday may revolve around carved pumpkins, costumes, and trick or treating, but for cigar loving adults, it’s the prime occasion to enjoy a chocolatey Maduro. Whether you’re huddled around a campfire, rehashing that  “one time at football camp” story, or just chilling on your porch, a premium Maduro is your best Halloween prop. From the big-shot brands to the underdogs, we’ve curated a list of 10 dark-leaf treats for new smokers and experienced smokers alike!

Have a favorite cigar of your own to smoke on All Hallow’s Eve? Let us know about it in the comments below!


Blackened M81 (Metallica) by Drew Estate

Body: Full

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - drew estate metallica blackened maduro at famous smoke shop

We knew from the second we heard that James Hetfield was working with Drew Estate, that the cigar they landed on was gonna sell out fast. What we didn’t expect, however, was that Blackened was going to be as refined, complex, and delicious as it was. It would have been easy for Drew to cash in on the iconic Metallica name and half-ass the cigar, but they painstakingly blended it over several years. The result: a pulse-quickening recipe of high-octane tobaccos—snug in their Mexican San Andres wrapper—with notes of espresso, pepper, earth, and semi-sweet chocolate chips. My summary in a word…encore.


CAO Flathead

Body: Full

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - cao flathead maduro at famous smoke shop

From the onset, CAO Flathead weaves a rich tapestry of sweet flavors, dominant with notes of dark cocoa and roasted coffee beans. These are beautifully complemented by hints of black cherry and a subtle, peppery kick. The experience is made even more memorable by its velvety, thick smoke and an impeccably even burn. The Flathead is more than just a cigar; it’s a journey into the depths of flavor, making it a standout choice for those seeking a robust and captivating smoking experience.


Charter Oak Maduro

Body: Mellow+

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - charter oak maduro at famous smoke shop

Unbeatable at its price, Foundation Cigar’s Charter Oak Maduro is one of the best examples of how Maduros don’t need to be strong to be delicious. Indulge in rich notes of dark chocolate and espresso, with hints of dried plum and a touch of earthy leather. As the cigar burns, there’s a gentle emergence of sweet molasses and a hint of spice, adding layers to the experience. The burn is commendably even, with a smoke that’s both aromatic and creamy. For those seeking a well-rounded, flavorful journey, the Charter Oak Maduro is a delightful choice.


Cohiba Black

Body: Medium

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - cohiba black at famous smoke shop

From the outset, Cohiba’s celebrated Black blend boasts a dark, oily wrapper with an intense flavor journey. As you take the first draw, a robust blend of espresso and dark chocolate greets the palate, complemented by subtle hints of dried fruit and spice. The experience is further elevated by its creamy undertones and a touch of earthiness. The burn is impeccable, producing a fragrant, velvety smoke that envelops the senses. For those seeking a rich, full-bodied experience with a touch of elegance, trusty ol’ Black delivers on all fronts.


H. Upmann Nicaragua AJ Fernandez Heritage

Body: Full

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - h. upmann 1844 aj fernandez maduro at famous smoke shop

From the moment it’s lit, AJ’s take on H. Upmann unveils a tantalizing array of flavors. Rich notes of roasted coffee beans meld seamlessly with nuances of sweet cedar and a hint of cinnamon. As the smoke progresses, there’s a delightful interplay of creamy nuttiness and a touch of dark fruit. The experience is further enhanced by its even burn and silky smoke, making each puff a sensory delight. This cigar is a testament to the mastery of its creators, offering a balanced and deeply satisfying smoking journey.


Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial

Body: Full

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - jaime garcia reseva especial maduro at famous smoke shop

From the first draw, there’s an unmistakable richness, with notes of dark chocolate, espresso, and a hint of black pepper. As the Connecticut Broadleaf wrapped blend progresses, subtle undertones of leather and cedar emerge, resulting in a complex and layered flavor profile. Overall, Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial offers a memorable experience for both novice and seasoned alike. Highly recommended for those seeking depth in flavor and a refined smoking journey.


JFR Maduro by Aganorsa Leaf

Body: Full

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - jfr maduro at famous smoke shop

Its deep, alluring wrapper sets the stage for a flavor profile that’s both robust and intricate. From first draw, there’s a delightful burst of dark cocoa and roasted nuts, seamlessly blending with undertones of ripe berries and a hint of leather. As the experience unfolds, a gentle spiciness adds depth and complexity to each puff. The burn is consistently even, producing a rich, velvety smoke that lingers pleasantly on the palate. For aficionados seeking a balanced yet bold experience, the JFR Maduro is a standout choice.


