Cigar Ratings & Reviews

NowSmoking: Romeo y Julieta Eternal

Reading Time: 4 minutes

#NowSmoking: Romeo y Julieta Eternal Toro Video Cigar Review

#NowSmoking: Romeo y Julieta Eternal

Factory: Plasencia Cigars – Estelí, Nicaragua
Size: 6”x 54 Toro
Strength: Medium – Full
Wrapper: Nicaraguan (double fermented, aged 26 months)*
Binder: Nicaraguan*
Filler: Nicaraguan*

*All of the tobaccos are from Plasencia’s private reserve stocks from Jalapa, Condega, Estelí, and Ometepe.

Presented in boxes of 11 cigars

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review of romeo y julieta eternal - single cigar at famous smoke shop

The Romeo y Julieta Eternal Cigars Back Story

The Romeo y Julieta Eternal is a limited edition production cigar that celebrates the iconic brand’s 145 year “passion for cigars.”

The 6”x54 vitola is blended and handcrafted by the Plasencia family in collaboration with Tabacalera USA’s Head of Product Development, Rafael Nodal. All the tobaccos are sourced from Plasencia’s private Nicaraguan leaf reserves, and the wrapper is a double fermented leaf aged for 26 months.

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review of romeo y julieta eternal - setup shot with cigar on box next to bottle of whiskey

Eternal is presented in boxes of 11 cigars. The 11th cigar (smoked in the video) differs from the rest, in that, it has a mostly gold band and a golden ring below which Nodal says, “symbolizes the strong bond between aficionados and Romeo y Julieta and the everlasting love of the iconic star-crossed lovers. It is a love that has proven to be eternal.”


The Basics At-a-Glance

Construction: The wrapper is beautiful and seamlessly rolled with a brick red patina. There are some little bumps, but no soft spots or vein trails. The rolling is literally seamless and the triple seam cap is perfectly applied. I also like the red silk band at the foot which gives it an extra shot of elegance.
Cold Draw: Excellent with a raisiny flavor.
Base flavors: Molasses, light earth, nutmeg, raisin, citrus tang, roasted nuts, charred oak.
Aroma: Aroma off the wrapper was grassy and sweet, while the smoke was primarily sweet.
Burn & Ash: Textbook.

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review of romeo y julieta eternal - close-up shot of cigar ash
#nowsmoking @famoussmokeshop: Rolled in a double fermented, 26-month-aged wrapper with a reddish sheen, this 54-ring Toro offers an elegant smoke. Medium-full in body, the cigar reveals a harmonious alliance of molasses, light earth, nutmeg, oak, citrusy notes, and more, with a fairly dry finish.


Romeo y Julieta Eternal Cigar Review – Act I

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review romeo y julieta eternal act 1

Surprisingly, the opening puffs were not spicy for an all-Nicaraguan blend. The first puffs came off more as herbal, nutty, and toasty, then quickly transitioned to a more chewy smoke with a molasses-like sweetness. Mostly medium in body the smoke left a fairly dry finish on my palate.

The burn was even out of the gate, and at about 1-inch some earthiness crept in followed by more flavors. By the end of this act I was getting a well-balanced mix of molasses, earth, nutmeg, raisin, lemony tang, and a savory-sweet aroma.


Romeo y Julieta Eternal Cigar Review – Act II

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review romeo y julieta eternal act 2

This act was the most sensational. Talk about your “sweet spot,” the smoke was smooth and creamy, the flavors very well defined, and the molasses became more dominant as the earthiness faded. Moving along, a mix of fruit and nuts entered turning my Eternal into a “trail mix cigar.” The body and strength remained mostly medium.


Romeo y Julieta Eternal Cigar Review – Act III

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review romeo y julieta eternal act 3

In this section, the molasses settled down while the body and strength leaned into the full zone. What remained was more tanginess and a little less sweetness. However, the smoke was still smooth and creamy, the aroma sweet, and the burn—textbook. At just under three inches from the shoulders earth returned along with a note of charred oak.


What whiskey pairs well with the Romeo y Julieta Eternal Cigar?

The Romeo y Julieta Eternal is tailor-made for a long-aged single malt or bourbon. Coffee drinkers might want to go for cappuccino. But for more combinations, see our Cigar & Spirit pairing guide.


Is the Romeo y Julieta Eternal cigar worth smoking?

Absolutely. I’m filing the Romeo y Julieta Eternal under “Perfect Cigar.” It pushed all the right buttons for me. The cigar never wandered too far into full body. The smoke output was generous, chewy and packed with a stimulating mix of flavors—even the aroma was stimulating.

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review romeo y julieta eternal nub

So, what you have in the Romeo y Julieta Eternal is a dazzling composition orchestrated with a harmonious medley of extraordinary tobaccos. (Is that musical enough for you?) You’ll also find Plasencia’s finest in the Romeo 505, Montecristo Espada Estoque, and their own Alma Fuerte cigars. Keeping those examples in mind, Nestor and Rafael totally nailed it for the Eternal. Plus, I can easily recommend this cigar to any avid cigar smoker for its body, complexity, and flavor profile. It’s an elegant cigar that begs you to savor it slowly with few if any distractions. Moreover, it’s beyond sublime and I’m adding it to my personal best cigars of the year list.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor news – la gloria cubana releases its society cigar ii – release – cover

Cigar News: La Gloria Cubana Releases Its Society Cigar II

Reading Time: 2 minutes La Gloria Cubana cigars turned to its most devoted La Gloria Cubana Society members across the country to develop the La Gloria Cubana Society II cigar. How’d they do? Read all about it.

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review nestor miranda special selection rosado - cover

#NowSmoking: Nestor Miranda Special Selection Rosado

Reading Time: 3 minutes Gary smokes the Nestor Miranda Special Selection Rosado Toro. Resurrected in 2019, Gary alleges that the factory, My Father Cigars, “tweaked the blend” to appeal to today’s cigar smokers. Get all the details by watching now.

Read More
cigar advisor news – punch introduces knuckle buster habano stubby cigar – release - cover1

Cigar News: Punch Introduces Knuckle Buster Habano ‘Stubby’ Cigar

Reading Time: 2 minutes Comparisons to famous professional wrestlers notwithstanding, Punch Cigars has added a Short Gordo to their Knuckle Buster Habano selection. Rolled to a portly 4½”x60 vitola, the cigar offers a robust Nicaraguan-forward blend and packs a low price. Read all about it here.

Read More
Top New Cigars Rocky Patel Sept 28 2020 Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (Sept 28 2020)

Reading Time: 2 minutes You ready for the Rockiest Top New Cigars yet? In this edition of Top New Cigars, Rocky Patel takes the spotlight as we take you on a brief tour of all his new arrivals. Check it out now!

Read More