Cigar Buying Guides

2020 CA Report: Top 5 Best Rated Macanudo Cigars

Reading Time: 5 minutes

Famous Customer Picks: 5 Best Macanudo Cigars 

Macanudo is one of the world’s most famous cigars. Much of its “household name” status is because of the brand’s role as the consummate first-timer smoke; and I’ll bet good money that Macanudo was one of the premium cigars that helped get you into the cigar life. Maybe you even recommended one to someone looking to break in. 

That’s how Macanudo made its bones: for five decades, a mild n’ mellow smoke, that has earned more than its fair share of fans. 

Here’s a Rough, 10-Second History of Macanudo cigars  

Many years ago, “Macanudo” was the name of a certain size Punch cigar. The moniker was later acquired by a Jamaican cigar company; that company was eventually bought by the Cullman family’s General Cigar Company, who updated the Macanudo blend – Dominican, Jamaican and Mexican tobaccos under Connecticut Shade – and introduced it to the US in 1971. Macanudo moved to the Dominican Republic in 2000, and dropped the Jamaican tobacco from the blend along the way. 

Inspirado is a whole different story, and Gary talked in depth with Macanudo’s Laurel Tilley about what went into making that series so much different (we’ll explore a few on this list, too). 

5 Best Top Rated Macanudo Cigars

About Our Top-Rated Picks 

I have spoken out many times on how reviews and ratings should factor into your decision to buy a cigar. I could tell you a cigar is good, but we all taste things differently – so no one can guarantee whether a cigar will live up to its promise. But three different opinions should be enough to tell you if that cigar is in your wheelhouseReviews written by “pros” in blogs and mags are nice, but I find that the best (and most candid) reviews come from our customers: they’re passionate about what they like, loud and clear about what they don’t.  

So, as with all our top-rated cigar guides, we set a baseline of how many of these voices we’ve heard from so far; in this case, a cigar has to have 5 reviews or more to make the cut. 

If you feel there’s a Macanudo missing from our list…don’t just tell us, rate it at famous-smoke.com! Your voice helps others – guiding their decisions, finding hidden gems, or cutting through the clutter to see the cigar for what it really is: a great smoke. 

Macanudo Café Court Tubes – 4.5 Stars – 32 CustomersBest Top Rated Macanudo Cigars Macanudo Cafe Court cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

A time-honored blend known for sweet, nutty, woody character. It’s been consistent for 50 years because no corner has ever been cut on this cigar: Dominican and Mexican long fillers are aged 2 years in Royal Palm bark bales, then finished in Dominican rum barrels. Next comes a genuine U.S. Connecticut shade wrapper leaf that got a special fermentation of its own. Review after review: “great cigar.”  

That’s especially true at this 4 3/16 x 36 size. That small form factor makes Macanudo Court a treat for dogwalkers, easy for beginners to handle, and just…well, snackable. Prefer something bigger? The legendary Macanudo is offered in nearly 20 shapes – but this is the one that rates highest among them all. 

 

Macanudo Inspirado Black Robusto – 4.5 Stars – 22 Customers 

Best Top Rated Macanudo Cigars Macanudo Inspirado Black cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

The Maduro Macanudo made, after disabling the rev limiter. This was on purposeblender/factory guru Jhonys Diaz made the effort to move away from the Dominican-forward blends you might tend to associate with Macanudo. So, his recipe is waaay different, including long fillerfrom Nicaragua’s spiciest growing region (Estelí) and a toothy, stalk-cured Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper grown in the US. Dense smoke flows with pepper and rich earth, along with plenty of sweet (raisins, licorice) and wood. With that many positive reviews, it’s hard to overlook this Robusto 

 

Macanudo Maduro Diplomat – 4.5 Stars – 15 Customers 

Best Top Rated Macanudo Cigars Macanudo Maduro Diplomat cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

If the shape looks familiar, it’s because it’s pretty much the same as the Punch Champion (they’re made in different countries, but Macanudo and Punch share the same parent company). And the tobaccos under the dark, extra-fermented Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper? They’re exactly the same as the super-mellow Macanudo CaféaboveAll it took to achieve such an exquisite, creamy smoke was a wrapper changethat rough-looking maduro is extra fermented, which accentuates the subtle dark sweetness in the leaf. It also handily debunks the “maduros are stronger” fallacy. 

So just as the original Macanudo has been a reliable stepping stone into the cigar world, this may be the open door that moves you over to the Maduro column. 