Padron 1964 Maduro

Body: Full

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - padron 1964 anniversary maduro at famous smoke shop

Immediately upon lighting Padron’s masterful 1964 blend, a symphony of flavors engulfed me—rich cocoa, roasted nuts, and a touch of dark fruit sweetness. Hints of earthy leather and a gentle spice soon came to the forefront, making each puff a delightful discovery. The Nicaraguan Habano Maduro wrapper brings a milk chocolate appearance along with its inherent coffee-laden sweetness. A testament to Padron’s commitment to excellence, offering an unparalleled smoking experience that lingers long after the final draw.


Perdomo 20th Anniversary Maduro

Body: Medium+

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - perdomo 20th anniversary maduro at famous smoke shop

Its deep, lustrous wrapper hints at the rich experience that awaits. From Perdomo 20th’s initial draw, there’s a profound depth of flavors, with dark chocolate and ripe cherries taking center stage, followed by nuances of toasted oak and a whisper of black tea. As the cigar progresses, a subtle spiciness emerges, adding complexity to the profile. The burn is remarkably consistent, and the smoke is both dense and aromatic. This cigar is not just a smoke, but an experience, marking two decades of Perdomo’s dedication to excellence in the cigar world.


Rocky Patel The Edge Maduro

Body: Full

cigar advisor top 10 maduros for halloween - rocky patel the edge maduro at famous smoke shop

With its lush wrapper, Rocky’s The Edge Maduro unleashes a burst of rich cocoa and dark coffee flavors that envelop the palate. Each puff is complemented further by subtle undertones of sweet molasses and black pepper. As the experience deepens, there’s a delightful transition to earthy tones and a touch of leather. The burn is consistently even, producing a thick, aromatic smoke that enhances the overall experience. For aficionados seeking a bold yet refined flavor journey, The Edge Maduro by Rocky Patel is a must-try.







Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Billy Davis
6 years ago

Love Maduro cigars now. Like you, at first I wouldn’t go near them. Now I realize how much I was missing out on.

Richard Flynn
6 years ago

Love Maduro cigars!

Greg Burgos
6 years ago

LFD and Olivia maduros two of my faves.

Randy Mason
6 years ago

Great smokes!! Love Maduro cigars…

Tom Rasmuson
6 years ago

When I worked at a couple different shops I used to convert a lot of my customers to the dark side. Many, as you stated, only smoked Connecticut shade cigars, once introduced to Maduro they found a whole new world of cigar enjoyment.
One of the first I would suggest is the El Rey DelMoundo robusto Larga. It’s an oldie but a damn fine smoke.

Carl Mintz
6 years ago

Maduro Cigars are my favorite too. I never thought they were too strong. They are very smooth.

James A. White
6 years ago

I have always smoked Maduro’s. I guess, maybe because that is what I started on (when I was 12 years old) and they were real Cuban Cigars before JFK put a stop on them.. and I am 70 years young today.

3 years ago

I’ve been a “ maduro guy”for quite some time. Just recently discovered the maduro perfecto! Don’t know why it took me so long to try the maduro perfecto “flavor bombs”!

Paul Lukens

Paul Lukens


Paul first fell in love with the leaf back in college, where he majored in Philosophy (yes, seriously). Upon graduating, Paul stared into the abyss and unemployment stared back. He responded by founding the ‘Pounding Fathers,’ a traveling Beer Pong team with the other Philosophy grad at UMass. Aspiring to subsist on more than Ramen Noodles and Natural Ice, Paul put down his ping pong balls and picked up a pen - and a cigar - and began working in the premium cigar industry in 2013.

Show all Paul Lukens' Articles
cigar advisor how to use a draw poker - cover

Cigar 101: How Do I Use a Draw Poker?

Reading Time: 2 minutes We pressed record on this answer to a question on how to use a draw poker without ruining your cigar. See the video now to find out the answer!

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars february 20, 2023 - cover

Top New Cigars (February 20, 2023)

Reading Time: 3 minutes What’s floating over the Famous Smoke Shop humidor this week? Fresh new cigars from Romeo, Espinosa, and HVC. Click now to read our quick-fire reviews and discover which Top New Cigar you should be smoking!

Read More
cigar advisor april fan mail 4-14-23 cover

Fan Mail: This Month’s Top Cigar Questions…Answered! (Part 55)

Reading Time: 3 minutes We’re back with another entry to our popular Fan Mail series! This month covers the best cigars for beginners, how to identify a cigar’s flavors, hygrometer accuracy, & more. Tune in for our full video answers!

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review of caldwell the king is dead the grand tour - cover

#NowSmoking: Caldwell The King Is Dead Escape Plan

Reading Time: 4 minutes Gary takes a tour of Caldwell’s The King Is Dead Escape Plan The Grand Tour. Rolled to a 5”x54 Robusto, this vitola now boasts a soft box-pressing and a spicy Mexican San Andrés wrapper. Watch now and see where the Tour ended-up.

Read More