Cigar Buying Guides

The Battle: Pairing Cigars and Liquor

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Pairing Cigars and Liquor? Bottoms up!

The Advisors are kicking off the calendar with a little bit of style and a little bit of swagger…actually, make that a little bit of stagger – as this time, we’re “informed” from deep within a few bottles of choice. We’re not pairing smokes, per se – rather, we’re pairing cigars with drinks because of the qualities they share, unique notes each presents and, well, just because they’re all so goddamned tasty. Mostly that last part. Notice that we’re only telling you what those cigars are, and why we like them, as opposed to giving these smokes a rating, a score, a rank or whatever arbitrary and arcane grade we could dream up. The Advisors call bullshit on pulling bogus “ratings” out of thin air, or basing a score on 3 puffs and a whole lotta hype. Instead, it’s best to let the cigars – and real smokers like you – do the talking. We simply supply the facts on each stick – do with that info what you will. But it’s these 12 in particular we enjoy with a kind of particular pleasure reserved for very few other adult delights: like pairing cigars with booze. As for the descriptions themselves, we’re going off of what flavor and body the fillers have, what qualities the wrappers have and so on, plus 100% personal experience…and pitting the cigars (and their boozy counterpart) against each other in this month’s Battle.

So let’s get started…vodka, tequila, rum and whiskey – each is a staple of the Advisors’ bottom desk drawer, and we know what to do with it; we also know that there’s no wrong way to drink them, except in excess. So we present a few solid drink recipes that, like the cigars in the following pages, get our mouths watering – put ’em head to head – and let them fight it out.

Get ready to imbibe – it’s cigars and liquor in the Battle!

Coronas: Vodka

Usually in the ballpark of 5 1/2 x 42, a good corona cigar goes down smooth and easy…just like a nice premium vodka. What makes both uncommonly good is their versatility. We suggest you put these 3 cocktails to put on your to-drink list – and if it helps to sway you, given you three unique cigars to which you can compare their uniquely similar characteristics. For instance: vodka may look unassuming, but brings the buzz; we think these 3 smokes will do the same. Click the arrows left or right to toggle between the selections!

L'Atelier Maduro

601 Oscuro

Romeo Y Julieta Reserve

Robustos: Tequila

As the robusto is a staple of the humidor, tequila is always on any liquor cabinet’s guest list. But just because they’re both oh-so-common doesn’t mean they’re incapable of bringing a pleasant surprise (though tequila’s “tomorrow morning” surprise is a significantly different experience). Try these tequila recipes for something out of the ordinary, and the cigars for some rich and powerful blends. Click the arrows left or right to toggle between the selections!

La Floridita Cigars

La Aroma De Cuba

Toros: Rum

Rum seems to be an acquired taste; so, too, are toros to those of us who typically stay to the smaller end of the ring gauge. But as these cigars build in size, so do the drinks that include a healthy hand’s worth of island goodness – and may God help you if you overdo it, as it’s very easy to do with these 3 blends and these 3 drinks. Click the arrows left or right to toggle between the selections!


La Gloria Cubana Gilded Age

Nica Rustica

Churchills: Whiskey

Yes, Churchill cigars got their name from the British Prime Minister; yes, there are plenty of Churchill stories that include a tipple or ten of the good stuff in the glass in his hand. While we can’t vouch for the authenticity of the subsequent legends of Winston’s imbibing (that’s a word, right?) we can vouch for these three cigars – and can certainly get behind the whisky/whiskey (whatever you prefer) drink recipes you see here. Click the arrows left or right to toggle between the selections!

Room 101 Serie HN 615

Punch Rare Corojo

Alec Bradley Prensado

Now – your opinion on pairing cigars counts. Try ’em all, and tell us which cigars and liquor you like best, in the comments below!

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Courtney Triple C Cook
6 years ago

Jack & coke and a 60 ringer is always great company

Hugh Gahn
6 years ago

A good single malt scotch, neat, and practically any smoke. But, I always love a CAO Flathead. Particularly the 554 Camshaft.

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles

Cigar News: Foundation El Güegüense Famous Exclusivo Cigars Arrive at Famous Smoke Shop

Reading Time: 2 minutes Foundation Cigar’s Nicholas Melillo has a gift for Famous Smoke Shop this Holiday season. He recently announced the release of the limited edition El Güegüense Toro Box Press cigar made exclusively for Famous Smoke Shop. Read more about it here.

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars april 18, 2022 - cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (April 18, 2022)

Reading Time: 3 minutes This edition of Top New Cigars highlights a trifecta of flavor-filled boutique blends from Caldwell, Aganorsa Leaf, and Stolen Throne.

Read More
cigar advisor news - camacho unleashed2 cigars release - cover graphic


Reading Time: 2 minutes Camacho Cigars has announced the addition of their second Camacho Factory Unleashed cigars with Factory Unleashed 2. The new cigar is a Toro rolled in a rare Ecuador Connecticut wrapper over a mostly Corojo leaf blend. Learn more about this bold new blend here.

Read More
NewAir 250 Count Electric Cigar Wineador review Cigar Advisor Cover

Cigar Advisor Review: NewAir 250 Count Electric Cigar Humidor Wineador 

Reading Time: 7 minutes If your cigars need a new home, step them up to the penthouse of humidors: we review the new 250 cigar electric humidor wineador from NewAir.

Read More