Cigar Ratings & Reviews

Phillies Titan Cigar Review. No, seriously.

phillies titan cigar review
Lou gives his Phillies Titan cigar review, giving a premium cigar enthusiasts take on this popular mass market smoke.

Phillies Titan cigars belong to a category variously referred to as mass-market, gas station, convenience store, or drug store cigars. Whatever you want to call them, the idea is that Phillies cigars and other similar smokes are cheap and widely available. It also means that they are not made with nearly the same quality of tobacco as premium handmade cigars like Padron, Fuente, or Davidoff.

With this in mind, I decided to grab a pack of Phillies Titan cigars and review them on their own merits.

Phillies Titan Cigar Review:


If there’s one thing you can say about them, it’s that they’re consistent. This is especially true because the wrappers are made from so-called sheet binder, a homogenized tobacco product in which large quantities of tobacco are broken down and reconstructed into a sheet of “tobacco paper,” as opposed to an actual tobacco leaf, which has been cured, fermented, and aged.

The cigars are individually wrapped in cellophane and have a paper ring. The foot is straight, while the head is tapered and pre-punched, negating the need to further punch or cut for lighting purposes. The pre-light flavor is very mild with a slight sweetness on the lips and very little resistance on the draw.

First Third

Out of habit, I toasted the first cigar like I would before lighting a premium, but with subsequent cigars I found that there was no benefit gained by doing this. Phillies Titan, like other cigars in this category, are made with a proprietary blend of shortfiller tobacco which has been refined and processed, as opposed to typical premium cigars, in which the longfiller tobaccos are bunched together and smoked end-to-end.

The sweetness on my lips persisted but eventually waned. The flavor and aroma were both incredibly mild and vaguely sweet.

phillies titan cigar review
Lou says he’s a cigar snob, but he sure looked happy while smoking for his Phillies Titan cigar review!

Second Third

By the second third I found that I was over-smoking my Phillies Titan, causing a buildup of tars at the head. To counteract this I cut the cigar with a guillotine cutter and made a conscious attempt to smoke more slowly. Subsequent cigars demonstrated no tar build-up with a slower approach. I suspect that premium cigar smokers may be tempted as I was to smoke more quickly because they are accustomed to a firmer draw.

Although I did note a slight increase in the intensity of flavor and aroma, overall the cigar remained mild and somewhat sweet. It should also be noted that the Phillies Titan had a flaky .5-.75″ ash that tapped off and disintegrated easily enough, but did not readily fall from the end of the cigar.

Final Third

Not much has really changed by the final third, again playing to the aforementioned consistency. While the cigar’s flavor and aroma continued to build somewhat, they still remained decidedly mild throughout the end of the cigar. The cigar’s burn line and burn rate were excellent, as should be reasonably expected of all such mass-produced cigars.

Final Thoughts

Phillies Titan is one of the better mass-market cigars I have smoked, and I would readily recommend it to mass-market smokers. They could also work for premium smokers who don’t mind a mild cigar, and are looking to stretch their cigar-buying dollar by getting some cheaper cigars in the rotation. Level your expectations – premium cigars they are not – but since they don’t require humidification, they could reasonably serve as an “emergency stogie” to keep in your car, golf bag, or bug-out bag. Hope you enjoyed my Phillies Titan cigar review, and if I can take a step outside my comfort zone, so can you! If you’re looking for a history lesson on Phillies cigars, check out their Wikipedia page – very informative!

Leave a Reply

3 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
0 Comment authors
Joe NgTerry BielserSteve Farless Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Terry Bielser
Terry Bielser

I love the taste of your cigars but my wife would like to know if would make flavored cigars she doesn’t like the smell but she dose like the smell of your flavored ones my name is Terry Bielser I’m at [email protected] thanks

Steve Farless
Steve Farless

I though this was an accurate and honest review; I would also put White Owl New Yorker in the same mix, but they must be smoked very slow.

Joe Ng
Joe Ng

sadly in hongkong cigars are very expensive due to heavy taxation

Lou Tenney

Lou Tenney

When he's not busy writing, editing, smoking cigars, or raising his many, many children, Hayward " "It's Lou, not Hayward" " Tenney spends his days combating confusion about his real name (it's Hayward, but please - call him " "Lou" ") and mourning the matrimonially-induced loss of his moustache (what's he gonna do with all that moustache wax he made?).

Show all Lou Tenney's Articles
top new cigars august 5 2019 cigar advisor cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (Aug. 5 2019)

Hey, there! Looking for something new? Check out this listing of the finest new cigars the tobacco industry has to offer, including ACID, La Gloria and CLE. Click here to see them…

Read More
#nowsmoking feb 19 2019 asylum medulla oblongata cigar review maduro toro Cigar Advisor cover

#nowsmoking: Asylum Medulla Oblongata Maduro Toro

#nowsmoking Asylum Medulla Oblongata Maduro Toro: “a dense, medium-plus smoke brimming with…”, well, LOTS of flavors. Click now for the tasting notes, and everything else you need to know about this cigar in under 60 seconds…

Read More
10 Best Top Shelf Maduro cigars Cigar Advisor Cover

2018 CA Report: 10 Top Shelf Maduro Cigars

Gary reviews 10 “Top Shelf” Maduro cigars: If you love the natural sweetness and savory aroma of Maduro wrapper, these dark discoveries are sure to please cigar smokers at every level of experience.

Read More

Top New Cigars – El Dudoso

El Dudoso – is this the last cigar you’ll ever need? With 40 built-in flavor profiles that match Fuente, Padron, Davidoff, and Macanudo, and fully customizable to become any cigar imaginable. Smoke the most sought-after blends of all time!

What makes El Dudoso truly awe-inducing is its ability to allow customization of personalized blends.

Read More