Cigar Ratings & Reviews

#nowsmoking: M by Macanudo Flavors Dark Rum

Reading Time: 4 minutes

#NowSmoking: Macanudo Dark Rum Cigar Review (Video)

Factory: General Cigar Dominicana, Santiago Dominican Republic
Size: 6” x 50 (Toro)
Strength: Medium – Full
Wrapper: Indonesia
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Nicaragua

Presented in boxes of 20 cigars

M by Macanudo Flavors Rum – Cigar Details:

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review of m by Macanudo Dark Rum flavor cigar - at famous smoke shop

M by Macanudo Dark Rum Backstory

M by Macanudo—the brand’s infused line—seeks to deliver a premium cigar experience that’s at once familiar and a departure from the ordinary.

The three new flavors—Dark Rum, French Vanilla, and Mint Cocoa—come in one size, a 6” x 50 Toro, and use the same recipe of an Indonesian wrapper over a Nicaraguan binder and long fillers. The cigars are then infused using Macanudo’s proprietary process.

cigar advisor - nowsmoking M by Macanudo Flavors Dark Rum Toro cigar review, with cigars, cigar box, cigar pairing and smoking cigars

Today I’m trying the M by Macanudo Dark Rum. Let’s see if this cigar lives up to its billing in the opening act.


Cigar Basics

Construction: Wrapper was light brown with an almost reddish hue. There was some give when lightly squeezed.
Cold Draw: Brown sugar, molasses.
Base flavors: Rum sweetness, pepper, wood.
Aroma: Sweet.
Burn & Ash: No issues.

Macanudo Dark Rum Review – Part 1

Right off the bat, and I mean immediately as I remove the Macanudo Dark Rum from its cellophane, I’m greeted with a pleasant, sweet smell. Closer inspection with the beak reveals a somewhat latent spicy component as well.

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review of m by macanudo dark rum toro - part 1

On lighting there is no mistaking this for anything but an infused cigar. And I have to mention the sweetness from the cigar’s tip—of the kind that leaves behind a sugary sensation. The flavors in the first third consist of strong dark rum notes, think sweet and fiery like a mix of kettle corn with a dusting of cayenne. On the more traditional end, I am picking up wood (like the inside of a barrel maybe) and earth to go along with the previously mentioned pepper. At the end of the first third, body and intensity are a solid medium and building.

Let’s see if this continues in the second act.


Macanudo Dark Rum Review – Part 2

I’m getting into the second third of the Macanudo Dark Rum and I’m beginning to notice a transition into more of the traditional cigar realm. The flavors are there—and I’m talking the sweetness—but they’ve mostly receded into the background.

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review of m by macanudo flavors dark rum toro - part 2

What emerges are notes of black pepper, earth, and dry wood that bring balance and complexity while steering the Macanudo Dark Rum into more traditional (and for some of us, familiar) territory. Body and intensity have increased to medium-plus and the construction has been faultless to this point.

Let’s see how it wraps up in the conclusion.


Macanudo Dark Rum Review – Part 3

As the Macanudo Dark Rum reaches nub territory, not much has changed. The basic components are still present—sweet, spicy, savory—and it never strays too far past medium full. To break it down further, the balance of infused vs. traditional remains present with kettle corn sweetness offset by black pepper, dry wood, and earth.

cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review of my by macanudo flavors dark rum toro - part 3

What beverage pairs well with Macanudo Dark Rum cigars?

I had to try a dark rum along with this cigar, and I chose Plantation Original for this journey. I enjoyed a healthy pour over a couple of ice cubes. Other dark rums will suffice.

cigar advisor - nowsmoking M by Macanudo Dark Rum cigar and drink pairing

For non-alcoholic options old standbys like coffee, Dr. Pepper, or water certainly pair nicely.

For additional pairing combinations, check out our Cigar & Spirit pairing guide.


Are Macanudo Dark Rum cigars worth smoking?


For some reason I was reminded of the poem The Road Not Taken while smoking the Macanudo Dark Rum. Not the whole poem—but the basic gist of it. The connection? Taking the road less traveled—or a cigar you might not normally pick—sometimes can make all the difference.

So, is it worth trying? Well, if you’re a traditional cigar smoker the M by Macanudo Dark Rum might surprise you. It most likely won’t convert you to a full-time infused cigar fanatic, but you might make occasions to enjoy one. For me, occasions to have a Mac Dark Rum would be when I’m looking for a cigar that I don’t need to pay attention to—like when I’m playing poker or dominos. Or if I were more athletic, golf.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Paul Lukens

Paul Lukens


Paul first fell in love with the leaf back in college, where he majored in Philosophy (yes, seriously). Upon graduating, Paul stared into the abyss and unemployment stared back. He responded by founding the ‘Pounding Fathers,’ a traveling Beer Pong team with the other Philosophy grad at UMass. Aspiring to subsist on more than Ramen Noodles and Natural Ice, Paul put down his ping pong balls and picked up a pen - and a cigar - and began working in the premium cigar industry in 2013.

Show all Paul Lukens' Articles
cigar advisor best yardgars november 5 2023 cover.

Yardgars: A Cigar Advisor Guide to Value & Variety

Reading Time: 6 minutes We know what they are. We may even have some stashed away in the dark recesses of our humidors. Now it’s time to bring these unsung heroes of the cigar world out from the shadows and show them the love they deserve. Check out our Cigar Advisor Guide to the 10 Best Yardgars and discover your next everyday classic.

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review warped el oso - cover

#NowSmoking: Warped El Oso

Reading Time: 3 minutes Crafted at El Titan de Bronze in Miami, Florida, Warped El Oso has been a boutique favorite since its introduction in 2014. Does this boutique blend still set the standard of excellence—watch the review to find out!

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review cavalier black serie ii - cover

#NowSmoking: Cavalier Geneve Black Series II

Reading Time: 3 minutes This week we’re reviewing the Cavalier Geneve Black Series II. Featuring an edible and smokable gold diamond fused into the wrapper—will this Maduro cigar make you want to go for the gold? Watch the review to see if Cavalier Geneve Black Series II is worth a try!

Read More
cigar advisor 5 things about steve saka cover

5 Things That Made My Career: Steve Saka of Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust (Podcast)

Reading Time: 5 minutes This podcast with Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Cigars founder Steve Saka reveals the five milestones that took him to rock star status. Starting with his discovery of premium cigars in the Navy, it’s an illuminating listen with one of the cigar industry’s most idiosyncratic and admired personalities.

Read More