Cigar Buying Guides

2019 CA Report: Top New Baby Cigars – Best It’s a Boy & It’s a Girl Cigars

Reading Time: 8 minutes

Cigar Advisor Guide to It’s a Boy & It’s a Girl Cigars

It’s the greatest cigar tradition of all time: handing out cigars to welcome the arrival of a new baby. Some have argued this custom has fallen out of favor, or just been “forgotten” as a novelty – but the custom of giving out cigars when a baby is born is still alive and well, because we cigar enthusiasts are a proud people, and we embrace tradition – which means it’s our responsibility to uphold it.

Handing out cigars is a new dad rite of passage…and it’s one of the most special cigars you’ll ever share with someone else.

We’re taking the time to look at New Baby cigars because the stats tell us that your special delivery is probably on its way very soon (the CDC keeps tabs on this birth rate by month data). More babies are born between August and October than at any other time of year, because… well, do the math: winter is for lovers…it’s cold; and Christmas excluded, there’s not a lot else to do, frankly.

So we’re using our time today to make sure you’re prepared, and not running around at the last minute looking for some cigars to hand out. We’ll explore why we give cigars when a baby is born, and take a look at your best It’s a Boy & It’s a Girl cigar options that fit every new dad’s budget…because those baby bills are going to add up, and fast.

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars man paying his new baby bills
“Bundle of joy? More like bundle of debt.” Kids are expensive, so we’ll be mindful of your cigar budget.

Why we give out cigars when a baby is born

An article on new dads passing out cigars, published in 2016, pointed me to a Richard Reed book titled Birthing Fathers: The Transformation of Men in American Rites of Birth. Part of the social psychology behind why we hand out cigars to welcome a new baby is tied to the age when men were excluded from the delivery room: smoking cigars was a way to help pass the time (and calm the nerves) in the waiting room. And sharing cigars to announce the birth of a baby “gives recognition and vent to the pride, relief and excitement that men feel as they become fathers and recognize a new one in their midst (p.94).”

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars man smoking a cigar with a toy zebra smoking a cigar
When you’re a new dad, you’re pretty excited to share a cigar with just about anybody.

Whether the handouts ever got smoked, well, that didn’t matter – it’s more about sharing your joy of taking your next step in life. Besides, taking part in the longstanding practice of cigar giving is a hell of a lot more fulfilling than a hashtag on Instagram.

Why are cigars celebratory?

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars three men celebrating with cigars together

We smoke a cigar to savor the overwhelmingly positive and emotional moments that come with life’s victories and achievements. It’s why you treated yourself to a top-shelf luxury smoke after you landed a promotion at work.

The Pats burned Padrons to celebrate their fifth and sixth titles; MJ torched a Cuban to celebrate bringing a trophy to Chicago. Now, I am by no means an athlete – but if an occasion calls for celebration, whether it’s sealing a big deal, or experiencing a rite of passage like graduation or getting married – the cigars come out at my house. No wonder, then, that the cigars would come out to welcome a child into the world.

Origins of the tradition

The custom of new fathers giving out cigars when a baby is born has been around for hundreds of years, actually. A little digging traces a similar practice back to the indigenous people of North America, who exchanged gifts (tobacco included) to celebrate a birth.

Then, we fast forward to the 1800s, when childbirth took place at home (hospitals were few and far between). While a midwife or doctor was helping your wife through the birthing process, you waited in another room of the house with your supportive friends and family.

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Three men smoking cigars waiting
Your friends: they’re weird, but they’re here to support you while you wait.

Women were sometimes included, but it was usually only a men-only custom (sorry, ladies). And once your son was born, you handed out the cigars. That’s right: originally, the tradition (supposedly) only extended to celebrating the birth of a male child (again – sorry, ladies).

In more modern times, you’d be stuck in the waiting room of the hospital until the nurse called your name; and when the baby was born, you – the proud new father – would hand out cigars to those waiting with you. Believe it or not, there was a time when you could buy New Baby cigars at the hospital gift shop – one of the reasons savvy cigar makers seized on the New Dad cigar-giving tradition, making special “It’s a Boy” and “It’s a Girl” cigars in the 1950s. (Bring cigars within 100 feet of a hospital today, and you’d probably be wrestled to the ground by security.)

Of course, no one documented these cigar traditions at the time – so while we all know cigars are handed out when babies are born, consider this a hand-me-down version of history…trust as much of it as you want.

Who buys the cigars when a baby is born?

If you’re the new dad, you do – this is your gift to hand out when your baby is born. Truth is, you can give any cigar…but these are special. Not just because of the band, but why you bought them.

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Man holding a baby smoking a cigar
Wait, what? No, no, no…you hand out cigars BECAUSE of the baby, not TO the baby…

A new parent’s budget appreciates a variety of price points, reflected in these eight “It’s a Boy” & “It’s a Girl” cigars. Some are top shelf smokes that will give you the most memorable cigar experience of your time on this earth; I’ve also included some of the cheapies, perfect handouts for the people who may not even smoke them. Each have names you know – and in most cases, the blends are the same as their everyday counterparts.

No matter which cigar you choose to hand out, thank you for keeping the tradition alive – and congratulations!


Alec Bradley

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Alec Bradley Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Whether it’s a boy or it’s a girl, these Alec Bradleys make a great celebration cigar – and these have three things going for them: first, it’s a smooth-smoking Connecticut that’s easy on any palate. Second, these Honduran handmades are 6” x 50 Toros – a very popular size. And last but not least, the box is the ultimate keepsake: that square on top is actually a picture frame, where you can print a snapshot of your new arrival (which will be met, of course, with a chorus of oohs and ahhs). And when the cigars have been handed out, it makes for a top-notch keepsake box that holds all the trinkets and treasures, like her delivery room wristband and a lock of hair from her first haircut. An endearing time capsule.