 

Macanudo Inspirado White Robusto – 4.5 Stars – 14 Customers 

Best Top Rated Macanudo Cigars Macanudo Inspirado White Robusto cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Last time I reviewed this cigar (same size, too), I called it a jump, rather than a step up from the Macanudo Portofinos you’d been tossing in your golf bag all these years. And while these Macanudos are made in the DR too, they have wholeheartedly embraced Nicaragua – the flavors are a little darker, a little heavier. 

That’s because everything that goes into the Macanudo Inspirado White is well-aged: the wrapper has sat idly by for six years; the Mexican San Andres long filler has four years under its belt, the Jalapa got two. Toasty, spicy and stout with a little background sweetness, it’s a Connecticut that you can happily pair with a wider variety of drink and food options. 

 

Macanudo Cru Royale Gigante – 4.5 Stars – 7 CustomersBest Top Rated Macanudo Cigars Macanudo Cru Royale Gigante cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

This was one of the earlier Macanudo cigars to challenge the idea that for it to be Macanudo, it had to be a mild old timer’s smoke. Benji Menendez, blending genius, went shoulder-deep into his bag of exotic tobaccos and came up with a Nicaraguan/Dominican/Mata Fina/Habano concoction that elevates the flavor profile far above your usual Macanudo politeness. This is not to say it’s overly powerful; but the flavors are somewhat…assertive, and that was a shock to some. Admittedly, Cru Royale is not everybody’s cup of tea, but this Gigante has certainly found its niche. 

 

Honorable Mention:

My by Macanudo Toro – 4 Stars – 13 CustomersBest Top Rated Macanudo Cigars M by Macanudo Coffee cigars Toro at famous Smoke Shop

I’m adding a bonus pick because it was thisclose to making the Top 5. And because the praise is high.

Macanudo has always been so…traditional. So, for them to go the flavored cigar route? Talk about taking a chance. But their risk has been the cigar lover’s reward. 

sudden fan favorite, M has a ton of cocoa-y chocolate and vanilla sweetness all whipped together; but the underlying coffee bean taste offers a nice streak of spice for balance. The M is blended with some less commonly used tobaccos than its coffee-flavored counterparts, which really help to solidify the smooth flavor in this slow-burning smokeM by Macanudo also does it without being overbearing, as some other flavored cigars can be. 

4 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Frank Gerechter
2 years ago

I like what you have said. I reviewed several of the cigars on my website too. Have not tried the new Green label yet.
The Red is my favorite in that line.
In 1973, I went to Jamaica and purchased a tin of the Ascots in the original blend from that country. Mild, sweet and one of my first forays into the world of cigars.

Jim Gotts
2 years ago

Love the Macanudo
…Should they be removed from the tubes to prevent drying

Editor
Gary Korb
2 years ago
Reply to  Jim Gotts

Good questions. Not necessarily. The tubes are not hermetically airtight. One thing you can do is remove the cap of the tube and put it aside. This way the cigar gets more air and is fully protected. Replace the cap when you’re ready to take the cigar out with you to a lounge, friend’s house, etc.
G-~

Bob Cestaro
12 days ago

I smoke Ascots some times I get a tin where 2 or 3 are not rolled properly. Hardd to draw. This happens quite often. Wish there was a little more quality control with this problem.

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
cigar advisor news - ep carrillo and oliva cigars introduce allegiance cigars - release - cover

Cigar News: E.P. Carrillo & Oliva Cigars Introduce Allegiance Cigars

Reading Time: 2 minutes In another fine cigar collaboration, top-rated E.P. Carrillo Cigars has joined forces with Oliva Cigar Co. in Nicaragua to create Allegiance Cigars. The four vitola selection was blended by Ernesto Perez-Carrillo using tobaccos from Oliva’s finest stocks. Get the full story here.

Read More
cigar advisor top 5 best-rated camacho cigars - cover

2022 CA Report: Top 5 Best-Rated Camacho Cigars

Reading Time: 4 minutes We talk about cigars for a living, but when it comes to what’s best, we wanna hear what you have to say. That’s why our Top-Rated series focuses on customer reviews only. See the list of consumer picks and discover Camacho’s best rated cigars!

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review powstanie wojtek 2021 - cover

#NowSmoking: Powstanie Wojtek (War Bear) 2021

Reading Time: 4 minutes Did you know that a bear served with the Polish army in WWII? It’s a story that inspired Powstanie to create Wojtek 2021. See the full cigar review video now to see if it’s right for your taste buds.

Read More
Drew Estate Puros Huerfanos cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

CA Review Panel: Drew Estate Puros Huerfanos Cigar Review (Video)

Reading Time: 7 minutes Puros Huérfanos is a new incarnation of a previously released Willy Herrera blend. What makes this particular review unique is that each review panelist smoked a different size. Find out if the difference between all three shapes was remarkably close or worlds apart.

Read More