Cigar Ratings & Reviews

#nowsmoking: E.P. Carrillo Pledge Prequel – #1 Cigar of 2020

Reading Time: 5 minutes

#nowsmoking: E.P. Carrillo Pledge Prequel Cigar Review 

E.P. Carrillo Pledge Cigar Review – Prequel (Robusto) 

Factory: Tabacalera Alianza – Santiago, DR 
Size: 5” x 50 box-pressed 
Strength: Medium-Full 
Wrapper: Connecticut Havanaseed wrapper 
Binder: Ecuador 
Filler: Nicaragua 
MSRP: $10.75/cigar* | Singles, 5-packs, and boxes of 10

* at press time 

Buy #1 Cigar of 2020 EP Carrillo Pledge Prequel cigar review at Famous Smoke Shop

The Back Story 

In a career filled with considerable milestones, Ernesto Perez-Carrillo has just added one more to the list – the E.P. Carrillo Pledge selection. Consisting of just two vitolas for its debut – four more will be added as they are ready for release – Pledge follows Encore and La Historia as the third release in this Perez-Carrillo series. It also marks Ernesto’s 50th year in the cigar industry, and was envisioned as a tribute by Ernesto to cigar lovers around the world. What it also represents is the growth of Ernesto Perez-Carrillo’s blending skills over his half century of work.  

EP Carrillo Pledge Prequel cigar box

For this initial two box-pressed vitola release – the Robusto-sized Pledge and Toro-sized, 6”x52 Sojourn  one size focuses on his roots in Cuba, which contributes to tobacco being in his blood, and the second points to his core years of developing the skills that led to his reaching cigar blending royalty.

#1 cigar of 2020 EP Carrillo Pledge cigars box

“I will never stop working with the best tobaccos and bringing new and innovative blends to you,” said Ernesto. “With each sample of the 6 different blends for Pledge I worked on, I asked myself, is this cigar worthy to follow La Historia and Encore, and I was very pleased when I found the one.” 

A Long Term Commitment

Ernesto spent six months testing blends before settling on what ultimately became Pledge. Before Pledge shifted into full production, Ernesto made sure he could procure enough tobacco for three years. Additionally, due to the COVID-19 pandemic and its impact on the factory, production of this cigar had to be very limited. 

EPC Pledge Prequel cigar review by Gary Korb

“I first became aware of the Connecticut Havana seed wrapper in the early 80s when it was not being extensively used by many manufacturers. This wrapper was relatively unknown in Miami; but when I was finally able to first smoke it, I fell in love with it. I started using it in some of the blends I was making at that time. More recently, I had only used this wrapper in 2 limited releases at E.P. Carrillo. With Pledge, it now becomes part of our portfolio. I couldn’t be more enthusiastic, as this wrapper and I go way back to my core years in developing my skills as a cigar blender.” 

epc pledge prequel cigar review closeup
#nowsmoking@famoussmokeshop: The E.P. Carrillo Pledge Prequel offers a chewy, medium-full smoke drenched with well-rounded flavors of oak, leather, sweet tobacco, and baking spice.


How well is the cigar made?  

Beautifully. Even with its 5”x50 dimensions, the cigar seems to have a slightly bigger appearance. The pressing is just right, and the wrapper has reddish-brown marbling with an oily-leathery patina. The triple cap is deftly applied, and the cigar feels balanced and comfortable to hold. The cap clipped perfectly offering just the right amount of pull with notes of salt, leather, and spice in the cold draw.

(Acts I-III are the tasting notes I recorded while smoking my sample prior to doing the video. 



EPC Pledge Prequel cigar review Part 1

Initial puffs are still a little salty and leathery. The draw reveals a healthy amount of smoke which lays smoothly on the palate and goes down easy. The body begins in the medium zone with an equal amount of strength. Notes of sweet tobacco also enter the mix and the finish has a slightly peppery snap to it. The burn up to the first ash is pretty even, and the ash itself is quite firm.  



