Cigar Buying Guides

2019 CA Report: 10 Top Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10

At Cigar Advisor, we don’t do ratings. It’s not our style. For one, everyone else is doing it. And besides, when the dust settles, it’s just one (or four) of our opinions. Sure, we know our stuff, but it just isn’t possible for our taste buds and personal preferences to speak for 17.4 million cigar smokers (and those are just the U.S. numbers). . .

We still think ratings have their place, though. When you log-in to Amazon to buy whatever it is you buy, you most likely browse the user reviews on the item. A manufacturer can tout a widget’s accolades all they want, but if most customers are giving it a one-star rating, then surely something devious is afoot.

Smoking is an exceedingly subjective affair, and as such, you’re going to need more data than just four middle-aged dudes who just happen to know a thing or two about tobacco. That’s why, for this article, I combed the Famous Smoke Shop website to find cigars that were highly-rated from customers – not staff, not bloggers. . . but consumers, like you.

The formula was simple: In order to qualify for this list, each cigar in question had to pass the following criteria:

  • Manufactured in Nicaragua
  • Priced under $10 a stick
  • Minimum of 10 customer reviewers
  • Attained an average rating of least 4.5 out of 5 stars

During my research for this article, I looked up some of the customer ratings for similar cigars offered by Famous Smoke Shop’s competitors. For some reason – maybe it was the glowing one-word reviews (That’s it? One word? That’s all you have to say?), or the fact that, somehow, everything everybody smoked was awesome (amazing!) – sampling those reviews gave me that “something devious is afoot” feeling I described earlier. Or maybe I’m just a cynic – so instead of dogging these guys, I’ll just take this opportunity to remind everyone of the Famous Smoke Shop rate & review policy for all of our products. 

So, as we dive into these 10, highly-customer-rated cigars, just remember: You don’t have to take my word for it when I say that these are the best of the best!

Don Pepin Garcia Original Generosos – 5 Stars from 11 ReviewsTop Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 Don Pepin Blue cigars Don Pepin Garcia Original Generosos Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

It seems like every time I make my way into the Famous Smoke Shop retail store, there’s someone singing the praises of Don Pepin Garcia Blue. Its across-the-board, five-star rating from Famous customers is all the evidence you need. The Original Generosos, as they’re more accurately called, are rolled in pristine Nicaraguan Corojo wrappers and are the product of Cuban-born blending legend, Jose Pepin Garcia. Underneath its wrapper you’ll find Nicaraguan Corojo and Criollo long-filler leaves that undergo a meticulous hand-selection process. The result is a full-bodied cigar with a spicy-sweet complexity that will satiate your senses from foot to nub. One thing is abundantly certain; these cult-classic cigars are crafted for connoisseurs – but priced for the everyman.

My Father No. 1 – 4.5 Stars from 10 ReviewsTop Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 My Father No 1 Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Moving on to the next generation of Jose Pepin Garcia’s lineage leads us to Jose’s son, Jaime Garcia. Jaime released the My Father line in 2008 to critical acclaim, and it’s clear that the apple has landed close to the tree. Enjoying the highest customer rating of the blend, My Father No. 1 employs a lush, Ecuador wrapper, a hybrid of both Rosado and Criollo, to crown its Nicaragua core of long fillers. Coffee, wood, cocoa, and a sprinkling of caramel sweetness will leave you clearing out time in your schedule to indulge in these full-bodied delights as often as possible!

Liga Privada Undercrown Robusto – 4.5 Stars from 23 ReviewsTop Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 Liga Undercrown Robusto Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Liga Privada Undercrown cigars were initially blended solely for the enjoyment of torcedors (cigar rollers) under Drew Estate’s employ. They were coveted treats within their ranks and rose so much in popularity, that they decided to bring them to market. It was a move that paid off in spades for both Drew Estate and tobacco enthusiasts like you and me. With a diverse blend of tobaccos, from its Mexican San Andres wrapper to the Nicaraguan and Brazilian tobaccos found under the hood, Liga Undercrown was a nearly overnight success. Expect to be captivated by its smooth sweetness that’s big on flavor without denting your bankroll.

