Cigar Buying Guides

2018 CA Report: How to Build a Well-Rounded Cigar Collection in 3 Easy Steps

How to Build a Well-Rounded Cigar Collection in 3 Easy Steps

By Fred Lunt

So, you’ve got this great cigar humidor. But you look inside, and you notice it’s lacking in certain areas…maybe you’ve got plenty of yard-gars, but not enough good “sharing smokes” for when friends are over. Or, you’ve got too much of a certain brand, too many full-bodied cigars, or too many of one size, etc. The key to building your cigar collection is having the right assortment of sticks to fit every occasion. How can I have a well-rounded cigar humidor, you ask? Well I’m here to clue you in on the essential basics of a balanced cigar humidor – it’s easier than you think!

Before we take the plunge into stocking the cart, you’re going to have to take a step back and figure out some key factors, so you can keep that humidor full of premium cigars at any time. One of the most important factors to remember is to shop for what you like and for any occasion. Are you ready? Let’s dive in.


build a cigar collection know what cigars you likeStep 1: Know the Cigars you like

While I assume you have a general idea of the cigars you like, you need to really think about which ones you want to keep on hand. I suggest taking a pen and paper and writing out the best cigars you’ve smoked. After you’re done, try to find similarities between them: are the cigars you like best made by the same brand or from the same country? Do they have similar blends or flavor notes? Take this into account so you know what to look for – this will hopefully give you an idea of a budget. Speaking of which…


build a cigar collection establish a cigar budgetStep 2: Establish a budget

Nobody is made of money; and if you are, you should seek medical attention immediately. Developing a budget is essential to balancing your cigar humidor, giving you a clear amount of dollars to set aside each week, month or year that you can put toward patching up the weak links in an unbalanced or underfilled humidor. Your cigar allowance will, of course, vary by your spending comfort level and tastes; after all, one man’s yard-gar is another man’s Padron. Use your budget to guide you while bagging bundles or clipping coupons for special occasion cigars.


build a cigar collection buy cigarsStep 3: Buying the right cigars

Today’s cigar world is unlike any other; there’s literally thousands of cigars on the market to choose from. While knowing the base flavors, strength and price helps when buying, it’s important to know the main staples of cigars you’ll find in every smoker’s humidor. As a wise unknown once said, “smoke for the occasion.” So here I’ve laid out the main occasions to buy for, effectively giving you a well-rounded humidor you’ll never tire of.

Note: (Prices are noted on a scale of $ – $$$$$. A single $ equates to the $20-50 range, while $$$$$ is $200+)


build a cigar collection work cigar yard garsWork smokes…AKA, the Yard-gar. Because not every cigar is going to be a Fuente Opus X; in fact, most of the cigars you’ll smoke will be under $3 each. The yard-gar varies on your budget but for the general public, the term is generally applied to a bundled second, overrun, closeout or budget cigar you can mindlessly enjoy while toiling away on the job or doing chores. They may not be pretty to look at, but they get the job done. Keep 10-20 in your humidor depending on the season.


build a cigar collection yard gards slaughterhouse cigarsStrength: Mellow-Medium
Notes: Sweet and creamy with a nip of pepper.
Wrapper: Mexican San Andres Binder: Mexican Sumatra Filler: N/A
Price: $

Famous Nicaraguan 3000

build a cigar collection yard gars famous nicaraguan 3000 cigarsStrength: Full
Notes: Dark coffee, cocoa, peppery spice and a tangy sensation.
Wrapper: Ecuadorian Habano Binder: Nicaraguan Filler: Nicaraguan
Price: $


build a cigar collection cigars for sharing cigarsCigars are best enjoyed with friends over a campfire or around a table with lively conversation. Of course, not all your friends are big cigar smokers and you don’t really want to shell out $10 per cigar only to find them half smoked in the ashtray the next morning. As a part of being a good host and BOTL you’ll need to keep a shareable cigar in your humidor for guests – preferably a smoke that’s both budget friendly and good quality. After all, nobody likes a cheapskate. Keep 10-20 on hand, if you have the space.

La Gloria Cubana Gilded Age

build a cigar collection sharing cigars la gloria cubana gilded age cigarsStrength: Medium
Notes: Tangy citrus, earth, toast, cedar wood, nuts and a hint of spice.
Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sumatra Binder: Honduran Filler: Nicaraguan
Price: $$


601 Kryptonite

build a cigar collection sharing cigars 601 kryptonite cigarsStrength: Medium
Notes: Cocoa, brown sugar, cream, pepper.
Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano Binder: Nicaraguan Filler: Nicaraguan
Price: $$


build a cigar collection everyday cigars

Every Day cigars are the ones that exist in your humidor solely for your enjoyment. Consistent, tasty, and reliable, these are the cigars you smoke with your morning coffee, while you’re walking the dog or with your after-work cocktail. You’re going to want a healthy supply in your humidor. I recommend picking a brand that hits all the points of your palate, and enjoys regular discounts when it’s time to restock – giving you the most bang for your buck. Keep 15-20 ready to go.


