Cigar Buying Guides

2019 CA Report: Box-Pressed vs. Parejo Cigars

Box-Pressed Cigars vs. Their Parejo Twins

Is There a Difference in Taste between Box-Pressed Cigars and Parejos of the Same Blend and Size?

Let’s say that some mad scientist cloned you as you are now. Everything about your duplicate was exactly the same internally, but your appearance was a little—off.  Maybe your hands were bigger, your shoulders narrower, and your gut was fatter. Even accepting those physical differences, do you think your new “twin” would have your same personality? Like the same foods? Enjoy smoking the same cigars?

In the world of sci-fi, anything goes. But in the real world, at least in the premium cigar-blending universe, this kind of thing happens fairly often. The blends and measurements are identical yet, the key difference is, one version of the cigar is round, while the other is square. Besides that, it’s the same cigar. . . or, is it? First, let’s take a look at the main differences between the two shapes.

Referred to as a parejo (pah-reh-hō) in the cigar industry, the majority of premium cigars are rolled in round shapes. In Latin American parlance, the word means “even,” which makes sense when you think about it. So, who would’ve thought to roll a cigar and then make it square? (Talk about the proverbial square peg in the round hole.) Known as box-pressed cigars, or “square-pressed,” not to mention the sharper-edged, trunk-pressed cigars, the origin of box-pressed cigars comes with several myths, which make for interesting debate.

box pressed vs parejo cigars - how cigars are box pressed

Although parejos are more popular, there are many cigar smokers who won’t smoke anything but a box-pressed vitola. Box-pressed cigars use a little less tobacco to make-up for the final squeezing that awaits them. That alone can factor into a difference in flavor and complexity. And because they are naturally more compressed, box-pressed cigars have less air inside, so they tend to burn longer than parejos.  

On the other hand, many cigar smokers find parejos more comfortable to hold in their hands and mouths. And since most new cigar smokers tend to start with parejos, they’re used to smoking round-shaped cigars. Moreover, in terms of the variety of blends available, there are a lot more premium parejos to choose from than box-pressed cigars for sale.

Generally speaking, there are going to be shape and blend differences between the two formats. So, I thought it would be fun to look at a number of box-pressed and parejo cigars that have identical blends, lengths, and ring gauges to see if there are any noteworthy flavor differences between them. The only spoiler I’ll give you is that, on average, all of the box-pressed versions smoked about a half-hour longer.

 

Asylum 13 Medulla & Oblongata Toro Corojo

Size: 6″ x 52
Strength: Full
Wrapper: Honduran Corojo
Binder & Filler: Honduran Corojo & Criollo

Box Press:

box pressed vs parejo cigars Asylum Medulla Oblongata cigars Medulla box pressed cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Parejo:

box pressed vs parejo cigars Asylum Medulla Oblongata cigars Oblongata parejo cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

The nice thing about the Asylum 13 Medulla Oblongata selection is that they come in boxes with equal amounts of both formats. Released in 2018, I guess Asylum founder, Tom Lazuka, got ahead of me on this one. It’s also one of the most ambitious premium projects on the market. The Medulla are the parejos, and the Oblongata are the box-pressed sizes. All of the tobaccos in these solidly-built puros are grown on Christian “CLE Cigars” Eiroa’s Corojo farm, and the Corojo wrappers, grown from authentic Cuban seed, are exquisite, to say the least. Both cigars offer pitch-perfect balance along with a copious amount of creamy smoke that brims with well-defined flavors of cedar, sweet spice, coffee and a splash of vanilla caramel.

The Verdict: In this case, it’s pretty hard to tell the two formats apart in terms of their overall flavor profile, but the box-pressed Oblongata was smoother, creamier, and offered a little more sweetness.

 

Camacho Ecuador BXP Toro & Ecuador Toro

Size: 6″ x 50
Strength: Full
Wrapper: Ecuador Habano
Binder: Brazilian Mata Fina
Filler: 2 high-priming Honduran fillers and Dominican Pelo de Oro ligero

Box Press:

box pressed vs parejo cigars camacho ecuador bxp cigars box pressed cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Parejo:

box pressed vs parejo cigars camacho ecuador cigars parejo cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

This is one of the dark horses from Camacho Cigars that you don’t hear too much about. Yet, if you ask Camacho smokers about the Camacho Ecuador selection, they typically agree that it’s one of the company’s best blends. The Ecuador Habano wrappers are gorgeous and have a dark, leathery appearance – even more so on the box-pressed version – while the interior has a naturally sweet Brazilian Mata Fina that binds an all high-priming Honduran-Dominican core. In a nutshell, Camacho Ecuador is a bona fide flavor bomb. An initial pepper blast rounds-out to a tangy, citrusy mix of dense, creamy-smooth smoke that shifts from spicy to sweet in well-balanced waves throughout for an impressively complex smoke.

