Cigar Ratings & Reviews

Punch Cigar Review

Reading Time: 3 minutes
punch cigar review
Lou takes on one of the most popular cigars on the market in his Punch cigar review

Punch cigars have a reputation for being straightforward fuller-bodied smokes. As one of the most iconic names in the world of cigars, as well as one of the most popular brands on the market today, this one was a prime candidate for a review on our blog. I’ve smoked plenty in the past so I’m quite familiar with the brand, but have never done a formal Punch cigar review. To further investigate this classic brand (and see if it lives up to the hype), I bought a 5-pack of Punch cigars in the Rothschild shape and got to smoking!

Punch Cigar Review

Appearance

The cigar’s appearance is, in a word, impressive. The wrappers are smooth and supple with relatively small veins, and have an oily sheen and feel to them. The seams of the wrapper were all but invisible. The cigar’s cap sliced off cleanly with a firm draw and dark, sweet aged tobacco flavors. I noted that the vitola felt well balanced in the hand.

First Third

I found that all of the Punch cigars I smoked for this Punch cigar review took a while to toast before actually lighting. This corresponds to a cigar with plenty of ligero (lee-HAIR-o) tobacco in the blend, which are the leaves from the uppermost part of the plant that receive the most nutrients and sunlight, and are therefore the strongest and oiliest.

Once lit, the cigar produced a large volume of thick, white smoke. While the cigar lacked the peppery bite associated with many newer full-bodied cigars, it still packed plenty of body, strength and flavor right off the bat.

Second Third

The cigar’s flavors had “settled in” by the time I rounded the second third, while the body and strength continued to build. I did notice an increasing sweetness and a palate of earthy, dark flavors with a strong room note. The cigar’s burn is for the most part straight, and while one of my Punch cigars began to burn unevenly, I was able to correct it without having to touch it up.

Final Third

In all of the cigars I smoked, I found that the mottled gray ash plopped down in firm 1″ nuggets. The construction also held up nobly right down to a half-inch nub. By this point the flavors had redoubled in intensity for a richly full-flavored smoke of earthy, nutty, dark tobacco flavors with some caramel-like sweetness to keep things interesting. The smoke by the end was full in body, although it should be noted that there has been a group of ultra full-bodied cigars that are heavier yet than Punch cigars. The cigar finished at a medium to full strength.

punchh cigar statue
In addition to making awesome cigars, the Punch cigar statue is an icon that has gone through many transformations.

Final Thoughts

If you are looking for nuance and complexity, look elsewhere. The original Punch series doesn’t purport to offer either of these things. Instead, the astute cigar smoker can reasonably expect a fuller-bodied smoke with rich, full flavors and medium to full strength. Punch cigars are best suited for more experienced smokers, although they may also be enjoyed by newer or occasional cigar smokers, given that they are not overwhelmingly strong.

It is advised to smoke them carefully, as over-smoking them can cause a build-up of strength and/or bitter tars. Furthermore, these cigars would pair well with a dark beer or brown liquor such as Scotch or Bourbon. Hope you enjoyed my Punch cigar review! To learn more, check out Punch’s official website for some additional details on the brand.

Punch Cigar Basics

Cigar: Punch Rothschild

Size: 4.5″ x 50

Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sumatra

Binder: Connecticut Broadleaf

Filler: Honduran, Nicaraguan, Dominican Piloto Cubano

7 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dwight Trotter
7 years ago

I agree. I really enjoy the upper cut when I can find them. Goes very well with Canadian whiskeys.

Paul
2 years ago

Honestly probably the most mediocre thing I’ve ever smoked.

Charles vescera
2 years ago

What does the writer mean when he suggests not to over indulge in the br a nd because you will build tolerance and or tar bitterneess??

Editor
Gary Korb
2 years ago

Hi Charles,
I’m a proponent of this as well. You don’t want to constantly draw on a cigar or the tars will begin to draw toward the head, albeit slowly. But when you get to that final third you may encounter some tarry bitterness.
Best advice is to take your time and try to puff in two minute intervals. Sometimes it’s hard, especially when the cigar tastes so good, but that’s what the writer was getting at. Hope this helped.
G-~

James Campbell
1 year ago
Reply to  Gary Korb

I’m guilty of this myself sometimes when enjoying a cigar. I try to get at least an hour out of a good smoke.

Shirley Elizabeth Pankey
1 year ago

Please send catalog

Editor
Gary Korb
1 year ago

Hi Shirley. I have sent your info to customer service. Thanks for the request.

Lou Tenney

Lou Tenney

When he's not busy writing, editing, smoking cigars, or raising his many, many children, Hayward " "It's Lou, not Hayward" " Tenney spends his days combating confusion about his real name (it's Hayward, but please - call him " "Lou" ") and mourning the matrimonially-induced loss of his moustache (what's he gonna do with all that moustache wax he made?).

Show all Lou Tenney's Articles
cigar advisor stocking stuffers 2022 12 cigar gifts of christmas - cover

Stocking Stuffers: The 12 Cigar Accessories of Christmas 2022

Reading Time: 5 minutes “The stockings were hung by the humidors with care, in hopes that cigar loot soon would be there!” See our must-have cigar accessory stocking stuffers inside.

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review - macanudo vintage 2010 cover

NowSmoking: Macanudo Vintage 2010

Reading Time: 4 minutes Travel back to the classic “Connecticut” cigars of yesteryear as Gary gives his review of the Macanudo Vintage 2010 Torpedo. Built on a 10-year-aged U.S. Connecticut Shade capa see what this cigar’s mellow character and nuanced flavor set have to offer.

Read More
cigar advisor news - diesel fools errand trilogy cigars release - box of cigars

CIGAR NEWS: DIESEL RELEASES ‘FOOL’S ERRAND TRILOGY’ CIGAR SERIES

Reading Time: 2 minutes Diesel Cigars has introduced a new “interactive” cigar series: Fool’s Errand Trilogy. The first of the three annually released cigars is ‘Stubborn Fool,’ a 5”x58 perfecto blended by AJ Fernandez and Diesel senior brand manager, Justin Andrews. Learn more about this intriguing, limited edition series here.

Read More
#nowsmoking EP Carrillo Pledge Prequel #1 cigar of 2020 cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: E.P. Carrillo Pledge Prequel – #1 Cigar of 2020

Reading Time: 5 minutes Gary smokes 2020’s #1 Cigar of the Year, the E.P. Carrillo Pledge Prequel. This third selection (behind La Historia and Encore, is arguably Ernesto’s finest work to-date; see if Gary felt this box-pressed robusto was worthy of its “98” tasting score!

Read More