Showing 1 through 10 of 63 reviews
Rocky Patel American Market Selection Sixty
"Great cigar"
This cigar is constructed very well. Nice siz...
more
This cigar is constructed very well. Nice size and great taste. Although this is the first one I have tried, the burn was even and the draw was excellent. Good draw has always been one the most important aspects of a good cigar. I will try more and see how they do. If they do as well as the first one, I will be ordering more.
less
Kathy in Kansas
July 25, 2010
Rocky Patel American Market Selection Petit Corona 5 Pack
"Good smoke, inconsistent construction"
These were recommended by FSS as a less-expen...
more
These were recommended by FSS as a less-expensive alternative to my usual Montecristo White Especial No. 3s. The strength and flavor were close to the Montes, if slightly bitter by comparison. Out of the five sticks I ordered, two had wrappers that "unrolled" as soon as I took the cellophane off-- sort of like Christmas wrapping paper. I had to use a little saliva (shades of cigarette rolling!) to get them to stay put, though they kept coming off during the smoke. If two out of five were this way, I'm wary of buying an entire box of them. But, the smoke was decent enough that I might risk it.
less
Eric in Cleveland, OH
July 23, 2010
Rocky Patel American Market Selection Toro 5 Pack
"Like Butter on Toast"
Ultra smooth, super flavor, one of the best m...
more
Ultra smooth, super flavor, one of the best mild cigars made. perfect construction. An excellent choice for anyone just starting to smoke. Very bold cedar and wood flavors with a very nutty cool smoke, I have a box in the Humi at all times. Great morning smoke
less
Ken in Sammamish Washington
July 22, 2010
Rocky Patel American Market Selection Robusto 5 Pack
"Best of the Best"
Simply the best. Super creamy. words cannot d...
more
Simply the best. Super creamy. words cannot describe the taste of this top shelf smoke, every serious smoker I know has this on their favorite list and we all keep plenty in the stash for ourselves. Way to good to give away. perfect draw and burn. a perfect 10 in my book. could be cigar of the year. all beginners should try this one so they know what a great mild smoke is.
less
Ken in Washington
July 2, 2010
Rocky Patel American Market Selection Lonsdale
"better than Cuba"
My first experience of smoking non-Cuban ciga...
more
My first experience of smoking non-Cuban cigars.
I really liked.
Gentle and mild taste.
Mint, manure, grass.
Nice wrapper, ideal consruction.
I am very pleased.
I recommend everybody who likes mild cigars
less
Sergey in Saint-Petersburg
May 23, 2010
Rocky Patel American Market Selection Robusto
"threw it away"
Bought the RP AM Robusto for $6.50. It was no...
more
Bought the RP AM Robusto for $6.50. It was not good in any way. From the moment I opened the wrapper and stuck the cigar in my mouth I could tell it just tasted wrong. After lighting it it was like a cheap Mexican cigar. Had to stop smoking it after a few tries.
Would never buy another one.
less
Andy in Los Angeles
April 9, 2010
Rocky Patel American Market Selection Lonsdale
"My new favorite"
My new favorite. I had been experimenting wit...
more
My new favorite. I had been experimenting with shapes, sizes and tastes. I was an Ashton smoker until these. This is what I will smoke unless/until someone turns me on to something better.
less
Larry S in Chandler, AZ
February 22, 2010
Rocky Patel American Market Selection Sixty
"Smooth and Mild as Advertised"
I picked up a box of these on Cigar Monster, ...
more
I picked up a box of these on Cigar Monster, and have been pleasantly surprised with what I have found! After seasoning for a few months in the humi, the burn was excellent and the draw was smooth. The overall taste was very mild and silky as advertised. Overall a positive experience and another great stick from RP!
less
Dustin in Columbus
February 14, 2010
Rocky Patel American Market Selection Robusto
"Creamy, nutty, delicious flavor"
I don't usually like mild to medium bodied ci...
more
I don't usually like mild to medium bodied cigars. Nor do I usually like Connecticut wrappers. When purchasing a couple of boxes of RP Cuban Blend (one of my faves) Famous sent several RP robustos as a bonus. This American Market Selection robusto knocked me out with cream and nuts. The burn was excellent, as was the appearance and draw. I just couldn't stop thinking about how much I enjoyed this cigar; so I ordered a box that has been aging over 6 months now. I'll wait at least another 6 months. I'm expecting very good things. I see why Famous claims it's their best selling box cigar.
less
Steven F in hot'lanta
November 28, 2009