The Verdict: The parejo runs more to the tangy-citrusy side with a bit more earth and pepper, while the BXP was markedly sweeter. This may have been due to the BXP having a little less filler, allowing more sweetness from the binder. It’s also a little smoother on the palate and has a more abundant volume of smoke.

 

Davidoff Nicaragua Box-Pressed Toro & Toro

Size: 6″ x 52
Strength: Full
Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano
Binder: Nicaraguan Jalapa Habano
Filler: Nicaraguan Estelí Viso, Condega Ligero, Ometepe Viso

Box Press:

box pressed vs parejo cigars davidoff nicaragua cigars box pressed cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Parejo:

box pressed vs parejo cigars davidoff nicaragua cigars parejo cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

The Davidoff Nicaragua selection was Davidoff’s first foray into a non-Dominican blend. It took a 10 year effort, but what emerged was a tour de force puro. The idea was to create a blend that would stimulate the bitter and sweet taste buds. True to form, the parejo is ultra-smooth, equally creamy, and starts out very spicy; then gradually transitions to notes of sweetness, spice, espresso, cedar, and bitter-sweet chocolate for a full-bodied, complex adventure from end-to-end. To its credit, in 2013 the Toro parejo at landed the #3 slot in Aficionado’s “Top 25 Cigars of the Year” with a “Classic” 95 rating.

The Davidoff Nicaragua box-pressed version carries a virtually identical flavor profile in just about every respect. There is one exception that I overlooked, and I apologize for my research lacking on this one. Although the blends are identical at the core, and rolled in Nicaraguan Habano wrappers, the parejo uses a Habano Rosado, while the box-pressed version has a Habano Oscuro wrapper.

The Verdict: I’ve smoked both cigars on numerous occasions, and found scarcely much difference between the base flavors. However, due to having the Habano Oscuro wrapper, the box-pressed Toro offers a little more sweetness, and the smoke is much creamier. The bottom line is: Both formats successfully provide the bitter and sweet stimulation Davidoff envisioned.

 

Laranja Reserva Caixa (Box-Pressed) & Laranja Reserva Volta (Parejo)

Size: 6½” x 48
Strength: Medium-plus
Wrapper: Brazilian Laranja
Binder & Filler: Nicaragua

Box Press:

box pressed vs parejo cigars espinosa Laranja Reserva caixa cigars box pressed cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Parejo:

box pressed vs parejo cigars espinosa laranja reserva cigars parejo cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

The Laranja Reserva selection boasts a rare Brazilian wrapper which La Zona Cigars founder, Erik Espinosa, named Laranja – Portuguese for “orange” – for its unique orange patina and redolent aroma. The wrapper also lends a tangy citrus note that’s similar to oranges. The Laranja Reserva Toro earned a 94 rating score in Aficionado, and at 6½-inches by 48 ring, the box-pressed Caixa and parejo-shaped Volta aren’t too far off from the Toro.

The box-pressed Caixa (Portuguese for “box”) has a peppery start, but quickly rounds to a creamy-smooth mélange of sweet spice, nutmeg, graham cracker, and that intriguing note of orange zest. Transitioning from medium to medium-plus, the smoke offers a long and creamy finish with some pleasant lingering spice.

As to the Laranja Reserva Volta, which is made expressly for Famous Smoke Shop, this parejo version comes in a humijar of 10 cigars instead of a box of 20. For cigar smokers who don’t smoke box-pressed cigars the Volta is not only on-par with the Caixa, it’s easier on the wallet, plus, you get the humijar, but they do share a similar single cigar price.

The Verdict: Despite the difference in their shapes, these are two of the closest competitors in terms of their flavor and character; therefore, it’s just a matter of preference. Both cigars are highly consistent from smoke-to-smoke, and well worth trying.

 

Romeo y Julieta House of Capulet Famous 80th Anniversary Toro & Capulet Toro

Size: 6″ x 52
Strength: Medium
Wrapper: Ecuador Connecticut
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Nicaragua, Honduras

Box Press:

box pressed vs parejo cigars Romeo y Julieta House of Capulet Famous 80th anniversary cigars box pressed cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Parejo:

box pressed vs parejo cigars Romeo y Julieta House of Capulet cigars parejo cigars at famous Smoke Shop

The House of Capulet cigars are one among a trio of Romeo y Julieta “House of” blends made exclusively for Famous Smoke Shop. This medium-bodied blend features a well-balanced core of Nicaraguan and Honduran long-fillers framed by a Nicaraguan binder and capped with a savory Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper. The Romeo y Julieta House of Capulet Toro parejo reveals a smooth, creamy smoke with base notes of cedar, nuts, leather, and a pleasant toastiness that segues to a sweet spiciness, not unlike that of cinnamon, in the latter stages.