CAO Brazilia Gol! – 4.5 Stars from 120 Reviews

Top Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 CAO Brazilia Gol Cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

For nearly 20 years, CAO Brazilia has been wowing the palates of cigar enthusiasts, and none of its sizes are more popular than Gol! With a staggering 4.5-star average across 120 reviews, it’s clear that not only is this the most popular CAO cigar, but one of the most popular cigars period. Gol! features an oily Brazilian Arapiraca wrapper that embraces a robust blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos below. Exotic spices, cedar, and a smooth finish are the perfect combination for a bold and full-flavored after-dinner splurge.

Merciless by Joya de Nicaragua Robusto – 4.5 Stars from 10 ReviewsTop Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 Merciless by Joya de Nicaragua Cigars robusto at Famous Smoke Shop

If you read our recent Essential Guide to Joya de Nicaragua, you may have noted that Merciless was my favorite of their portfolio. It’s not because I think Merciless is the best JdN out there. . . It’s because I believe it has the highest flavor-to-cost ratio among their blends. Wrapped in an Ecuador Habano leaf, its Nicaraguan and Dominican core exudes a medium-bodied, oaky sweetness with a trace of warm pepper. If you allow yourself to indulge, you may notice that they aren’t the most visually appealing cigars, but let’s ask ourselves if that really matters. What means more to you? A picture for Instagram, or the value of its flavor?

New World by AJ Fernandez Toro – 5.0 Stars from 19 ReviewsTop Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 New World by AJ Fernandez Cigars Toro at Famous Smoke Shop

Collaborating with his father, Ismael, AJ Fernandez crafted New World by AJ Fernandez after the universal kudos he received from his freshman solo debut with San Lotano. AJ’s blends are typically stronger and feature plenty of kick, but New World is medium-full in body, yet subdued with smooth and creamy spice – the perfect cigar to pair with a post-meal cup of joe. Combining Estelí, Condega, and Ometepe leaves for its core, a hybrid Nicaragua Oscuro leaf tops this deftly executed blend for a memorable experience that is only outperformed by its surprisingly low price-point.

Oliva Serie V Belicoso – 4.5 Stars from 27 ReviewsTop Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 Oliva Serie V Cigars Belicoso at Famous Smoke Shop

Even if you’ve been a premium cigar enthusiast for a short period of time, you are probably as unsurprised as I was to find that the Oliva Serie V Belicoso is well-loved and highly-rated by smokers everywhere. The apex of the their lineup, Serie V, is comprised of a Habano Sun Grown wrapper and well-aged tobaccos for the binder and filler that were culled from Nicaragua’s lush Jalapa Valley. Its signature flavor is a spicy smoothness that never overpowers, delivering satisfaction that’s both dependable, and affordable.

Rocky Patel Nicaraguan Toro 4.5 Stars from 12 ReviewsTop Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 Rocky Patel Nicaraguan Cigars Toro at Famous Smoke Shop

Rocky’s tribute to Nicaragua comes via Rocky Patel Nicaraguan. This painstakingly-crafted gem is beloved, and even more so in the ever-popular Toro size. Known for its impeccable balancing act and a full flavor that doesn’t bite your palate, Rocky’s Nicaragua Habano leaf crests an all-Nicaraguan tobacco core to offer dollops of spice, pepper, earth, and sweetness that works in unison with these warmer spring evenings. This one’s as worthy of your back porch as it is your humidor.

Asylum 13 Seventy 5.0 Stars from 12 ReviewsTop Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 Asylum 13 Seventy cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

There’s no shortage of love for big-ring cigars, and Asylum 13’s Seventy is about as big as they come! With a whopping 70 ring gauge and a length of seven inches, you’d be forgiven to think that this was purely a novelty, but you’d be wrong. A perfect score from Famous Smoke Shop customers makes it clear that Asylum was swinging, not for the fences, but for the parking lot. Cocoa, espresso and some sugary spices are just a few of the takeaways from these voluminous beauties.