Arturo Fuente

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Arturo Fuente Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

A specially-wrapped version of Fuente’s ginormously popular Brevas, their mixed-filler cigar. It’s an easy-smoking Dominican blend wrapped in delicate Cameroon wrapper – which ensures that even your casual cigar buddies can take part in this celebration. Fuente “It’s a Boy” cigars are clad in a cello with blue print, “It’s a Girl” is in pink. A great handout cigar when a baby is born, not just because the price is right – but because as Fuente is a tradition in its own right. And you’ll still get to keep some coin in your pocket to get that college fund rolling.

Ashton Classic

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Ashton Classic Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

I would consider Ashton’s New Baby cigars to be the handouts for your closest of friends and family…this top-shelf Dominican selection is clad in genuine Connecticut Shade, and smokes toasty-sweet and mellow. This is a glass tubo presentation, in two sizes: a 6 ½” x 44 Lonsdale, or 6” x 49 Belicoso, with “It’s a Boy” or “It’s a Girl” stickers affixed to the tube. If you’re keeping your circle of celebration small, this is a connoisseur’s smoke that your VIPs will be more than happy to partake with you.

Rocky Patel

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Rocky Patel Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

If anyone can tell you about the celebratory experience of smoking a premium cigar, it’s Rocky Patel. Fitting, then, that RP gets into the spirit with a New Baby Boy and Baby Girl cigar. Best I can tell is that it’s not far off from the Edge Connecticut, except that it’s made in Nicaragua; medium in body and shrouded in an Ecuador Connecticut wrapper, this creamy smoking Toro offers up toasty tastes of nuts and wood. Bonus: it’s a legit premium at under $4 each, which is great now that you’re forced to divert cigar money to the diaper budget.

Romeo y Julieta

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Romeo y Julieta Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

RyJ takes part in the New Baby cigar tradition with their Reserva Real blend, one I consider to be a cut above the regular-run Romeo. And for the presentation, Romeo y Julieta really goes the extra mile: each cigar is wrapped in a cedar sleeve printed with “It’s a Boy” or “It’s a Girl”, then sealed in a glass tube for safekeeping. A keepsake for sure; but if you do decide to break the seal on this 5 ½” x 44 Corona, expect a Dominican long filler blend that pairs well with sweeter beverages, if you’re planning on adding a toast to your new arrival.  

Cuesta Rey

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Cuesta Rey Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Historically speaking, Cuesta Rey is a cigar “fit for a king” – Spain’s King Alfonso XI, to be specific. Over 100 years later, Cuesta Rey is here with It’s a Boy and It’s a Girl cigars to announce the arrival of your prince or princess. To make these Caravelles, JC Newman takes a mellow blend of Dominican tobaccos, rolls them into a skinny 6 ¼” x 34 Panatela, then finishes them in a Connecticut wrapper; blue or pink storks are featured on the cellos. At under $1 a piece, this old school Dominican fave is great if you have many with whom you’d like to share your good news. Your dad might have even passed these out.

White Owl

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars White Owl Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

If it’s more about the tradition than it is about the cigar itself, consider these sub-$1 souvenirs. White Owl was one of the first cigar companies to make “It’s a Boy!” cigars, around 1953 – so all the more reason to consider these mellow Coronas, in “It’s a Boy” and “It’s a Girl” foil wrappers, from one of the kings of machine-made cigars.

Factory Throwouts

Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Factory Throwouts Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Another JC Newman entry for your New Baby celebration…Factory Throwouts are mellow budget bundles, machine made in Tampa with a mix of Dominican fillers under Ecuadorian Sun Grown wrappers. Each stick comes in baby bottle-printed cellos: blue for “It’s a Boy” and pink for “It’s a Girl” cigars. An affordable way to carry on the New Baby cigar tradition, as these Throwouts will run you about the same as a box of bubble gum cigars.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Stan Walker
4 years ago

Perfect timing for me. We just had our second grandbaby yesterday, a girl. Good to know there are decent baby cigars out there. Thanks for the article.

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
cigar advisor the difference between cigar strength and body - cover

What’s the Difference Between Cigar Strength and Body?

Reading Time: 4 minutes Understanding cigar strength and body helps you choose the perfect smoke. We’ll simplify these concepts and explain how you can better evaluate strength and body. You’ll soon be on your way to discovering the art behind choosing the ideal cigar for a truly memorable experience.

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars 8-21-23 - cover

Top New Cigars (August 21, 2023)

Reading Time: 3 minutes Inside: Diners Drive-Ins and Draws: Guy Fieri and Espinosa release a fresh Knuckle Sandwich, plus new cigars from West Tampa Tobacco and a sequel to an award-winning Montecristo…see it all inside this edition of Top New Cigars!

Read More
cigar advisor fan mail part 58 cover

Fan Mail: Even More Burning Cigar Question Answers! (Part 58)

Reading Time: 3 minutes Fan Mail is back with more cigar questions answered. This month, we’re talking about cigar burn touch ups, Winston Churchill, and which leaves fare best as Maduro wrappers. Check out all the details inside now!

Read More
cigar advisor avo caribe cigar panel review cover


Reading Time: 6 minutes Avo Syncro Caribe is the fourth installment in Avo’s artisanal line extension, and the Panel offers their review of the Avo Syncro Caribe Toro. Capped by a Dominican wrapper, there are a number of things that make this particular blend unique. For the entire story, watch now.

Read More