This year, the Romeo y Julieta House of Capulet Famous 80th Anniversary cigar made its debut, and if you watched Cigar Advisor’s video review of the Romeo y Julieta House of Capulet Famous 80th Anniversary cigar, it’s probably the one cigar in this list that does differ the most from its fraternal twin. This box-pressed vitola offered notes of salted nuts, graham cracker, toffee, oak, sweet spice, and some light earthiness. It also has more transitions along the way, and doesn’t retain as much sweetness as the parejo.

The Verdict: As noted above, these two cigars, despite having the same blend and measurements, were markedly different. Even though the box-pressing on the 80th Anniversary is very sharp, my fellow reviewers and I concluded that the pressing must have had something to do with it. As CigarAdvisor.com Managing Editor, John Pullo, noted in his text review, “the flavors are much more forward” in the 80th. Moreover, this is the cigar that actually inspired me to write this article.

 

Conclusions

In most of the cases above, the flavor profiles were pretty close. It could be because all 10 selections are top-drawer blends, and when you have great tobacco it’s hard to miss. Therefore, I suggest that at some point you give these cigars a try in both formats. If you’re not accustomed to the look and feel of box-pressed cigars, maybe this article will spark your curiosity. After all, Padron cigars are made in all box-pressed sizes, and they’re among the most desirable cigars on the planet. Like most things when it comes to premium cigars, preference rules and individual tastes vary. However, if you do decide to take up the challenge, you may find some pleasing flavors I overlooked and find yourself preferring one shape over the other. As always, enjoy, and please leave a comment if you do.

7
Leave a Reply

avatar
3 Comment threads
4 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
gary korbBrian DavisBrianArthur PaysonDavid Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
David
Guest
David

I smoke box press cigars when I’m playing golf. Less likely to roll out of the cart

gary korb
Guest

Tha’s true. My brother’s a golfer, and he told me the same thing a few years ago. Thanks for the comment. G-~

Arthur Payson
Guest

I love the way box pressed cigars feel in my hand. They tend to sit nestled between my fingers like a suede glove. I especially like the thin and wide box pressed examples like the Drew Estate Norteño. Plus, pressed cigars often have an easy draw, making for abundant smoke output. These factors contribute to an enhanced smoking experience for me. I’ve never done a side by side comparison like you have Gary, but I’d say box pressed cigars have an edge just by virtue of the fact that they offer comforts not found in a standard Parejo. Particularly provocative… Read more »

gary korb
Guest

Thanks Arthur. Appreciated the comment, and I agree on the Herrera Esteli Norteño, which is a cross between box and oval pressing. I think you’re seeing more box-pressed offerings on the market, too. Guess it’s catching on.

Brian
Guest
Brian

I remember early on in my cigar journey thinking I would never smoke a box pressed stick, or a Padron for that matter*. Eventually that changed and now I prefer box pressed cigars, especially Padron.

Brian Davis
Guest
Brian Davis

* In the early days of my cigar journey I was very much against paying over$7 for a cigar. It’s just a bundled of tobacco leaves, right? How could a Padron costing $12/$15/$18/$22 be worth the money? I found a honey hole that had 1964 Diplomatico maduros for well below MSRP. I took a chance and bought one. I smoked it after dinner that night. I was hooked. What an amazing cigar! I went back to my honey hole the next morning and bought the remainder of the box! The shop was out of 1926 maduros so I went to… Read more »

gary korb
Guest

Thanks Brian. Looks like you’ve got everything sussed, plus a great collection. Padron cigars are probably a lot of new cigar smokers’ first taste of a box-pressed cigar.

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for CigarAdvisor.com since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
#nowsmoking la meridiana cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: Villiger La Meridiana Toro Box Press

Gary Korb presents his review of the Villiger La Meridiana Toro Box Press cigar in this #nowsmoking cigar review video. Gary paired the cigar with coffee and 1804 Grand Imperial Orange Liqueur. To get his take on this cigar, click here.

Read More
7 Top Quality Cigar Cutters Under $20 And How To Use Them Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: Top 7 Quality Cigar Cutters Under $20 … And How To Use Them

Need a cigar cutter, but need to cut costs? Here are our 7 top picks for quality cigar cutters under $20 – along with a bonus tip on how to use each one.

Read More
nowsmoking oliva baptiste maduro robusto cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: Oliva Baptiste Maduro Robusto

“A handsome-looking, well-built Oliva cigar” and a bold, satisfying smoke for lovers of dark Nicaraguan tobacco flavor. Click NOW for the full rundown on Baptiste Maduro, in under 60 sceonds…

Read More
buy cuban cigars in america

When Can I Buy Cuban Cigars in America?

Now that the US is talking to Cuba, people wonder: "are Cuban cigars legal in the US? If not, when will they be and where can I buy them?" We have answers.
Read More