Famous Nicaraguan Selection 6000 Toro – 4.5 Stars from 19 Reviews

Top Rated Nicaraguan Cigars Under $10 Famous Nicaraguan Selection 6000 cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

After 80 years in the biz, Famous has been around the block enough times that by this point, they’re able to comfortably cherry pick private labels before they associate their name with them. Crafted by Amilcar Castro, who also has blended for Rocky Patel, Famous Nicaraguan Selection 6000 Toro sells in droves, both online and in Famous’s retail store. Each Nic 6000 is topped with an Ecuador Habano wrapper and choice long fillers from Nicaragua and Honduras. There are cheap cigars, and there are value cigars, and you can rest assured from these reviews that these ain’t no Ron Mexicos.

What Nicaraguan cigars would you rate highly? Let us know in the comments below and thanks for reading!

Leave a Reply

4 Comment threads
3 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
5 Comment authors
Steven LandriganJared GulickJimmy WilliamsRonBrian Davis Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Brian Davis
Brian Davis

None of the Padron Classic had reviews that met the requirements? That’s a shame. The 2000 is a phenomenon sub-$6 stick. Several other vitolas in the line meet the sub $10 mark. The Tatuaje Havana VI line also lands in this territory. Illusione 88, 68, HL, Rothschild? Curavari? I guess I need to write more reviews.

Jimmy Williams
Jimmy Williams

Correct..As a Padron Smoker I agree with Brian

Jared Gulick
Jared Gulick

Brian, you’re absolutely right regarding the Padron 2000. Both the Natural and Maduro of these cigars well exceed the requirements of the article, but when we’re only choosing a certain number, there are bound to be a few that don’t make the cut. Maybe I’ll add it to the list a little later on. Thanks so much for reading and your feedback!


This list left off an excellent cigar. Alec Bradley Tempus Nicaraguan. Great smoke at a great price.

Jared Gulick
Jared Gulick

The only issue with that cigar was that it wasn’t rated enough by Famous customers to fit the criteria. I agree that it’s a great smoke, though!

Steven Landrigan
Steven Landrigan

How about some time looking at Mello or average strength

Steven Landrigan
Steven Landrigan

How about looking at mellow or average strength

Jared Gulick

Jared Gulick


Jared Gulick is an avid cigar smoker, nerd of all things science, musician and serial abuser of the Oxford comma. He got his start in the cigar industry in 2013. A Certified Tobacconist, Jared made his way to the Famous Smoke Shop retail store in 2018 - then joined the Cigar Advisor team, when it was discovered that he could locate the shift key. Prior to his work in the cigar industry, he was a recording studio engineer, songwriter, and a journalism major at Northampton Community College.

Show all Jared Gulick's Articles
top new cigars july 22 2019 Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (July 22 2019)

Want to get the scoop on the latest cigar offerings at Famous Smoke Shop? You’ve come to the right place! Click to view the current rundown.

Read More

CA Year-End Report: 2018 Top 25 Best New Cigars of the Year

Our Top 25 Cigars of 2018 are announced: these are the year’s best smokes, each a new-for 2018 release that more than impressed us…they left a mark. If you’re feeling adventurous for new cigars to try, here’s a quick n’ tidy recap of the selections we think are totally worth your time.

Read More
Gran Habano Blue In Green cigar review Churchill Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Review Panel: Gran Habano Blue In Green Cigar Review (Video)

The Gran Habano name doesn’t often come up in conversation, but the loyalists know how good they are. GH’s latest, and the subject of our Blue In Green cigar review, was inspired by George Rico’s favorite Miles Davis composition; But how jazzed up did we get over this cigar? Watch now and see…

Read More
Swisher Sweet Buys Drew Estate

Swisher Buys Drew Estate: Good…or Bad?

Swisher haters, time to let it go: Commentary on the news of "Swisher buys Drew Estate." Could this be a win for both Drew Estate and Swisher International?
Read More