Cigar Buying Guides

2021 CA Report: Top 5 Best Rated Romeo y Julieta Cigars Under $10

Reading Time: 4 minutes

The Best Rated Romeo y Julieta Cigars – and They’re Each Under $10

A Brief History of Romeo y Julieta cigars 

There’s no two ways about it. Romeo y Julieta is one of the most celebrated cigar brands of all time. A mere 10 years after the brand’s introduction in 1875, Romeo y Julieta had earned a trophy case full of gold medals for flavor. Medals that the brand proudly showcases on their logo to this day. But when former Cabañas factory head, José “Pepin” Rodriguez Fernández, took the reins in 1903, RyJ was rocketed into cigar stardom. It was even Winston Churchill’s favorite brand. 

Best Churchill Cigars Under $10 Sir Winston Churchill smoking a cigar

Unlike many Cuban brands that have a contemporary in the American market, in this case, it’s Romeo y Julieta’s Cuban arm that borrows the nameAfter José’s passing in the early 50s, and the encroaching Cuban revolution, the original Romeo y Julieta company moved their headquarters to the Dominican Republic and has been there ever since. And you don’t need us to tell you that they’ve kept up the pace. Yesterday’s gold medals are today’s 90+ ratings. RyJ earns them with a consistent track record spanning almost 150 years. 

Rolling Romeo y Julieta cigars at Flor de Copan in Honduras
Rolling Romeo y Julieta Reserve Robustos (#4 below) at Flor de Copan, Honduras. (Image courtesy Altadis USA)

Don’t take our word for it…or theirs

But cigar ratings don’t always tell the whole story. At least not the ones in those bougie magazines. They’re all based on one opinion. One ridiculously overdressed reviewer speaking for an estimated 12.2 million (and rising) cigar smokers in the U.S. alone. Hardly all-encompassing, right? That’s why we’re not even offering our own take – three reviewers aren’t much better. With our Top-Rated series, we’re demoting the suits and putting the power of ratings in your hands. Because, here at Cigar Advisor, your opinion is the only opinion we care about. 

How our customer-based cigar rating system works:

After searching through the entire Romeo y Julieta catalog, we’ve landed on the top-rated cigars for each blend. To qualify, a blend must attain a minimum of 10 reviews averaging at 4.5 stars. Whichever size has the highest average customer rating is the one we highlight. No bias. No favoritism. Just the feedback you want without searching hours to find it.  
One more thing. We upped the ante with one additional rule: every Romeo y Julieta cigar featured in this guide is under  $10/stick at press time based on the box price. 

Have a Romeo rating of your own? Drop us a comment below and tell us what you think! 


Romeo y Julieta House of Capulet Toro – 4.5 Stars across 40 Reviews 

Top 5 Best Rated Romeo y Julieta cigars Capulet at Famous Smoke Shop “These are simply great go-to cigars that you would be proud to share with anyone.” Review by David G. Gerber, CA.

Not only is the Romeo y Julieta House of Capulet Toro Famous’ best-selling house blend, but it’s the best-selling and highest-rated Romeo on their shelf. Period. That’s some serious love, even for a brand that’s all about romance. The blend’s silky notes of vanilla, cedar, and toast smokes sweet thanks to a medley of Honduran and Nicaraguan core tobaccos and a golden Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper. It’s a stick that transcends typical Connecticut flavors without losing the mellow character you’d expect from it. You can even try the House of Capulet Famous 80th if you wanna see what it’s all about in a box press. 


Romeo y Julieta 1875 Cedro Deluxe No. 2 – 4.5 stars across 33 Reviews 

Top 5 Best Rated Romeo y Julieta cigars 1875 Cedro Deluxe No 2 at Famous Smoke Shop “Easy to light, great burn, great draw, great flavor, just a flat-out great cigar! Highly recommend you get this one.” Review by John in AR

Romeo y Julieta 1875 is often the first ‘real cigar’ a budding cigar smoker lights up to take off their training wheels. The blend is medium-bodied and favors notes of oak, cedar, and nuts with faint spices and even some more peppery moments. That’s because of its classic blend, a consistent staple for decades: Dominican long filler leaves, an Olor binder, and genuine Indonesian Java Sumatra wrapper. Even to veteran smokers, like us, this Cedro Deluxe No. 2 serves as a breakfast cigar that never bores. 


Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Toro – 4.5 Stars across 28 Reviews 

Top 5 Best Rated Romeo y Julieta cigars Reserva Real at Famous Smoke Shop “This is a great smoke if you want one early in the day or just before bed when you don't need a good kick in the ribs.” Review by Red in S.C.

The Romeo blend that keeps it real. With a more traditional approachRomeo y Julieta Reserva Real cigars are bred for the Connecticut purists. Spices stay on the lighter side thanks to a balanced recipe of Dominican and Nicaraguan tobaccos and an Ecuador Connecticut on top. Flavor and strength wise, the blend is medium-bodied, creamy, and imbues all the cedar, earth, and creaminess you could ever ask for. At their price and consistency, Reserva Real is affordable enough to hand out to your buddies for some delicious tee time fun. 


Romeo y Julieta Reserve Robusto – 4.5 Stars across 20 Reviews 

Top 5 Best Rated Romeo y Julieta cigars Reserve at Famous Smoke Shop “Burns so smooth to the end that I nearly burnt my thumb!” Review by Phil in Columbia

Romeo y Julieta has made a name for itself by staying middle of the road. You could even say they’re typically all-inclusive. Romeo rarely make a cigar that goes in heavy, but when they do, you’re in for a tasty rideOne such heavier cigar is Romeo y Julieta Reserve – a love letter to full-bodied cigar fans everywhere. Here’s what’s under the hood: a cinnamon-hued Nicaragua Habano wrapper with a potent tobacco core from Nicaraguan and Honduras. Together, they dish out some seriously sweet and spicy flavors of earth, coffee, and dark wood. Romeo y Julieta Reserve is must-have for any Romeo fan.


Romeo y Julieta Vintage No. 3 – 4.5 Stars across 16 Reviews 

Top 5 Best Rated Romeo y Julieta cigars Vintage at Famous Smoke Shop “I have smoke over a dozen of these and have bought boxes for parties and gatherings. This is a crowd pleaser and a RyJ treasure.” Review by Tony in TX.

To call something vintage…it can’t just have some age on it. It also has to stand the test of time and become a classicFitting that bill is the three-year-aged Dominican Olor tobaccos in Romeo y Julieta Vintage. Not only do they have that coveted flavor-building age, but they’re blended with an Ecuador Connecticut wrapper. Mouthwatering is an understatement. Like most of Romeo’s Connecticuts, Romeo y Julieta Vintage goes above and beyond – this cigar with delicious flavors of cedar, cream, nuts, and even a hint of citrus. We’re talking luxury premium expectations on a budget, and it’s hard to improve from that. 

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jared Gulick

Jared Gulick

Features Editor, Jared Gulick, is a Certified Tobacconist, nerd of all things science, musician and serial abuser of the Oxford comma. He made his way to the Famous Smoke Shop retail store in 2018 and joined the Advisors when it was discovered that he could locate the shift key. Prior to his work in the cigar industry, he was a recording studio engineer, songwriter, and a journalism major at Northampton Community College.

Show all Jared Gulick's Articles
cigar advisor top new cigars september 5, 2022 - cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (September 5, 2022)

Reading Time: 3 minutes This week in Top New Cigars, we review CAO BX3, El Rey del Mundo, and All Saints. See which ones you should be smoking before summer ends!

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars may 16, 2022 - cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (May 16, 2022)

Reading Time: 3 minutes In this edition of Top New Cigars we’re reviewing some innovative limited-edition blends. Get you fill from the gourmet recipe in Crowned Heads Mil Dias Marranitos, the extra age in a CAO Pilon Anejo, and the launching of a quest with Diesel Fool’s Errand.

Read More
cigar advisot top new cigars december 6 2021 cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (December 6, 2021)

Reading Time: 3 minutes It’s early December – get ready for the holidays with these new cigar arrivals from Asylum, Drew Estate, and Hoyo de Monterrey

Read More
Bolivar Cofradia cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Review Panel: Bolivar Cofradia Cigar Review (Video)

Reading Time: 6 minutes The Bolivar cigar brand may conjure up images of the golden age of Cuban cigars. But there’s another Bolivar, Bolivar Cofradia, blended in Honduras by the late Estélo Padrón. Here is our review of the Churchill, along with all the surprises this big boy had for the Panel…

Read More