build a cigar collection every day cigars hoyo excalibur cigarsStrength: Mellow
Notes: Oak, leather, earth, cream and coffee.
Wrapper: U.S. Connecticut Shade Binder: Connecticut Broadleaf Filler: Dominican, Honduran, Nicaraguan
Price: $$$


Punch Gran Puro Nicaragua

build a cigar collection every day cigars punch gran puro nicaragua cigarsStrength: Full
Notes:  Sweet spice, dark cherries, oak, caramel.
Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf Binder: Nicaraguan Filler: Nicaraguan
Price: $$$


build a cigar collection occasional cigarsThese “every now and then” cigars are what I call mid-shelf treats. We all need a carrot at the end of the stick – a special treat to enjoy on an evening out or just to shake things up. These mid-shelf treats are the ones in your cigar collection that you look forward to smoking when you’ve got the time and the mood is just right. Keep 5-10 in your humidor at any given time.

Padron 3000 Maduro

build a cigar collection good cigars padron 3000 maduro cigarsStrength: Full
Notes: Caramel, cedar, coffee, cocoa, leather, and white pepper.
Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano Binder: Nicaraguan Filler: Nicaraguan
Price: $$$$


Camacho Corojo

build a cigar collection good cigars camacho corojo cigarsStrength: Full
Notes: Leather, coffee, cedar, and charred wood.
Wrapper: Honduran Original Corojo Binder: Honduran Filler: Honduran
Price: $$$$


special occasion cigars cigar collectionSpecial Occasion cigars are the rarities – the cigars you ogle but only smoke on the right occasions. Events like anniversaries, holidays, vacations and the like are what the special occasion cigar is all about. A good many of us save a special corner in our humidor for these; often times they’re gifts, defunct brands or limited editions or just plain splurge cigars. Keep 1-10 of these in your cigar collection for when these rare occasions arise.

Winston Churchill The Late Hour by Davidoff

build a cigar collection special occasion cigars winston churchill late hour cigarsStrength: Full
Notes: Cream, coffee beans, sweet spices, caramel, and oak.
Wrapper: Ecuadorian Habano Binder: Mexican San Andres Negro Filler: Dominican, Nicaraguan
Price: $$$$$


Olivia Serie V Special V Figurado

build a cigar collection special occasion cigars oliva serie v cigarsStrength: Full
Notes: Coffee and chocolate with a peppery spice.
Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano Binder: Nicaraguan Filler: Nicaraguan
Price: $$$$


Now that you’re armed with this cigar shopping knowledge, go forth and seize your dream humidor. Share your cigar collection essentials in the comments below!


newest oldest most voted
John Raiona
John Raiona

Great article. As a newbie I definitely want to learn to build a well rounded collection.

Sonja Fassbender
Sonja Fassbender

Cottage hill has a walk in humidor and a tobacconist as well, stop buy

Turo Saldana
Turo Saldana

I like to find samplers of cigars i might like. And if i findba gem in the sampler i buy them in 5 packs.

Randy Sterling
Randy Sterling

Great article

Fred Lunt

Fred Lunt


Fred Lunt was discovered to be the youngest cigar smoker in his family shortly after setting his crib ablaze; today, he's added an avid whiskey and craft beer appetite to his lineup. Fred has worked in marketing, blogging and communications at boutique PR agencies across New York and has personally had the pleasure of witnessing over four breakdancing shows in a single commute on the NYC subway. Prior to his work in marketing Fred was a student of communications at Temple University and still holds illusions that Temple has a better football program than Penn State.

Show all Fred Lunt's Articles
Aganorsa Cigars Guide Casa Fernandez Aganorsa Cigar Review Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: The Essential Cigar Advisor Guide to Aganorsa Cigars

New to Aganorsa Cigars? Aganorsa Leaf grows some of the world’s most sought-after Nicaraguan tobaccos, and are one of the fastest-growing boutique outfits in the biz. Check out our detailed tour of their entire portfolio, with tasting notes, now!

Read More
2019 Best Cigar Samplers for New Cigar Smokers Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: 5 Best Cigar Samplers for New Cigar Smokers

Cigar samplers are great for discovering the smokes that may become your regular favorites; that goes double if you’re new to cigars. Click now for 5 of our top picks, our most-recommended cigar samplers for new cigar smokers…

Read More
la gloria cubana esteli cigar review video cacover

CA Review Panel: La Gloria Cubana Cubana Esteli Cigar Review (Video)

La Gloria Cubana Estelí cigar is a more full-flavored take on the classic La Gloria Cubana cigars, heightening the flavor and character of the brand’s original “white box” blend. Here’s what the Cigar Advisors thought of it. . .

Read More
CACover Cigar Tobacco from Different Countries

2017 CA Report: Cigar Tobacco From Countries That May Surprise You

Go beyond the Big 4 - Cuba, Nicaragua, DR and Honduras - as we turn you on to cigar tobacco from unexpected places. Why do cigar makers use these flavors?
Read More