Cigar Ratings & Reviews

#nowsmoking: Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo Super Toro

Reading Time: 5 minutes

#nowsmoking: Caldwell Long Live The King Mad Mofo Super Toro Cigar Review 

Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo Cigar Review – Super Toro

FactoryTabacalera William Ventura (DR) 
Size: 6”x 54 
Strength: Medium 
Wrapper: Mexican San Andrés Maduro 
Binder: Indonesia 
Filler: Dominican Republic, Nicaragua and U.S. Pennsylvania  

Presented in boxes of 10 cigars and singles. 

#nowsmoking Caldwell Long Live the King Mad MoFo cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

The Caldwell Cigars Back Story 

The Caldwell Cigar Company was created in 2014 by Robert Caldwell who set a very simple agenda: “Create special cigars using well aged rare tobaccos and to enjoy the hell out of what we do. It is a business built on friendship and fun. Our goals will always be: Creation, Innovation & Ambition.” 

Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo cigar has a pigtail

Caldwell cigars are known for using very long aged and rare tobaccos. Caldwell believes that extra-long aging is one of his company’s key ingredients. “Using tobaccos that are harder to procure, or more limited in nature can deliver a flavor that isn’t quite what you are used to,” adds Caldwell. 

Back to the Beginning

Robert Caldwell’s first cigar-related enterprise began in 2008 with a hospitality cigar distribution company.  After that, he went on to manufacture private label brands for hotels and restaurateurs. The Wynwood Cigar Factory in Miami, Florida followed, and that venture led to work in the Dominican Republic.  

Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo cigar paired with bourboniring

In 2014 Caldwell founded Caldwell Cigar Company and Down&Back Distribution. Long Live the King, The King is Dead, and Eastern Standard, were the three original lines introduced by Caldwell that same year. (The original Long Live The King cigars have a Dominican Corojo wrapper.) 

Long Live the King MAD MOFO was released in 2018. The “MAD” in the name is short for “Maduro.” As to the MOFO part, the line was originally launched as the “MF,” but later changed to MOFO. 

Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo single cigar in box with drink pairing

“We launched our brands with a very different approach,” said Caldwell in a 2018 Aficionado interview. “A refined, artistic, fresh kind of agenda in terms of our packaging. And we have energy—an energy that gets people interested. We were having fun.” 

Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo Super Toro cigar review by Gary Korb
#nowsmoking @famoussmokeshopThe Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo Super Toro is a handsome cigar with notes of light earthiness, sweet tobacco, tart berries and a hint of light pepper on the finish. Medium bodied and well-balanced. 


The Basics At a Glance 

Construction: A beautifully made cigar adorned with a neatly twisted pigtail cap. The wrapper is even in color with few discernible veins and well packed. The cigar is appointed with double bands. The top band reads, “Long Live The King”, while the other reads, “Mad Mofo.” (If you look closely at the image of the face under the over-sized crown, I’m pretty certain it’s Elvis.) 
Cold Draw: Twisting the pigtail didn’t produce enough exposed tobacco, so I clipped it thinly. The draw was perfect with a nutty and lightly sweet flavor plus some herbal notes.   
Toasting and light: No problems. First few puffs were smooth, quite sweet, and lightly spicy with some herbal notes.  
Base flavors: Light earthiness, sweet tobacco, herbs, light spices. 
Aroma: Strong hay aroma off the wrapper. The foot offers a mix of herbs and flowers. Once lit, the cigar reveals a woody fragrance with a charred smokiness.  
Retrohale: Smooth, lightly peppered, and tingly but stronger in the latter stages. 
Burn & Ash: One of the more impressive features about this cigar. Long, firm and mostly grey.  



Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo Cigar Review Part 1

My Caldwell LLTK Mad Mofo Super Toro got off to a tasty start; medium-bodied and smooth with a mix of marginally defined notes of sweet tobacco and spices. Additionally, the burn was also off to a good start – nice, even, and firm. With a name like “Mad Mofo,” I expected this cigar to be bolder in flavor, but it was actually quite nice. I was glad to discover that, but I still didn’t know what the next section would offer. 



