Top Dessert Cigars You Should Be Smoking

Save Room for Dessert

So, what’s a dessert cigar anyway? Well, they’re not cigar-shaped pastries filled with chocolate or fruit. And, to my mind at least, they’re not sweet, flavored cigars—like these from Tatiana and CAO Flavours—that you’re probably thinking of. Nah, what I’m talking about are the premium cigars you reach for after devouring a hefty porterhouse or demolishing some wings or a pizza (or two)—the handmades that add an exclamation point to a flavor-packed plate.

A Matter of Taste: Selecting the Right Dessert Cigar

Now, when it comes to picking the perfect cigar for dessert, it’s all about finding that specific stick that not only hits just right after a big meal but also goes hand-in-hand with coffee, whiskey, or your after-dinner beverage of choice. And these aren’t one-size-fits-all smokes either—what works for one palate might not for another. Maybe you’re into bold and earthy flavors, or perhaps you lean toward something rich and sweet with notes of cocoa or espresso. Whatever your preference, dessert cigars share one thing in common: they’re built to cap off the night with style, flavor, and a sense of satisfaction. So, if you’re ready to explore, here’s a list of five of the best dessert cigar options that’ll make your post-meal ritual truly unforgettable.

Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Polpetta

If cigars had a "most flavor for your buck" category, Steve Saka's Polpetta would reign supreme. This chubby 4 x 48 morsel (whose name literally means "meatball" in Italian) delivers an experience that cigars twice its size dream about. Built with leftover tobaccos from Saka's premium lines, it delivers notes of dark chocolate, espresso, leather, and just enough pepper to remind you it's a Saka creation. Perfect when you want that after-dinner smoke but don't have the time for a Churchill. It's proof that sometimes the best desserts come in small packages.

EP Carillo Pledge

Ernesto Perez-Carillo didn't earn the nickname "Godfather of Cigars" by playing it safe. This box-pressed beauty brings together Connecticut Havana-seed wrapper, Ecuadorian binder, and Nicaraguan fillers in a masterclass of blending. Your first puff delivers dark chocolate, roasted coffee, and toasted nuts, evolving into baking spices and subtle sweetness. Medium to full-bodied but never overwhelming, it's the kind of smoke that demands your attention while still playing nice with a quality bourbon or aged rum—complex, refined, and absolutely unforgettable.

Epic A Bronx Tale Calogero

Named after the iconic character from A Bronx Tale, and made in partnership with Chazz Palminteri himself, the Calogero has personality in spades. The Ecuadorian Habano wrapper hugs a Dominican binder and fillers from Nicaragua and the Dominican Republic, creating a medium-plus smoke that's equal parts sophisticated and street-smart. The flavor profile opens with creamy toasted almonds and cedar before transitioning to rich espresso, cocoa, and subtle spice. What makes this stick dessert-worthy is its remarkable balance and evolution through each third. Pair it with an espresso or Amaretto for an authentic Bronx experience.

RoMa Craft Neanderthal

The Neanderthal HS isn't for the faint of heart. This 5 x 52 powerhouse comes with a warning: don't smoke on an empty stomach. Pennsylvania Double Ligero makes an appearance alongside Nicaraguan and Dominican tobaccos, all wrapped in Mexican San Andrés wrapper and Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro wrapper. The result? A bold experience with notes of dark chocolate, espresso, black pepper, and earthy undertones. Despite its strength, there's surprising complexity here—like discovering your caveman ancestor was actually a philosophy professor. Save this bad boy for after a protein-heavy meal when you're looking to settle in for the night.

Stolen Throne Crook of the Crown Limited Edition

This boutique darling features Mexican San Andres wrapper, Indonesian binder, and fillers from Nicaragua creating a medium-full bodied experience that's simultaneously accessible and complex. The smaller 5.5 x 42 Corona vitola concentrates flavors of dark cocoa, roasted coffee beans, leather, and subtle cinnamon spice. What sets the Crook apart is its remarkable balance and the way each flavor note complements rather than competes. Produced in limited quantities, it's the kind of cigar that makes you slow down and savor each moment. Pair it with a quality añejo rum or espresso for a dessert experience that'll have you checking your humidor for more.