Cigar Ratings & Reviews

What Makes ACID Cigars Different?

acid cigars
Acid Kuba Kuba is the most popular of the ACID cigars.

What makes ACID cigars different from all other cigars may not be as obvious at first sight. In their cellos they look like most other premium handmade cigars, though the band colors may be a bit louder than your average Macanudo. It’s when you take them out of their cellos or tubes that you immediately notice the difference. And unless you have absolutely no sense of smell, it’s as plain as the nose on your face. Each cigar is imbued with its own intense fragrance characteristics. To some of you who grew up during the 1970’s, they may remind you of the incense they used to burn in the head shops. The aromas in ACID cigars come from a special mixture chosen for each blend from over 140 herbal and botanical essences. Many have tried to replicate the Acid “blend,” but with little or no success, because the secret to Acid’s unique infusion method has never been revealed, and they intend to keep it that way.

It’s really amazing how many combinations they’ve come up, not to mention the success that followed since Drew Estate founders Jonathan Drew and Marvin Samel launched the brand. According to their website: The two frat brothers from New York started out small… Small, as in a 16 square foot retail kiosk in the World Trade Center in NYC. In late 1998, Jonathan Drew moved to Estelí, Nicaragua with the hopes of starting a rebirth in the cigar world. With a handful of rollers and an even smaller handful of money, the story of “That Crazy Gringo” began. Imagine, going from a NYC apartment to sleeping on a mattress above a ramshackle factory, hardly knowing a word of Spanish too!”

Though “the rebirth of cigars,” was their motto, in 1998, Jonathan and Marvin had no idea that less than a decade into the new millennium the slogan would turn out to be prophetic. Nor did they expect that ACID cigars would create a cult following, the likes of which have only been seen in the music industry. For this reason alone you could say they are different from all other cigars in the premium cigar market. But it’s more than that…

In the cigar business, quality and consistency are King. The cigars are handmade using only choice Nicaraguan filler and binder tobaccos rolled in every variety of popular wrapper leaves including Connecticut Shade, Cameroon, Sumatra, and Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro. These are not to be confused with machine made cigars like Dutch Masters, the construction is first-rate, providing an easy draw, clean burn, and excellent balance at a reasonable price. The shapes and sizes vary in appearance from rustic to luxurious, plus the bands are color-coded to help you choose the Acid cigars that are right for you.

jonathan drew
An early shot of Jonathan Drew, the mastermind behind ACID cigars.

Acid Blue are mild to medium in body and highly aromatic, like the bestselling Acid Kuba Kuba, a smooth, mellow smoke rolled to a 5″ x 54. Acid Red offers a high intensity smoke like the Acid Nasty, a short pyramid rolled in a Connecticut Broadleaf maduro. The Acid Gold line offers even more distinctive aromas like Cold Infusion, a Lonsdale with a Connecticut Shade wrapper which is lighter in body. Acid Purple offers more complex, aromatic hybrids like Extra Ordinary Larry, a 6″ x 60 whopper brimming with sweet spice flavors. Because there are plenty of choices in each band color, it’s no wonder that many cigar smokers who have taken to Acid cigars go through almost the entire line until they settle on one, two, or more blends that they find consistently satisfying.

Moreover, because of the cult status the cigars have acquired, particularly with younger cigar smokers, each year the following multiplies by word-of-mouth, as Drew Estate continues to develop new Acid blends, or does something new with the packaging like the Acid G-Fresh series sold in “road trip-ready” bags of 5 cigars, individually presented in their own baggies.

Beyond the mainline Acid cigars, you have the Subculture selections. “Born from the ultimate expression of craft and art,” these limited edition cigars are made specifically for exclusive retailers, so no two Subculture cigars are alike. Priced reasonably, too, these custom-blended, small batch cigars are like manna from heaven for the die-hard Acid devotee. Of course here at Famous Smoke Shop we have our own Acid Subculture, the Acid Subculture Progeny, which has been extremely popular since it’s introduction.

Finally, there’s the Ambrosia selection, which could be called the “ultimate” Acid cigars. Two years in the making, they’re infused with exotic spices including cloves, plus additional spices used by only a few indigenous cultures who add them to their own native smoking tobaccos. Ambrosia cigars are so intense, they’re usually reserved for those who crave the most profound spice imbued smoking experience.

Though many smokers of “traditionally blended” cigars see them as a novelty, they are a far cry from whimsy. They have achieved cult status, and cost about the same as many of the finest mainstream cigars. As their co-creator Jonathan Drew says: “We can’t divulge too much about what our Acid cigars taste like. The fun part about smoking cigars is deciding what flavors and notes YOU taste while you’re smoking.”

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for CigarAdvisor.com since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
master blenders klaas kelner davidoff cigars interview cacover

CA Master Blenders Video Podcast: Klaas Pieter Kelner, Davidoff Brand Ambassador

His father is one of the cigar industry’s legendary master blenders; Avo was his adopted uncle, he knows the cigar business inside and out. He’s also just a really nice guy: Klaas Pieter Kelner, Davidoff Cigars Brand Ambassador, who talks with us about growing up at the heart of the business, the appreciation of a fine cigar, and more

Read More

My Weekend Cigar: May 7, 2018 – AVO Syncro Nicaragua Toro

AVO Syncro Nicaragua is a move into more exotic territory, and we're happy to come along for the ride: this box-pressed beauty issues perfectly-balanced flavors, and gives your palate a crash course in tasting zesty Nicaraguan Ometepe. It's our Weekend Cigar - click to get the tasting notes, and see the review now!
Read More
aging room small batch quattro f55M cigar review CA Cover

My Weekend Cigar: Mar. 12, 2018 – Aging Room Small Batch Quattro F55M Vibrato

Looking for a cigar that goes great after dinner, or pretty much after anything? It's the Aging Room Small Batch Quattro F55M, and it's My Weekend Cigar. If you love cigars rolled in top-grade San Andrés maduro wrapper, this cigar delivers - see what else I have to say about My Weekend Cigar, in this short review!
Read More
top rated maduro cigars 2017 halloween

2017 CA Report: 10 Top Rated Maduro Cigars For Halloween

Don't be afraid of the dark: these top rated Maduro cigars are naturally sweet treats, and are rated highest by Famous customers. See this best-of list now!
Read More