EP Carrillo Pledge Prequel cigar review Part 2

At the midsection, the strength remains on the medium end, while the body improves taking the cigar into the medium-full arena. At this stage, the salt has all but faded, but there’s still some leather in there. Some woodiness also arrives at this juncture and the cigar seems to have taken on more of a sweet-spicy character – certainly sweeter than the previous section. The finish remains spicy with a fair amount of pepper and baking spice. There’s something about how the smoke just seems to coat the entire palate with this wonderful, full-on chewiness, while retrohales have more of a black pepper reveal. At this point everything is running at full potential. 



EP Carrillo Pledge Prequel cigar review Part 3

But that’s far from the last of it. At this stage, I’m starting to wish this cigar was a bit longer just so I can get a few more minutes out of it. The sweet spice has moved toward the back and I’m now getting a bit of earth and black coffee. The leather and baking spice remain in the mix, and occasionally there’s a snap of tart fruit. But the overall flavor profile is a well-rounded serving of woodiness, semi-sweet treats, and peppery spices.    


What can I pair with this cigar besides coffee?  

Jack Daniels Heritage Single Barrel Whiskey, or a good rye. I also think The Macallan 12 Year Double Cask would make a fine match-up. Wine lovers would do well pairing it with a Californian Paso Robles Syrah.  

Jack Daniels Heritage Barrel EP Carrillo Pledge cigar pairing

(Find more cigar and drink pairing combinations here.) 


Final Thoughts. . . This cigar is a sparkling gem from first puff to last. Anyone who calls themself a cigar smoker should experience the Perez-Carrillo Pledge – not because it was awarded “2020 Cigar of the Year” either. Because it’s loaded with chewy flavors and a fullness that only comes from using the most perfectly aged tobaccos. I smoked it well before it received its #1 ranking and knew then that this cigar had something special going for it. It’s worth every penny, too. Ernesto could’ve charged more for it, and I would’ve paid it. Pledge represents another fitting milestone in a cigar-making career that’s spanned more than half a century, and Ernesto is far from finished. 


#cigaradvisor #cigar #cigars #cigarlife #cigarlifestyle #cigarsociety #cigarporn #cigarreviews #cigarphotography #botl #sotl #nowsmoking #menwhosmoke #thecigarculture #relax #luxury #ultimateluxury #luxurylifestyle #luxury #gooddeal  #smokeability #epccigar #perez-carrillo #number1cigar #cigaroftheyear #pledgeprequelcigar   

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2 years ago

Great cigar just finished smoking one and I’m going to buy a few more!!

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor news – gran habano announces bold corojo no.7 cigar – release – cover image

Cigar News: Gran Habano Announces Bold Corojo No.7 Cigar

Reading Time: 2 minutes It won’t appear on cigar store shelves until January 2024, but Gran Habano Cigars wanted to get the word out in advance about their long-awaited Corojo No.7, a limited production Nicaraguan puro with an all-Corojo leaf blend. Learn more about it here.

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review west tampa attic series - cover

#NowSmoking: West Tampa Tobacco Co. Attic Series

Reading Time: 3 minutes This week we’re reviewing the first release from the Attic Series, Attic, from West Tampa Tobacco Co. Out of the imagination of Rick Rodriguez, the Attic Series will feature blends that Rick’s kept all for himself over the last 30 years. Watch the review to see if Attic Series, Attic is worth a try!

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review west tampa tobacco white - cover

#NowSmoking: West Tampa Tobacco Company White

Reading Time: 4 minutes Former CAO brand ambassador Rick Rodriguez now has his own premium cigar brand, West Tampa Tobacco Company. In this review of the West Tampa White Toro Gary called it “a real finger burner.” Was he just being nice? Check out his entire review now.

Read More
10 top rated AJ Fernandez Cigars Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: 10 Top Rated AJ Fernandez Cigars

Reading Time: 10 minutes AJ has created some of the industry’s highest scoring premiums, but now it’s cigar lovers like you who get their say! Check out the top-rated AJ Fernandez cigars chosen by Famous Smoke customers who have scored these picks as 5 stars – see if you agree, or get a new suggestion for an AJF cigar that’s right for you.

Read More