Caldwell Mad Mofo cigar review part 2

Pretty much a continuation of Act I. So far, the cigar’s body and strength was consistent, and the flavors did begin to come more focused. Definitely more sweetness, some peppery spice, and even a hint of tart berries enters the fray. Also, the Pennsylvania double ligero added more flavor than power for me. On top of that, the cigar also exhibited flawless balance.  

Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo super toro cigar review ash quality and color

Burn-wise, the cigar did beautifully. It was a little faster than I liked, but it was also about as perfect as it gets, so no issues there.  



Caldwell LLTK Mad Mofo cigar review part 3

The body shifted to medium-plus but the core flavors remained pretty much the same. So, the Super Toro may not have had a big slew of flavors, but the sweet and spicy mix was enjoyable enough for me to smoke it down to the nub. Even then, the smoke remained balanced; it was a little more intense and even tart at times, but overall, put in a great performance. 


What can I pair with this cigar besides coffee?  

nashville barrel company 7 year paired with Caldwell LLTK Mad Mofo cigars

Our pairing expert recommends Nashville Barrel Company Single Barrel Rye Whiskey. Sweet and tangy aromas, with a taste that’s balanced between depth and complexity. The mouthfeel is creamy and the back palate offers floral notes, toasted walnuts, charred oak, and white pepper. It has a medium to long finish with oak and pepper spice, subtle charred cinnamon, and floral honey. 

(Find more cigar and drink pairing combinations here.) 


Final Thoughts. . .  

As I mentioned in the video, I haven’t smoked that many Caldwell cigars over the years, but I’m quite familiar with their popularity. I like the steampunk-ish imagery that makes Caldwell cigars instantly identifiable, and Caldwell’s dedication to quality is without question. Besides, sometimes not knowing what to expect makes the experience more interesting. 

Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo Super Toro cigar review summary

In the back story above, Caldwell says they use tobaccos that “deliver a flavor that isn’t quite what you are used to.” From my experience with the Super Toro, there was a lot of truth to that. At times, it was difficult for me to get a fix on specific flavors, but all combined, the smoke was very pleasing. Better yet, smoke one yourself and you’ll understand what I mean.  

Finally, if you’re looking for a good, medium-boded cigar that’s skillfully made, well-balanced, and uncomplicated, the LLTK Mad Mofo Super Toro should be quite satisfying. To that end, this maduro is also a welcome departure for cigar smokers at every experience level. 


#caldwell #caldwellcigar #lltkcigar #longlivetheking #boise #caldwellcigarco #cigaradvisor #cigar #cigars #cigarlife #cigarlifestyle #cigarsociety #cigarporn #cigarreviews #cigarphotography #botl #sotl #nowsmoking #menwhosmoke #thecigarculture #relax #luxury #ultimateluxury #luxurylifestyle #luxury #gooddeal #smokeability #friendsoffamous 

1 Comment
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
8 months ago

Great body and smoke, loved every sec of second of the cigar MF!!!!

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
cigar advisor top new cigars april 18, 2022 - cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (April 18, 2022)

Reading Time: 3 minutes This edition of Top New Cigars highlights a trifecta of flavor-filled boutique blends from Caldwell, Aganorsa Leaf, and Stolen Throne.

Read More
#nowsmoking cigar advisor review montecristo epic vintage 12 cover

#NowSmoking: Montecristo Epic Vintage 12

Reading Time: 5 minutes How does a rare vintage crop of Dominican tobacco harvested in 2012 affect the blend of this new small batch cigar selection from Montecristo? Gary takes the Montecristo Epic Vintage 12 Blue No. 2 Pyramid for a test drive to answer that question and more in this cigar review.

Read More
top 6 best rated aleck bradley cigars under $10 cover

2021 CA Report: Top 6 Best-Rated Alec Bradley Cigars Under $10

Reading Time: 6 minutes Finding the best Alec Bradley Cigars according to Famous Smoke Shop customers is easy. Getting them each for under $10? Now that’s a challenge. See which AB blends made the cut!

Read More
worst cigars from the boom era CACover

2018 CA Report: The 10 Worst Cigars From the Boom Era That Are Making a Comeback(?)

The mid-90s Cigar Boom may have catapulted the cigar biz to new heights, but it also brought us a plague of the worst cigars ever made, a combo of poor tobacco and even worse names. Now we hear that some of these stink-sticks are coming back to the market before the final FDA clamp down. Read on for the entire story!
Read More